5 ms·
The world's largest 3D printer is building cozy homes from wood
- organsnyder 2y agoAs a 3d printer enthusiast, I think this is really cool. But as someone who built an ADU a few years ago, I fail to see how this will address affordability in any meaningful way. Building a structure is a lot more than framing. For our project, the framers were on site a few weeks out of the six-month total. I think modular pre-fab building is a much more effective strategy for this segment of the market. Perhaps 3d printing techniques can increase productivity there, but I'm not quite show how.
- pavel_lishin 2y agoAgreed; we looked into building one, and the actual construction wouldn't have been the problem - getting permits, paying to have surveys done, and drawing up architectural drawings and such would have already been pretty expensive - and that's the bare minimum required to even get an answer from our city as to whether we can plop one down.
- Luc 2y agoADU: Accessory Dwelling Unit
- SamBam 2y ago> I fail to see how this will address affordability in any meaningful way Especially since it's unlikely that we can address the housing shortage by building single-family homes.
- onlyrealcuzzo 2y agoEspecially when permit fees and taxes are fixed and ~30% of the cost to build (in cities like Vancouver: https://dailyhive.com/vancouver/vancouver-housing-government-fees-taxes-costs-may-2018 https://dailyhive.com/vancouver/vancouver-housing-government...) It could cost $250k to legally build a sandcastle in Vancouver.
- dghlsakjg 2y agoThat was a study done by an industry group and included all fees and taxes in a contrived scenario. Not just permitting fees. So things like property tax during the build period, as well as sales tax and service tax charged by the builders contractors. The study assumed a 5 year build period and multiplied all yearly property taxes by that amount. It also tacked on things like the vacant home tax and speculation tax which are not applied to properties under construction. Many of the taxes and fees are also scaled to the square footage of the house. Lastly they also included things like sewer hookup fees, which is really not an unnecessary cost for a builder to pay. Permit fees are too high, and maybe we should exempt a lot of them given the current crisis, but this study is aiming for a quick headline. If you dig into their analysis it is a worst case scenario for what a house would cost for a foreign speculator who left the house vacant before flipping it and didn’t qualify for any homebuyer tax exemptions. A lot of those taxes and fees wouldn’t apply to a sandcastle is what I’m saying. The $250k figure is the number they quoted for a $900k 2-bed new-build condo in a transit corridor. Even in their own study the lower cost housing units were coming in at half that.
- throwaway22032 2y agoWhy is it unlikely? Not enough physical resources? People working in the wrong jobs? Or just, we won't?
- SamBam 2y agoFor one reason, fixing the 4-5 million unit housing shortfall by building endless sprawling suburbs is not at all environmental or energy efficient.
- najarvg 2y agoI remember reading on a related reddit thread (more about container home costs) that structural costs account for only a small portion of the cost of home-building and that ground and electrical work, plumbing, finishes etc add a big portion
- mikeg8 2y agoIn light frame residential construction, the structural envelope (foundation, framing, roof, and exterior doors/windows) will usually be about 50% of project cost, if not a little more
- Mountain_Skies 2y agoSheds and small storage buildings seem like they could be a good use of the technology. Dwelling units and production spaces need utilities, which complicates things. Sheds need a solid base, good walls, a roof (which might be 3D printed in stairstep fashion), and a door. There's a big gap in the market between the metal/resin DIY kits from big box retailers and the prefab sheds delivered by flatbed truck.
- pavel_lishin 2y ago> “People can’t find homes, they’re very expensive. We also have an aging population … so there’s less and less people who are electricians, plumbers, or builders,” Habib Dagher, the executive director of the University of Maine’s Advanced Structures and Composites Center (ASCC), told CNN via video call. Presumably this thing doesn't print pipes or electrical wires, so it seems like there's still a need to address those issues.
- darepublic 2y agoCame here to say the same thing. Is he suggesting that when enough plumbing and electricity problems accumulate, the future non handy folk will just order a new home?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- klyrs 2y agoWhat I love about modern housing is that it's built out of modular parts that I can buy from the hardware store and fix myself. 3d prints are notoriously unrepairable; if there's an earthquake will houses like this fracture in a way that the entire thing is scrap?
- gambiting 2y agoPresumably, long term these kinds of printers would be ubiquitous, so you just pop into your nearest hardware store, give them the CAD file or a picture of what you want and they just print you a replacement. But obviously like with any new technology it's the initial bit which might be painful.
- tempoponet 2y agoHow do you figure? We're talking about the structure of a home, not a modular component of one. A 3d printed car frame would be impractical to replace, let alone the side of a house.
- gambiting 2y agoSure, but if I make a hole in the side of my house I don't need to replace the entire wall - I can patch it up. I'm sure the same is true here?
- klyrs 2y agoNo, that's exactly my point. The walls are all printed together as a single monolithic building. I can do a repair in my house to the point that you can't tell it was ever broken. I'm not confident you can do the same here.
- goda90 2y ago3D printed houses are cool, but I wonder if the future would actually be in robots doing the heavy labor of regular balloon framing instead. Given a standard set of pre-fab frames and parameterized layouts that only use standard sizes, a small team of robots could probably put up a frame pretty fast. Two robots to place a piece, and one to nail it in place.
- tombert 2y agoMaybe it's just the fact that I don't know anything about material science, but I am not sure I'd feel safe in a wood+resin house; this just seems like it's going to end up as extruded particleboard, which I wouldn't even consider building a house out of it. Honestly, maybe they're getting better, but when I researched 3D printed houses about a year ago I was a little disappointed to see how little the 3d printing actually bought you. It still seemed like an awful lot of human labor was involved in the process, to a point where I'm actually not sure that the 3D printing actually saved time or money. There's a lot more to a house than the walls, but the 3D printer can't really help with anything but walls.
- Mountain_Skies 2y agoReminds me a bit of the Shed-to-House projects or shipping container house projects that end up costing nearly as much as a site built home once all of the non-shell costs are added in.
- tombert 2y agoYeah, that's what I was thinking as well. It's obvious why something like this would be appealing; stuff like shipping containers are abundant and cheap and modular, so it seems like a no-brainer, but I think a lot of people forget that building codes actually exist for a reason. You need a foundation if you don't want your home to sink, unless you want to larp as the unabomber you'll need electricity and plumbing installed, in the case of shipping containers there's a risk that the paints and metals inside there aren't really meant to be inhaled by humans for prolonged periods of time (which is not an issue if you're only in there for a few minutes a day to load and unload boxes, but might be an issue if your plan is to sleep there). There's a cool novelty to some of this stuff, and that might be worth it for some people, and I don't really want to tell people how to spend their money, but it just doesn't seem worth it to me. This isn't to knock prefab homes as a concept, there are plenty of really good ones and they're not necessarily overpriced, but those are basically still just regular houses with pre-cut and pre-measured materials, and there's no delusions that it'll lead to a house being built overnight.
- bluGill 2y ago
- bamboozled 2y agoDefinitely a lot of unanswered questions for me, feels a bit like a feel good piece honestly.
- tombert 2y agoThat's kind of how I feel about the entire prospect of 3D printed houses in general. The idea of 3D printing an entire house is objectively cool (insofar that anything can be objective), it feels like the future, and viscerally it feels like it's a cheap way to get endless houses which would be a good thing. But, at least right now, all the 3d printers do is extrude walls and floors. What percentage of actual home labor is involved with the rough framing of the walls and floors? Certainly not "zero", but you still need to clean up everything, install drywall, paint everything, install plumbing and electrical, etc. I think the idea that we're going to be able to use 3D printing to address the housing shortage is a cute but kind of naive idea.
- tonetegeatinst 2y agoTechnically, humans are also 3d printers....we just are super slow at assembly of large structures.... However we are able to design and build and "print" more complicated structures as we work in 3 dimensions and are only limited by our strength. Side note: 3d printing is awesome tech. While its not exactly super eco friendly, its a big help for rapid prototyping. I currently have an ender 3 pro which I upgraded with a touch sensor. Its not working due to issues I can't figure out....but I think it has a motor or alignment issue....but the 2 prints I have successfully done were amazing.
- mikeg8 2y ago> we are just super slow at assembly of large structures… The Amish would like a word with you lol
- yardie 2y agoI watched a warehouse go up over the last few months. Everything above the floor was pre-cast concrete shipped in on flatbed trunks. For the size of the warehouse it was fascinating to watch just how fast it got built. The big time sink wasn't even the warehouse superstructure. Majority of the project time was leveling, compacting, and foundation. When I see 3D printing construction compared to precast modules I simply don't see a future where printing a whole building is price or labor saving.
- dghlsakjg 2y agoI feel the same way. Especially with a promo piece like this so short on details. If you’ve watched a house, or any structure, go up, you know that building the basic structure happens remarkably quickly. This seems to replace framing, roofing and siding. Maybe drywall too? But you still have all of the expensive/slow stuff like plumbing, electrical and finish carpentry that still has to be done.
- Swizec 2y ago> But you still have all of the expensive/slow stuff like plumbing, electrical and finish carpentry that still has to be done. I did some research on modular construction recently to use in a talk about modular software design. This tech is getting really cool! You can nowadays get hotel modules that are full pre-built suites. Comes with all the plumbing, electricals, even furniture. Bed and everything already bolted into place. You just lift it to your hotel’s superstructure, plug in a water pipe, an electric connection, and a sewage connection. Boom. New suite added. I’m sure similarly pre-fab modular family homes exist. We have the tech, question is whether we have the demand.
- pavel_lishin 2y ago> I’m sure similarly pre-fab modular family homes exist. They've existed for longer than I've been alive, and they're called "mobile homes" - but they have a bad reputation. Actually, sorry, I'm wrong - they're not modular in the way you describe.
- 2y ago
- ben_w 2y agoCool though they are, like everyone else, I think 3D printed houses are solving the wrong problem. I can get an empty shell built for €100k, double that if you want the interior finished, add another €200k around here minimum for land and connecting utilities. The physical structure of houses themselves are already pretty cheap, it's everything else related to them that makes them expensive.
- darepublic 2y agoThis is very cool, but as others have mentioned this article was not a deep dive. The general idea of "disrupting" housing by innovating to reduce build cost does seem exciting to me. Empowering people to have a place to live for cheap and therefore make them more resilient seems like it could be a general good. I dunno if 3d printed stationary homes is the way, but creativity around making homes, mobile housing, living off the grid, etc though often maligned seems like it might be a fruitful thing to explore
- barfbagginus 2y agoOh yes, please let me live in the microplastics house, uwu
- washadjeffmad 2y agoIn my area, the definitions of prefab or "manufactured" housing used to keep out poverty-associated dwellings have been extended to apply to anything not constructed locally on site. We're also famous for our "Sears homes", which ironically would be illegal under the modern interpretation of the codes to construct. Given that I don't think the prejudice is against the materials themselves, bringing the manufacturing on site to fabricate a home is more likely to get new laws written against the process than to fix housing in areas that don't feel they have a particular deficiency of 3D printed homes.
- samtho 2y agoI’ve worked a lot in construction both prior to entering tech and as a side hustle while working for tech companies. Every single one of these construction-tech products fail to address actual problems and bottlenecks in the construction process, ultimately creating just novelties dreamt up by someone who has never set foot on a job site. The wood frame is one of the fastest parts of structure, I am able to frame 300-900sqft ADUs (accessory dwelling units) in 2-3 days with help or 3-4 days solo, which is 24-48 human hours. The lumber is ordered and delivered by truck, it requires no special equipment, only really needing a battery operated miter saw, nailer, impact driver, measuring tape, speed square, string lines, levels, hammer, and sunscreen. What takes a long time is everything else: * Foundation is 85% site prep, 10% coordination of materials/subcontractors/inspection, and 5% of actual work construction. Draining and grading is overlooked or under considered most often leading to settling/cracking or outright failure of the foundation system prematurely. * Plumbing needs to be involved between every single step, beginning from after the site is graded to after wall coverings are up and fixtures are ready to be installed. DWV (drain waste vent) is critical to get right as shit only travels downhill. * Electrical is time consuming, has expensive materials, and is getting saddled with even more requirements of diminishing returns. 200A main panels are the norm basically all new construction is 100% electric. You are running 10/3 wire (3 conductors of 10AWG + ground) at $1.30/ft for a clothes dryer, 6/3 at $5.50-6.50/ft for both your electric range hookup and EV charger, 8/3 at $3-4/ft for your HVAC, dedicated 12/2 circuits for each of your microwave, refrigerator, dish washer, garbage disposer, etc. all circuit breakers that service circuits in dwelling area must be arc fault protected (which means your breakers went from $10-20 each to $40-80 each). I won’t even go into solar and how much of everything must be solar ready. * HVAC is straight forward for new homes, provided the unit/s is/are sized appropriately. * Wall covering (usually drywall) takes a long time with many passes to affix, tape, and sand wallboard * Vapor barriers on the outside require basic knowledge to get the install right - which is sadly not always present for the build * Exterior cladding can take many forms from shiplap siding (cedar or composite), masonry board, a masonry product like stucco, vinyl, or just a tongue and groove primed siding board. * Roofing is easy and fast but costly * Final utility hookup is fraught with slowdowns and annoyances, requires certain inspections to be done (but not all) and unless you have someone’s desk phone at the utility to help you out, it’s a crappy process to navigate. * Landscaping and other finish work takes a while The elephant in the room, however, is always the going to be related to the red tape. Permitting accounts for a significant chunk of the cost where a new single family home might incur $90-$130K in just permit fees alone (in Sacramento where I’m located, which is on the medium/low end for California). The process is becoming so convoluted and draconian that you need literal consultants to tell you where to burn piles of cash that add comparatively little value to the overall project and just drive costs up unnecessarily. Having safe buildings is important and there is value in getting an third party check work for correctness, but something is wrong when my $85-$200K construction project doubles because it’s literally illegal not to pay this. Because this cost does not scale linearly with the size of the build, most developers build the largest sized home they can for the plot as that’s the best value relative to permitting costs. Affordable housing to-own is never going to be within reach with the way this is setup.
- voidUpdate 2y agoJust 3D print the biggest benchy ever out of wood filament and sail away
- drivingmenuts 2y agoThis will be awesome until the venture capitalists get involved and then it will. become more like traditional homes: completely unaffordable.
- LeafItAlone 2y agoA lot of people are commenting about how this isn’t better than pre-fab or other existing methods. And it is not, for the purposes of constructing same-style buildings. But I don’t use my 3D printer for things I can order off Amazon or that I need 1,000 replicas off that I can get injection molded. I use it for unique designs and prototyping or one-offs. I think that is where “3D printed” homes will find their niche too.