5 ms·
People keep calling social security a ponzi scheme, but it's not. For the simple reason that it's not trying to make a profit - it's trying to give back to peop
by ars 18y ago
People keep calling social security a ponzi scheme, but it's not. For the simple reason that it's not trying to make a profit - it's trying to give back to people the same amount of money they put in.
It's more of a forced investment than anything else, with the variation of having the money skip a generation.
The difference is that if all you do is give people the exact same amount of money they put in, you can run forever. All you need is a buffer of some kind.
- byrneseyeview 18y agoFor the simple reason that it's not trying to make a profit - it's trying to give back to people the same amount of money they put in. If Charles Ponzi wanted to live modestly, but donate huge sums to charity so everybody would love the big-shot Ponzi, it wouldn't have been a Ponzi scheme? If he'd wanted to buy votes, would it have been less of a Ponzi scheem? It's more of a forced investment than anything else, with the variation of having the money skip a generation. Well, no. It's forced redistribution. The money is not invested; it's spent. The difference is that if all you do is give people the exact same amount of money they put in, you can run forever. All you need is a buffer of some kind. But SS was designed with the assumption that either demographics wouldn't change, or that they'd change so slowly that nobody would suffer politically for having invented Social Security.
- mattmcknight 18y agoThat ignores that the first beneficiaries never paid in. Also it has little to do with what you put in. That is why Gore proposed the lockbox. All the money We put in this year is already spent.
- anamax 18y ago> People keep calling social security a ponzi scheme, but it's not. For the simple reason that it's not trying to make a profit - it's trying to give back to people the same amount of money they put in. No, it's not. If it was, people who cap out for years would get roughly the same return on their "investment" as people who do the bare minimum. Instead, SS gives a much higher return (on investment) to folks in the latter group than it does to folks in the former. (It's almost a decent investment for the minimum folks, while it's a crappy "investment" for the cap-out folks.)