9 ms·
Some notes on influenceering
- emmanueloga_ 2y ago> early on, it plays tricks with your mind — what if I’m really as clueless as they say? > What stings far more is when you get no reaction whatsoever Wow, even someone like lcamtuf can feel like this sometimes. This guy is the author of super-awesome stuff like "The Tangled Web" book, the "Guerrilla guide to CNC" and the "american fuzzy lop" software. Definitely, his work is the kind of content that makes the internet 1000 times better!
- ipython 2y agoI still remember being in awe of his paper on strange attractors - plotting the random number generators from various oses and languages in 3D space to discern patterns. That blew my mind at the time. Edit: ah here it is. It was initial tcp sequence number generators: https://lcamtuf.coredump.cx/oldtcp/tcpseq.html https://lcamtuf.coredump.cx/oldtcp/tcpseq.html
- ImaCake 2y agoThat's an amazing piece of work. Even in a quick skim I picked up a lot of new ideas which speaks to how well the author can explain tricky concepts!
- pclmulqdq 2y agoHaving done some blogging that I need to get back to, I have to agree with you that follower counts are mostly worthless. Platforms like Twitter and YouTube end up with hugely inflated numbers compared to your actual audience. A fantastic following is 1000 people who really care. A million random YouTube subscribers might have that.
- skilled 2y agoThe problem is that communities got replaced by algorithms who think on your behalf. The algorithm is by definition random, and yet for countless years now it is how most social media sites, including popular developer communities, operate. In the era of the feed and timeline, nobody bothers to check “Following” when you have “Recommended” enabled by default. The former requires effort, while the latter gives a false sense of reality. Every refresh it is something new and exciting, every time. A never ending loop of joy and happiness. Who knows… one day the algorithm could even show you in front of the entire world!
- boredemployee 2y ago>> In the era of the feed and timeline, nobody bothers to check “Following” when you have “Recommended” enabled by default. That's something I really hate and I feel pretty dumb that I found just some weeks ago that I can change X's feed to show me the posts people who I follow. I wonder if that's true for instagram as well because I can't stand to see random posts anymore. To be honest, I'm getting tired of it. i.e: I'm really enjoying going to a record shop to listen to music instead of spotify crap. the serendipity is real
- soulofmischief 2y agoAs a counterpoint, I feel like my experience with platforms such as bandcamp, YouTube, private trackers, etc. replicate much of the serendipity of a record shop, while vastly increasing discoverability. I love going into a record shop as much as the next guy, but I do find that I discover more new things which actually stick via the internet. I also find that I am able to rely more on network-based algorithms for discoverability if the community is well-aligned. Even better if I can navigate myself when the underlying data is exposed via similarity maps, tags and other hypertext. Recommendation algorithms we see on corporate social platforms (Spotify included) generally suck because the underlying data is not exposed to the user. That would be bad for ad revenue. These platforms enjoy the profound level of mind control which they employ towards their users, and are loathe to surrender it.
- immibis 2y agoIf a chronological feed of everyone you follow is what you want, you'll love the Fediverse because it has so little algorithm that it's actually a flaw. Although, if you follow lots of people, a chronological feed is still just "random posts", because they are the ones that happened to get posted just before you looked at the feed. A customized feed would be better - some way to up-weight insightful posts and down-weight memes.
- righthand 2y agoIsn’t it just automated channel flipping, but instead of isolated display space per channel, instead the channels are conglomerated together into an endless feed? A never ending loop isn’t intended to bring joy and happiness and that’s why it fails. It is however intended to remove control from the controller.
- dinkleberg 2y agoThe best thing I've learned about "influenceering" is to stop thinking you're hot shit and focus on being useful (or entertaining if that is what you're about). Years ago I was pumping content out all the time and I was just creating the content for the sake of creating it. Consequently, the content was mostly pointless and garbage. If you want to treat your social media as a public journal that is cool, but not likely to make you an influencer. If your goal is to grow a following, you've gotta be empathetic towards your audience and create what they want to see. If you're trying to entertain, make sure you're actually entertaining. Or if like me you're educating, make sure you're actually educating. It seems completely obvious, yet when you're doing it, its easy to lose sight of the mission. Once I "removed myself" from the equation and just focused on what is actually useful to my intended audience things improved tremendously.
- zackproser 2y agoThis is helpful - thank you for sharing. I've been down a mental rabbit hole lately and reached similar conclusions.
- zackproser 2y agoAnd, for what it's worth, I also share because I love building things and learning. I taught myself how to code using free resources online, so it felt perfectly natural to publish and open-source everything I figured out. I also wouldn't mind eventually making some money off delivering reliable value to others.
- bawolff 2y ago> If you want to treat your social media as a public journal that is cool, but not likely to make you an influencer I think the key trick is you need to be interesting. A public journal can be for some people but probably not most. I'm interested in a public journal of someone in the top of their field, thinking deep thoughts and explaining how they see the world. I'm not interested in a public journal that amounts to: today i bought groceries and binged netflix.
- immibis 2y ago
- luu 2y ago> Some of my most popular posts are throwaway quips and memes that went viral on social media. One of my life’s crowning achievements is this: [witty, throwaway, quip tweet]. > In contrast, some of the work I put weeks or months into essentially lost the SEO game and gets nearly zero traffic ... Even though I don’t write for money, there is an immense pressure to produce clickbait — even if simply to add “hey, since you’re here, check out this serious thing”. This will be different for different people, but I've noticed a moderately strong negative correlation between how much effort I put into something and how much engagement it gets (this seems likely to be different for people who apply their effort to generating engagement). The highest engagement content content of mine tends to be thoughtless social media comments I make without thinking. Something like https://danluu.com/ftc-google-antitrust/ https://danluu.com/ftc-google-antitrust/, which summarizes 300+ pages of FTC memos and is lucky to get 10% of the traffic of a throwaway comment and is more likely to get < 0.1% of the traffic of a high-engagement throwaway comment. Of course there's a direct effect, in that a thoughtless joke has appeal to a larger number of people than a deep dive into anything, but algorithmic feeds really magnify this effect because they'll cause the thoughtless joke to be shown to orders of magnitude more people so something with a 10x difference in appeal will end up with, say, a 1000x difference in traffic on average and even more in the tail. I don't think this is unique to tech content either. For example, I see this with YouTube channels as well — in every genre or niche that I follow, the most informative content doesn't has fairly low reach and the highest engagement content leans heavily on entertainment value and isn't very informative.
- Swizec 2y ago> the most informative content doesn't has fairly low reach and the highest engagement content leans heavily on entertainment value Same observation here. I think it's because these channels are optimized for people looking to be entertained, not looking to be informed. There's an impedance mismatch between high value content and what people want while doomscrolling on the couch at 8pm or while on a coffee break at work.
- Forgeties79 2y agoMy gut says - and this is very much gut - that throwaway content/posts probably tend to be comedic, and sometimes we just strike comedy gold. One good, funny sentence can ripple very quickly.
- gowld 2y agoSurely that throwaway "computer science" tweet only went viral because lcamtuf was already famous and had a high follower count because of their previous, substantial work.
- TeMPOraL 2y agoVery good observation, and I strongly agree. A person's shitposting reads differently when they have some name recognition in the audience. Especially that of an expert - I find myself looking into deeper meaning in a throwaway comment that I wouldn't even notice if it came from some random Internet user.
- ImaCake 2y agoHim making this joke is also a product of his expertise. Like, it takes at least some experience to have the insight and then be able to communicate it in a pithy way.
- JohnMakin 2y agoCan relate to a lot of this as a very small content creator that has been doing it for fun for over 10 years. On online weirdos - this is very much a thing. You can pick up weirdly persistent stalkers and haters and it can be exhausting and sometimes scary. For me, I do it for fun. I find it very frustrating to have conversations with followers/viewers that are wanting me to do $thing and why don't I open subs to $monetize blah blah and I explain that while I do enjoy putting out content, at the end of the day this is for my enjoyment and there is zero chance I can make as much as I do from it as my day job, so I don't. It's very frustrating and a sad state of affairs that people can't seem to grasp the idea of making content for the sake of making content. That's how the early internet was, no one was getting paid, and it put out arguably some of the best there has been. Regarding hosting/seo stuff, I always let platforms like twitch, meta, YT, etc. manage that for me rather than wrangling SEO hell, but I acknowledge the video space is a bit different than the blog space. For the writing I do, I wouldn't dream of self hosting for the reasons he describes.
- zackproser 2y ago+1 - I picked up my first semi-stalker / email harasser recently from blogging and sending out a newsletter about apps I build and open-source. Pretty weird experience.
- paulpauper 2y agobut otherwise, it’s OK to write about what excites you, and to do it as you learn.” yeah, but what if no one else cares what you write about or it does not gain traction
- QuantumG 2y agoNot everyone cares about that.
- jwr 2y agoSo what? You care. That's what matters.
- exitb 2y agoIf the lack of traction takes away from your excitement or ability to learn, it best to just skip writing. It’s fine to do fun stuff just for the sake of it, no need to justify it by getting an audience.
- _xiaz 2y ago[dead]
- baby 2y ago> #1: It’s still a chore just use a static site if you can. I think I’m also stuck with an old stack and don’t have the time to move to a static site and I’ve been paying the price for years. All my new stuff is static, pushed on github, deployed by cloudflare pages. Worst was when a linux upgrade deleted a bunch of user content, fortunately I had set up backups! But spent the entire night fixing things. Now I do static site or managed databases. > #2: There are weirdos on the internet I agree. The worst is when it’s people you know (or even admire) who take a direct (or indirect) stab at you and your content. But I think you can’t let that stop you, because it stops most people from publishing what they have in their brain. The more successful you are the more haters you’ll attract, that’s just the way it is.
- _xiaz 2y agoAny reason in particular for going with cloudflare pages instead of github pages? The latter has served me well for years, but I'm wondering if I'm missing out
- immibis 2y agoRemember that both of these are giant corporations with your worst interests in mind, and they will demand payment or delete your site as soon as it's convenient for them, so don't rely on them too much.
- pclmulqdq 2y agoA $4/month VPS hosts my static site and a bunch of other convenience things for me. I can swap CDNs if cloudflare decides to kick me off (and this VPS can handle a shockingly high data rate with just nginx). 100% recommended.
- _xiaz 2y agoI'm prepared for that scenario and can migrate to a different host in about an hour. I advise users on github pages don't make use of platform specific features, mostly the default jekyll, for that reason
- 2y ago
- mattgreenrocks 2y agoHearing about the CTR of his videos vs his followers is really interesting. There’s a narrative that once you build up a sufficient following then you have a better shot at getting eyeballs on future things you make. But these stats throw some cold water on that. People don’t magically convert from follower to customer or viewer. I think these narratives are pushed implicitly by the platforms to justify their stranglehold, and the creators themselves who have won big. At a certain scale, the model works, but due to very uneven distribution of attention, it’s tough to be that person. Also, most social media platforms are so infuriatingly mind-numbing now with everyone running around speaking in that faux-authoritative voice when they’re just offering their opinion. I want a great reset of the internet where the subject matter experts are the ones getting attention, not the people who post stupid engagement bait all day. But that won’t happen.
- gavinhoward 2y agoThis is why you must self-host. And use HN for comments. You may think I'm joking, but my pure self-hosted website can get more attention through HN if I put effort into blog posts. I have two blog posts that say the same thing, one with a ragebait tone, and one that is moderate. HN loved the moderate one. I love this site. Anyway, I think he hit on the reason: other platforms give you bad signals for their own benefit. HN still gives a good signal, and self-hosting avoids bad signals from bad platforms.
- trust_bt_verify 2y agoHacker news seems to love rage bait and may just align with your biases better than other tech sites. This has certainly been my experience, I often find people I agree with more reasonable before any personal reflection.
- gavinhoward 2y agoThat may be true, but my biases are towards more professionalism in the industry, and the VC-backed HN community may not like that.
- jfoutz 2y agocompletely unrelated (pretty much) But this is still one of my favorite parts of the internet - https://lcamtuf.coredump.cx/gcnc/ https://lcamtuf.coredump.cx/gcnc/ amazing, information dense guide to actually making stuff. I reached out once to the author, who was patient and kind. I get through my days, I make stuff I do stuff, and I'm generally content with that. The author, lcamtuf, from my very limited interaction seems "extra". Maybe it really just is writing stuff down. Maybe I should do more of that.
- salamo 2y agoI decided a long time ago that my main audience will be myself in the future. A blog post is the output of a project which at a minimum forces me to organize my thoughts on something important, and usually involves getting my hands dirty to understand something at a deeper level. I don't care about SEO because I'm writing for myself, not robots. That said, I feel for people trying to monetize because I know I never could.
- langsoul-com 2y agoI decided to stop writing blog articles and my podcast recently. It's just a ton of work and non existent gain. Unless I wanted to do current news and entertainment, traction is just near impossible. At some point, there's no point dreaming of how things should be, or what could be, but look at the cold hard reality that is today.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- purple-leafy 2y agoOne of my most ambitious projects, I spent nearly every weeknight for 3 months building a tool. I made a good video to present it, and a website. It barely got 100 users. Then for fun, I randomly made a 60 line bookmarklet, converted it to a chrome extension, posted a shitty video, and it grew to 100,000+ users in like a week. The masses absorb drivel, not true effort
- t0bia_s 2y ago- Some of my most popular posts are throwaway quips and memes that went viral on social media. That is mine experience as well. Projects I've spent half year working on is barely noticed, while almost meme content is spreading quite fast. Thats why internet trends are driven by entertainment, not sharing a knowledge or making art in first place.
- huijzer 2y agoSame if you compare Linus Torvalds income with that of a famous singer or football player.
- t0bia_s 2y agoI don't know their income. Do you?
- huijzer 2y agoThe following sources are not the most reliable, but I guess they will not be an order of magnitude off. If you think about it, the numbers make sense. How many people have heard of Linus Torvalds versus Bruce Springsteen? I'm not saying the one person is better than the other, I'm just saying one receives more money than the other. Linus Torvalds: about $10 million per year [1]. Taylor Swift: about $185 million in 2019 [2]. Bruce Springsteen: about $435 million in 2021 [2]. Cristiano Ronaldo: about $260 in 2023 [3]. [1]: https://www.quora.com/Did-Linus-Torvalds-make-money-from-Linux-If-so-how-did-he-earn-money https://www.quora.com/Did-Linus-Torvalds-make-money-from-Lin... [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forbes_list_of_the_world%27s_highest-paid_musicians https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forbes_list_of_the_world%27s_h... [3]: https://eu.usatoday.com/story/sports/soccer/2023/10/14/highest-paid-soccer-players-messi-ronaldo-top-world-2023-list/71185586007/ https://eu.usatoday.com/story/sports/soccer/2023/10/14/highe...
- ghaff 2y agoPresumably Torvalds has other sources of income but the Linux Foundation pays pretty modestly by big tech standards. Certainly, some executives/founders make big money comparable to big name athletes and entertainers--often primarily through stock. But it shouldn't be a surprise that big name entertainers and athletes make a lot of money (while those on the other end of the scale make basically nothing).
- hiAndrewQuinn 2y agoShitposting is the top of my personal sales funnel. Always has been. I got married to a wonderful woman I met on Twitter about 4 years ago. We now live together, slowly conquering Europe from the northeast down and to the left. I got multiple interviews and job offers from it, too, none of which I could take sadly because I planned to move to Finland to be with the aforementioned lass. But I knew plenty of others who did. Shitposting is a game where the rewards to being (smart ∩ charming ∩ really fucking funny sometimes) are disproportionately high. I don't use Twitter anymore, but I see my involvement with it around 2020-2021 as one of the best longshot investments I ever made. By treating it as a gateway drug to the experience that is knowing me as a person, and discovering to my surprise and delight that many people found it extremely worthwhile, I think I permanently deleted any sense that I somehow was too dumb, too awkward, too boring to justify my being. It was great!
- tivert 2y ago> Shitposting is the top of my personal sales funnel. Always has been.... I got multiple interviews and job offers from it, too, none of which I could take sadly because I planned to move to Finland to be with the aforementioned lass. But I knew plenty of others who did. There was a pretty in-depth article about that recently: https://www.nytimes.com/2024/05/26/nyregion/twitter-lawyers-threadnought-elon-musk.html https://www.nytimes.com/2024/05/26/nyregion/twitter-lawyers-...
- boneitis 2y ago> A while ago, I put together an impassioned, contrarian guide to photography, illustrated with a number of interactive shots. The only traffic it’s getting today are confused searches for a porn performer with a vaguely similar name. This has me spinning, even after skimming the referenced piece. What is the performer's name, and to what does s/he have a similar name?
- CM30 2y agoAs a YouTuber and content creator myself, this article rings all too true to me. Lots of good points here for anyone looking to get into this game. > It’s still a chore! Yup. People often underestimate the amount of work it takes to run a blog or YouTube channel in general, and how much of that work doesn't involve the content itself. It's no surprise everyone wants to monetise these things; doing them for free can feel like a second unpaid full-time job in of itself. > There are weirdos on the internet Unfortunately. Which makes for a deadly combination alongside sudden fame and psychological instability. So much drama can basically be summed up as "assholes discover mentally unstable content creator" or "mentally unstable content creator hits the big time and becomes a worldwide celebrity". The end result can be an internet car crash that basically destroys any hope of a normal life. And the more popular you become online, the more likely it is you'll encounter the rare person wanting to make your life a living hell. > Indifference is the real killer 100%. Being hated sucks, but seeing something you worked so hard on go completely ignored... well, that's arguably even worse. Nothing kills motivation faster than the feeling you're not getting anywhere, and platforms like YouTube and Twitch only rub that aspect in your face even more. > Follower counts are a lie Definitely. YouTube is probably the best example, since it seems the majority of users find content via the recommended videos list and home page feed rather than subscriptions now. But just about everywhere is the same, and it only makes it feel worse when only about 1% of your 10,000 followers seem to actually give a toss about your work. > Money is the root of only some evil This is an interesting point, though I'm not sure I agree with the example given. Generally I gain followers when I post videos, with the only difference between posting more and less stuff being whether the number grows gradually or slightly more quickly. Nah, in my opinion, the real root of all evil is that these platforms expect their users to be machines. They expect non stop, consistently posted content on a daily/weekly/hourly basis without fail. And they also usually don't want you to leave your lane either. If you get popular posting about any one topic (whether a game or series, framework or programming language, sport, band, etc) then they only want you to post about that topic until the day you die. That's the big problem with content creation and social media right there. And it's the cause of every issue these platforms face. Why do we get people making meaningless polls about every random topic under the sun? Why has AI generated garbage run rampant? Why is there so much plagiarism from large creators? How have content mills taken over everything? Because that's how you get things done on the ludicrous schedules expected by these platforms. By giving up your humanity and becoming nothing more than a faceless machine attempting to please the algorithm.
- unclear0 2y agoAccess audit my entra 8 external unclear.cunt.tv