3 ms·
It's incredible how short-sighted and an echo-chamber HN has become. The comments to this article are of zero-substance and just re-writes of talking points pus
by BoiledCabbage 2y ago
It's incredible how short-sighted and an echo-chamber HN has become. The comments to this article are of zero-substance and just re-writes of talking points pushed out a hundred times.
A bunch of straw-man arguments ("See they argued in support of the risks of something I don't care about or think is important, therefore there are no risks at all").
False motivations ("It's just OpenAI trying to capture the market"), while almost 70% of the people signing the letter don't work for OpenAI.
Absolutely absurd thoughts: "Do they want to be working on something capable of 'human extinction'?"
And from people who supposedly work in tech, but somehow are suddenly incapable of grasping the difference in scale of impact that automating something for extremely low cost has on society. "We always had these risks in society, so this is nothing new". Completely ignoring the difference in for example having to travel to to basement archives of every small town in the country to read through papers to research something vs having all of that information at the tips of your fingers.
I don't think I've ever read any set of responses on HN that I've been more disappointed in. And not necessarily because I disagree with them, but because of how little critical thought when into them.
I think there will be a time where we'll look back at comments like these in response to this concern as being absolutely painfully naive.
- reducesuffering 2y agoNo doubt that the majority opinion scoffing at AI risk here is going to look very poorly in a couple years as the reality dawns on them and HN realizes how behind the curve it’s getting. Which is sad, because HN was overall prescient about social media and Facebook’s problems a decade ago, which bear some relation. I’m not sure the cause, but HN is clearly getting worse on the frontier of broad specialties (AI, frontend dev, econ) whenever one has extensive domain knowledge in them. The amount of scoffing at OpenAI since inception almost a decade ago, is wild, as they continuously flew by the expectations here… the old threads did not age well and they’re not on track to now either
- jazzyjackson 2y agoHN is specifically patronized by people who are not busy
- asp_hornet 2y agoYeah, like all those short sighted bitcoin naysayers. Sometimes overhyped tech is just over hyped tech.