4 ms·

I think this is a relatively niche product. Most people aren’t using so many apps and extensions that their menu bar is getting crowded with stuff.

garciasn 2y ago
I haven’t seen a single Mac user on screen share that doesn’t have too many icons on their bar for me. I want to see almost none. For all of Apple’s insistence on design and clean, the menu bar and those hideous icons always there was the worst one ever. I’ve been a Bartender user for over 10 years (I believe 12) and I’m now really fucking sad.
- LeoPanthera 2y ago
  > I haven’t seen a single Mac user on screen share that doesn’t have too many icons on their bar for me. This says more about app devs than it does about users.
  - pxc 2y ago
    Apple devs as well as application developers— menu bar icons are clearly a neglected corner of the ecosystem in that Apple would prefer that app devs not persist icons in the menu bar at all. But the feature is nonetheless wildly popular as the nearest systray-alike functionality on macOS.
  - hombre_fatal 2y ago
    Not really. Even in the case where every single app has a good reason to have a menu bar icon, but you're still left with the fact that macOS doesn't let you manage them.
    - pxc 2y ago
      Or maybe they don't all have a good reason but you don't really have a choice about running them (e.g., on your work computer). If you are visually impaired, you also likely have greatly reduced space for those icons, especially when undocked. (This issue plagues me personally.) In that case, this is not merely a clutter issue: app icons will simply be truncated from the menu bar, and in some cases that may mean that some functionality is just totally inaccessible to you.
JoeMattiello 2y ago
It’s included in the SetApp bundle and a highly rated and recommended app on there. It’s not that niche especially for developers and power users that gravitate towards SetApp subscription. For me, I was already paying for “clean my Mac” and fantastical which both cost the same or more than a SetApp subscription which includes dozens of additional apps.

garciasn 2y ago

I haven’t seen a single Mac user on screen share that doesn’t have too many icons on their bar for me. I want to see almost none. For all of Apple’s insistence on design and clean, the menu bar and those hideous icons always there was the worst one ever. I’ve been a Bartender user for over 10 years (I believe 12) and I’m now really fucking sad.

LeoPanthera 2y ago
> I haven’t seen a single Mac user on screen share that doesn’t have too many icons on their bar for me. This says more about app devs than it does about users.
- pxc 2y ago
  Apple devs as well as application developers— menu bar icons are clearly a neglected corner of the ecosystem in that Apple would prefer that app devs not persist icons in the menu bar at all. But the feature is nonetheless wildly popular as the nearest systray-alike functionality on macOS.
- hombre_fatal 2y ago
  Not really. Even in the case where every single app has a good reason to have a menu bar icon, but you're still left with the fact that macOS doesn't let you manage them.
  - pxc 2y ago
    Or maybe they don't all have a good reason but you don't really have a choice about running them (e.g., on your work computer). If you are visually impaired, you also likely have greatly reduced space for those icons, especially when undocked. (This issue plagues me personally.) In that case, this is not merely a clutter issue: app icons will simply be truncated from the menu bar, and in some cases that may mean that some functionality is just totally inaccessible to you.

JoeMattiello 2y ago

It’s included in the SetApp bundle and a highly rated and recommended app on there. It’s not that niche especially for developers and power users that gravitate towards SetApp subscription. For me, I was already paying for “clean my Mac” and fantastical which both cost the same or more than a SetApp subscription which includes dozens of additional apps.