3 ms·
Yes. As the article says, they needed "a use case that could tolerate the inevitable inadequacies of the 1.0 version of the device". A Newcomen engine is a turk
by Animats 2y ago
Yes. As the article says, they needed "a use case that could tolerate the inevitable inadequacies of the 1.0 version of the device". A Newcomen engine is a turkey. It's about 0.5% efficient. It's the size of a house with the power of a riding lawnmower. And it took most of a century to advance to a better model.
There's another direction that might have created an industrial revolution. High-quality steel swords were known in Roman times, but they were not mass-produced items. The Roman army did produce swords in quantity, and they had a modest steel-making capability. But the Romans never made it to the Bessemer converter.
The Bessemer converter is a simple, crude device. The Romans could have built one.
But the metallurgy of making steel with it is hard.
Early versions had serious yield problems - much of the time, the steel produced was terrible.
It took over a thousand test runs by one of Bessemer's customers and some knowledge of analytical chemistry to figure out the additives that make the process work reliably.
The demand wasn't there yet. But if someone had developed gunpowder...