3 ms·

Something to consider: when you remove the female body from the definition of woman, what else remains besides sexist feminine stereotypes? More to the point,

Something to consider: when you remove the female body from the definition of woman, what else remains besides sexist feminine stereotypes? More to the point, when a male says he identifies as a woman, what exactly is he identifying with? You can't identify with a organs you don't have, so what could he actually be identifying with, if not sexist feminine stereotypes? And how is it progressive to say that a man who identifies with feminine stereotypes is a woman? Is it not more progressive to say that a man who identifies with feminine stereotypes is simply a feminine man?

fao_ 2y ago
> Something to consider: when you remove the female body from the definition of woman, what else remains besides sexist feminine stereotypes? Any definition of woman that includes all cis women must include all trans women, or will otherwise include trans men. Fertility? Many women are infertile. Chromosomes? There is at least one genetic line of women in the world where they were all identified at birth as women and have each given birth, but have XY chromosomes. Anecdotally, many universities have had to stop genetics students from testing themselves for their chromosomes as a fun thing to do on the weekend, because the incident rate of chirality is MUCH higher than you would otherwise expect. Any other such metrics either end up becoming pure phrenology or excluding massive amounts (millions) of women. Moreover, trans women do not "identify with female stereotypes" and they are often most often strongly aligned with cis women who break stereotypes, cis women who are also largely targeted by the bathroom bills you are in favour of. The science says that being transgender isn't purely social and cannot be fixed through therapy, please avail yourself of the cult[0] that you are a part of. Thank you for your time. [0]: https://beaudyess.medium.com/ https://beaudyess.medium.com/
- 123yawaworht456 2y ago
  >or will otherwise include trans men. correctly so.
- irkvatjbzna 2y ago
  So what are these males identifying with then?

fao_ 2y ago

> Something to consider: when you remove the female body from the definition of woman, what else remains besides sexist feminine stereotypes? Any definition of woman that includes all cis women must include all trans women, or will otherwise include trans men. Fertility? Many women are infertile. Chromosomes? There is at least one genetic line of women in the world where they were all identified at birth as women and have each given birth, but have XY chromosomes. Anecdotally, many universities have had to stop genetics students from testing themselves for their chromosomes as a fun thing to do on the weekend, because the incident rate of chirality is MUCH higher than you would otherwise expect. Any other such metrics either end up becoming pure phrenology or excluding massive amounts (millions) of women. Moreover, trans women do not "identify with female stereotypes" and they are often most often strongly aligned with cis women who break stereotypes, cis women who are also largely targeted by the bathroom bills you are in favour of. The science says that being transgender isn't purely social and cannot be fixed through therapy, please avail yourself of the cult[0] that you are a part of. Thank you for your time. [0]: https://beaudyess.medium.com/ https://beaudyess.medium.com/

123yawaworht456 2y ago
>or will otherwise include trans men. correctly so.
irkvatjbzna 2y ago
So what are these males identifying with then?