4 ms·
>- The delay was caused initially by a safety critical instrument being recognized as faulty, which required the airline to seek a replacement aircraft. This wa
by gruez 2y ago
>- The delay was caused initially by a safety critical instrument being recognized as faulty, which required the airline to seek a replacement aircraft. This was deemed out of control of the airline, with subsequent staffing and catering issues cascading (in airline's control).
Looking at the government's site[1] it looks like you're only owed compensation for "flight delays or cancellations that are in their control and not related to safety", so at least with respect to the first delay it's safe to say that the CTA was correct in ruling against you in this case. The second part (ie. "staffing and catering issues cascading (in airline's control)") is in a legal gray zone and I could see it argued either way. For instance, if a flight was 6 hours due to safety issues, and then as a result they're not able to get a flight crew, because they're not expecting a flight to occur at that time, that's arguably caused by the safety issue rather than "in airline's control".
>- CTA made no acknowledgement of the claims that 1) Air Canada did not inform passengers the nature or possible length of delay, 2) did not offer any rebooking, accommodation, or food/drink during extended layover, and 3) the Regulations Amending the Air Passenger Protections Regulations (https://otc-cta.gc.ca/eng/content/new-refund-regulations-now-force https://otc-cta.gc.ca/eng/content/new-refund-regulations-now...) which requires the airline to at least communicate but in many cases offer reimbursement regardless of whether an incident is in or out of their control.
My interpretation here is that if the airline fails to do those things, they're in violation of the regulation and are liable to pay fines to the regulator, but it doesn't say that the passengers are entitled to compensation. At best you could argue that as a result of those delays you had to buy food/transportation/accommodation, submit receipts, and argue that the airline should compensate you for those expenses. I don't think it's something where if they failed to do something, you can straight up demand $$$ as compensation.
>they had simply alerted passengers what was happening and what to expect then I would've arranged a pick up in advance
I think you're overestimating how much the airline knew. If it's a random mechanical issue it's plausible that even they didn't know how long the repairs would take. Same with the staffing/catering issues afterwards.
>or requested that we catch a flight the next day
The regulations does mention "once a delay reaches 3 hours, an airline must also offer alternate travel arrangements in the same class of service and using a reasonable route", but it's unclear whether if the next flight leaves in 12 hours and the delay is 7 hours, whether you can arbitrarily rebook to any flight you want. Moreover, it's possible that the next flight is also full and you can't change to that.
>Well, yes, I'm making a comment on the internet about my negative experience with Air Canada and CTA in about 15 minutes. The claim itself had all the information and took hours to compile, I'm not sure how long it would take for me to simplify that point by point without still missing something.
I mean, as mentioned in the above paragraphs, whether you're entitled to a claim hinges on the cause of the delay, so it's fair to expect that this at least gets a passing mention.
[1] https://otc-cta.gc.ca/eng/air-passenger-protection-regulations-highlights https://otc-cta.gc.ca/eng/air-passenger-protection-regulatio...
- voxic11 2y agoHe is entitled to a refund but not compensation. What you linked applies to compensation beyond a refund which you are right he is not entitled to but he never claimed he was. > If the situation is within the airline's control, but required for safety purposes > Airlines' obligations to you include: > standards of treatment; and > completion of your itinerary or a refund. https://rppa-appr.ca/eng/obligations-and-level-control https://rppa-appr.ca/eng/obligations-and-level-control
- ics 2y agoIt was a little tricky because they do actually request that you provide all relevant information and then a narrative for how they relate to the claim. From my reading of the regulations, I should be eligible for EITHER a partial refund on each ticket due to the delay (CAD$700 each) OR reimbursement for itemized expenses. I reiterated in the narrative that I felt as though we were due one or the other depending on how CTA ruled on the original situation causing delay and Air Canada's handling of it (not providing adequate notification, etc.). I tried not to double dip, ended up (almost) empty.
- ics 2y agoRead that page again. The link you put in [1] also includes the link to the "New refund regulations" (which is what I linked). Reading the Introduction paragraph, it sounds like the page is from 2019 and has not been updated to reflect the new regulations; the newer one should be read and considered in addition. I itemized all receipts and even had to provide USD/CAD/JPY conversion on every single one but funny enough the only thing which did get reimbursed, the stroller, was based on the current Amazon CA price for the similar model. In the section where you provide documentation you can provide a narrative, which I did along the lines of "I would request the maximum compensation based on my interpretation of X-Y-Z but be satisfied with the minimum reimbursement for itemized additional expense". Sure, the CAD$700 per passenger that the APPR mentions would be nice but the taxi ride seemed obvious? I figured it's one or the other because the point of reimbursement is to cover those extra things without putting the burden of receipts and claims on the customer. I also noted that in the APPR it states "If the situation is within the airline's control (whether or not it's related to safety)" which led me to question what makes a safety issue in or not in the airline's control? I imagine this is common knowledge to those involved but again, would've found the judgement more credible if my question/claim had been addressed directly. > I think you're overestimating how much the airline knew. They submitted documentation showing that they were aware of the issue ~2hrs before our scheduled departure. From there, I think there are many reasonable steps they could have taken all of which are not pretend it's a catering issue while holding people in the airport for 6+ hours after scheduled departure and offering no assistance whatsoever. I tend to approach these sorts of issues with very little expectation that my interpretation is right (even if it is reasonable), that I'm owed anything, or that other parties will do any more than uphold the minimum required of them. Still, it did not increase my confidence in CTA helping consumers when airlines somehow do not fulfill their own obligations.