6 ms·
Is It Time to Stop Filming Strangers in Public?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- exabrial 2y agoyes, absolutely.
- JKCalhoun 2y ago> These videos often rack up millions of views which is proof that there is “clearly an appetite to watch as strangers are shamed, ridiculed, gawked, or generally caught off-guard, even when we know it isn’t exactly morally sound.” This is has been a pretty hot topic since Allen Funt kicked off his little gig in 1948. As much as I personally like to people-watch, I don't think it's cool to share but I also don't think you can rein it in. I suppose I tell myself that the more people do it, the less embarrassing it becomes. Yeah, yeah, people of Walmart, ha, ha ... okay moving on....
- mariodiana 2y ago"Candid Camera" required people to sign a release for the scene to be aired, no?
- Suzuran 2y agoYes, but only because the footage was being used commercially for broadcast. Depending on who was doing the filming they may also have been required to pay the subject; For example, a person who accidentally entered an active shoot of a Hollywood movie encountered the actors and had a short conversation with them. The footage turned out to work well with the scene, and the director wanted to keep it. In order to do so, not only did they have to pay this person and give them credit for a speaking role, they had to be given membership in the Screen Actors' Guild.
- ghaff 2y agoAnd of course, at the time, publishing was pretty much synonymous with commercial publishing. (Though newspapers, magazines, news broadcasts, etc. have had broad exemptions for editorial publication in the US.)
- giantg2 2y ago"but only because the footage was being used commercially for broadcast." Influencer is now a job. They make money off of sponsorship. Even if they aren't currently making money or taking sponsors they are generating goodwill towards their brand, which does have monetary value as denoted on balance sheets and can be used to future commercial value.
- pimlottc 2y ago> For example, a person who accidentally entered an active shoot of a Hollywood movie encountered the actors and had a short conversation with them. The footage turned out to work well with the scene, and the director wanted to keep it. In order to do so, not only did they have to pay this person and give them credit for a speaking role, they had to be given membership in the Screen Actors' Guild. Did this actually happen or are you speaking hypothetically?
- Suzuran 2y agoIt happened but I don't remember which movie. It's not the often-quoted Star Trek instance - In that case, the woman was a first-time extra who was not aware that extras are not supposed to speak, even when directed to "act natural". In the case I am thinking of, they forgot to rope off a park entrance or something like that, and someone who regularly went there just did their usual thing and blundered into an active shoot.
- JKCalhoun 2y agoMy recollection (and I'm old but not that old) is there was nonetheless a lot of uneasiness by the viewing public as to whether watching, regardless of whether the person later signed a release, was in itself a bit of guilty voyeurism. That the whole concept of the show was in poor taste— catching people off guard and vulnerable. EDIT: and because I can't not share, this funny clip of Woody Allen on the show: https://youtu.be/LGb_jzaUWOg https://youtu.be/LGb_jzaUWOg
- pfdietz 2y agoOh, it was a big issue since the invention of still photography that was sufficiently fast to capture moving people in public. In practice, controls on photography or filming in public would be used to suppress recording of those in power, such as police. It's quite proper that the right to take such images be protected. Attempting to exempt commercial efforts from these protections would be like exempting commercial news organizations from protection under the 1st amendment.
- jsjohnst 2y agoI think a reasonable outcome would be to make a distinction between incidental recording (I have a camera recording Times Square and happen to pass you) as opposed to direct recording (as in you are the subject of what I’m recording). It’s definitely a grey area still, but would help if we want to apply limits on this type of content.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ryandrake 2y agoIt would be really hard to prove in court that someone's picture of you was direct vs incidental, especially with how good cameras are. In a few years time, if I wanted to illegally take a "direct" picture of someone I was creeping on or stalking, or just film something that would embarrass someone, I'll be able to whip out my 100 gigapixel camera and take a benign picture/video of the overall area and simply crop the subject later.
- eqvinox 2y agoJust for reference, what they're describing is already illegal in Germany, and by the first two articles of the constitution no less. (DE: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recht_am_eigenen_Bild_(Deutschland) https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recht_am_eigenen_Bild_(Deutsch... - no english version of this wikipedia article sadly) (You are not allowed to publish¹ photos or film specific/individual people without their consent. This is only abated when individual people are not the focus of photographing/recording, i.e. crowds or random stragglers in photos of other things.) ¹ edit/correction: this originally said "take" rather than "publish". The legal limits relevant here are on publishing, not taking photos/filming.
- Rinzler89 2y agoSame in Austria. You aren't allowed to film people in public without their consent. This is overall a positive but it comes with many downsides as well like if you want to get evidence on someone doing something wrong or screwing you over.
- ghaff 2y agoAnd how many photos of clearly-identifiable people in those countries do you suppose get published to the internet every hour?
- eqvinox 2y ago"clearly-identifiable" is not the criteria, it's a question of focus and respect. The articles of constitution this is based on in Germany read (roughly): "(1.) Human dignity is inviolable. (2.) Everyone has the right to free expression of their personality, so long they do not infringe on others." You can publish photos with identifiable people as much as you want, as long as the intent of the photo is not to capture one (or more) person specifically.
- ghaff 2y agoPeople take photos of other (unconnected) people who are the primary focus of photographs all the time--and publish them. Maybe they're not supposed to in some countries even in public but they do with great frequency.
- matsemann 2y agoI bicycle with a camera to protect myself. I'd prefer the rules to be around publishing (which they already are where I live).
- mobiuscog 2y agoThat's a good compromise, until you consider stalkers and/or Scientologists.
- matsemann 2y agoBut that would go under other laws already.
- jraph 2y agoOkay but include "storing on someone else's computer" in the definition of "publishing" in this case. I don't want to be recorded and uploaded to Google or Dropbox without my consent. Although it's not totally satisfying: a record can leak. No record is the only guarantee for no leak.
- boffinAudio 2y ago"Publishing" means making something available to the public. It does not mean making my own copy of something.
- jraph 2y agoI know. Let me rephrase my comment: I think the publishing restriction of the law is not quite enough, also make "storing your private copy on Google Drive or Dropbox" illegal. If you store your private copy on Google and Dropbox, you are not publishing it but you are sharing it with them. And I don't trust them. They could for instance decide to train models on my image or fulfill requests from law enforcement and my data gets somehow involved and I don't want them to. I believe the law could have been written at a time when the cloud was not common, and just restricting publication was enough. It isn't anymore IMHO.
- rendall 2y agoThe article headline is about filming people in public but most of the video examples are not in public, but private spaces like gyms, pubs or work places. These are not the same thing.
- eqvinox 2y agoDepends on the country/legal system, but most would consider at least pubs a public place. Gyms possibly as well, sometimes even more so than workplaces (because it's much harder to become an employee somewhere than it is to sign up for a gym.)
- ghaff 2y agoGyms feel more problematic--even outside of locker rooms. And companies tendnot to be too big on photographs of workplaces generally. Pubs, music festivals, neighborhood BBQs, etc. seem a lot more natural as long as you aren't being obnoxious or someone asks you to stop.
- giantg2 2y agoThis is pretty much covered by civil law. You can sue for commercial use of your image. After all, influencer is now a desired job and you can make money doing it. There may be some scenarios we're the person doesn't make money from sponsors and seeing could be more difficult, but technically goodwill is listed on balance sheets, so if theyre generating public goodwill towards their brand, there's still a basis. If you're a focus of the content, you can sue.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Someone1234 2y agoYou CAN sue, but you won't, because no lawyer will take the case and the potential gains in most cases don't pay for the filing fees let alone discourage the behavior. So with a few exceptions, videos like this go largely unchecked because the current system we have is too inefficient at these low financial levels.
- giantg2 2y agoYou can always find a lawyer willing to take the case, as long as you're paying money and not on contingency. Even if you make the recording or publishing illegal the cops aren't really going to do anything for such a low level offense, especially with such high volumes. In either scenario, it's mostly a function of selective enforcement and intimidation.
- Suzuran 2y agoI think the line should be drawn when there is a commercial interest - If the footage is monetized, the subject should have a veto. Other than that, it should not be prohibited for members of the public to make a recording of anyone's conduct in a public space, because to prohibit that would enable bad actors to harm others without possibility of being held responsible. For example, imagine if it were illegal to make recordings of the Proud Boys in places where law enforcement actively encouraged them to commit criminal acts...
- smnrg 2y agoNo, it's not time to stop taking photos of strangers because capturing a public moment is called documentary, reportage, and also is an art practiced for a century or more by the likes of Cartier-Bresson and Martin Parr. And it's a journalist's ethical duty, or even a citizen's, important in case of abuse of power, such as murdering by law enforcement forces in certain countries. However, it's important to dismantle platforms that reward engagement based on voyeurism and cruelty towards strangers for the purpose of advertising, such as the cases described in the article. So no, unless stop taking film and photos of strangers means disabling all the security cameras that constantly intrude in our lives in public spaces to analyze data unilaterally. Which is what would remain.
- rurban 2y agoLike with every other film/photo professional they need signed releases from all people on their images, to be used later. Or they will be taken to court by someone sooner or later. Nothing to worry about too much. Same as using Beatles songs in videos. Which will cost you about $20.000 - $80.000 Biggest problem is that "influencers" have no formal education in publishing and copyright law. This is what we learned in film class in the very first week. But staying a free, not-regulated occupation is more important imho.
- eqvinox 2y agoDo you have any context what legal framework the "release" mechanism is coming from? Is it copyright? Trademark (to your own likeness)? General right to photos showing you?
- ghaff 2y agoIn the US, "commercial use" specifically--as in marketing, advertising, etc.--typically requires a model release from of a person (and stock agencies tend to err on the side of caution in this regard). As I understand it, it's basically a right not to have your image commercially exploited. As I also understand it though, it doesn't keep me from making money as a fine art poster or selling it to a newspaper for editorial use. Obviously there are gray areas. But it's not copyright. As the photographer I hold the copyright in any case.
- rurban 2y agoCopyright and privacy rights 99%. Trademarks certainly not.
- _yb2s 2y agoAs a dad that does a lot of outdoor adventures with my young son... apparently there is something cute or interesting looking about us, and strangers literally crowd around us snapping photos almost everytime we go out. Maybe half ask first, but when I say no they often try to argue "it's just a picture!" I am a very private person and don't put photos of myself or my family online at all, in any capacity, but there are tons of photos of us posted online by strangers against our will- I confirmed this via an AI facial recognition search engine. My son is also often the only non-white kid in schools, summer camps, etc. so they want to use his photo on all of the advertising, billboards, newsletters, etc. usually without permission, and they act indignant when I stop them from doing so. Apparently it's all the rage to brag that your overpriced summercamp once had a non-white person enroll, and prominently use photos of them on everything forever. Leave us alone!
- bluefirebrand 2y agoI've found that people who are serious about photography tend to behave in a way that is exactly legal but still extremely annoying. They're relatively harmless (after all "it's just a picture!") but the behavior is still a public nuisance A few years ago I read a similar anecdote of a woman being accosted by a photographer on transit, taking photos of the baby she was carrying and persisting even after asked to stop. She wound up having to physically shield herself and the baby from being photographed and the guy kept taking other shots every chance he got, like when she was leaving the train and such. Super rude, but technically legal. This was in Alberta, for those who care It really made me think we need different laws about consent in photography. Surely we can carve out exceptions for photographing notable events, documenting crimes, crowd shots and other such valid reasons for photographing someone without consent, without allowing a rando with a camera to pester (and arguably intimidate) people just going about their day Edit: There was also a case a few years ago of a guy going around taking creepshots of women, their butts and cleavage and such and publishing them. That was clearly illegal so we already do have some rules about public photography that is allowed and some that isn't.
- ryandrake 2y ago> A few years ago I read a similar anecdote of a woman being accosted by a photographer on transit, taking photos of the baby she was carrying and persisting even after asked to stop. She wound up having to physically shield herself and the baby from being photographed and the guy kept taking other shots every chance he got, like when she was leaving the train and such. Super rude, but technically legal. I think there's a line somewhere between "being annoying/rude/obnoxious" and "politely refusing to stop recording." You can see this when you look at a few different "First Amendment Auditor" content creators. Some of them are obviously obnoxious, belligerent, and clearly looking for conflict. Others just quietly keep recording, politely but firmly ignoring the subject's (often themselves annoying) demands for them to stop. I don't have any problem whatsoever with the latter behavior. The former is kind of cheap and trashy, even if it's still legal.
- mellosouls 2y agoThere are at least two different issues here, and it is a shame that they often seem conflated: 1. Filming without consent in public. 2. Uploading the media without consent of the subjects to social media or other public platform, or private channels with multiple participants. I have no problem with the former - as others have pointed out, there is a long history of doing this in the name of art, documentation etc. Asking for consent just isn't often feasible in advance. The latter though seems to me to be deeply unethical in principle, though there may be exceptions. It is the exposure to the view of others (often with intent to ridicule or shame) that seems to be the invasion of privacy and the aspect with significant potential to hurt.
- Workaccount2 2y agoMy seemingly controversial take on this: No one cares that you appear in a video on tiktok. No one. Content saturation is so intense than anyone who witnesses your generic human self for 6 seconds in a video short is going to have completely forgotten about it in the next 6 seconds. Yes, for you the main character, it might feel like an egregious transgression. A victim of the ruthless paparazzi. But you are not that important, and are indistinguishable from the tens of thousands of other public wanderers who crop up in these videos. Besides, they are supposed to have you sign a release form anyway.
- underseacables 2y agoWould this not also include filming people committing violence and crime? Police? Politicians? It's kind of impossible to draw the line between "illegal photography" and legitimate citizen journalism.
- reify 2y agoThe brain dead single cell mulluscs of Airstrip One love it. CCTV everywhere, the most CCTV surveilled country in the world. If its not on their phones its on their doorbells I dont do it and I dont tolerate it. I love Germany. No CCTV allowed in public places or by the general public. This is how privacy should be enacted
- naveen99 2y agoAren’t self driving cars necessarily filming everything in front of them all the time ?