3 ms·
> As witnessed in Ukraine, tanks are toast, fighter planes are of relatively limited utility in contested airspace, and surface navy is a dinosaur None of thos
by bluGill 2y ago
> As witnessed in Ukraine, tanks are toast, fighter planes are of relatively limited utility in contested airspace, and surface navy is a dinosaur
None of those are witnessed in Ukraine.
Tanks are only useless if you use them in roles most armchair strategists wouldn't be stupid enough to use them for, much less a proper military strategist. Ukraine is using tanks to great effect today - as are the few competent commanders Russia has. (though with drones tanks are not as useful as in the past they are still useful).
Ukraine is asking for more fighters for a reason - they believe that if they had greater numbers they could contest airspace and win. Fighters are useless in small numbers is a good lesson to draw, but that doesn't say anything about larger numbers.
Surface navy hasn't been fighting in Ukraine at all. We cannot draw any lessons from this conflict. Sure they are vulnerable to drones - but there are also protections that could be applied. You should perhaps look to the red sea where the US navy is fighting and shooting down drones with reasonable success.
Ukraine/Russia is one war. While there are a lot of lessons to learn there, do not draw the wrong ones. Militaries around the world constantly make the mistake of preparing for the last war. The next war (whatever it is!) will be different, and taking a lesson out context will lose the war for your side.