3 ms·
I am going to be diplomatic, and just flat out call her a liar: "Johansson has numerously said that tools that can scan for CSAM are highly accurate. For examp
by belter 2y ago
I am going to be diplomatic, and just flat out call her a liar:
"Johansson has numerously said that tools that can scan for CSAM are highly accurate. For example, in a presentation to and exchange with LIBE MEPs in late 2022, Johansson promised that CSAM scanning tools have an accuracy of 99.99%."
https://edri.org/our-work/commissioner-johansson-cannot-be-trusted-with-the-eus-proposed-csa-regulation/ https://edri.org/our-work/commissioner-johansson-cannot-be-t...
- theyinwhy 2y agoEven if true, 99.99% is way too little!
- belter 2y agoYes indeed. 99,99% would be just for Germany, and assuming each citizen send one message every 12 months, 8000 false accusations per year.
- cnity 2y ago99.99% would mean 1 incorrect classification for every 10,000 images, which is actually a very large number. I mean, how many pictures do you think are sent per hour across all mainstream communication platforms?
- belter 2y agoDon't bring logic to this discussion. It's an EU Commissioner...
- 0dayz 2y agoTo be fair to Ylva, she may say this dumb crap but it's not from any extensive knowledge she may have about the subject. Instead politicians are always briefed by experts in the field about said topic. The issue is they can selectively pick and choose which field of expertise the experts should be listen to or just personally put their fingers into the ears and go lalala. In this case she never invited privacy or security experts but instead US based corporations represented by a lobbying group and charity and the Europol.
- belter 2y ago> To be fair to Ylva, she may say this dumb crap but it's not from any extensive knowledge she may have about the subject. Instead politicians are always briefed by experts in the field about said topic. The exact same excuse, used by the CEO at the head of the UK Post Office, at the time of the infamous scandal.
- 0dayz 2y agoIts literally how politicians do their job without having to be an expert in the field. You'll be gobsmacked by how few financial ministers have a background in economics.
- belter 2y agoI have enough with a lawyer as Chair of the Federal Reserve of the United States...
- eru 2y agoYes, but if you want to be the guy in charge and delegate, you also have a responsibility to delegate to the right people; and you are (or should be) responsible when that goes wrong.
- 0dayz 2y agoYes I never said that politicians aren't beholden. I only said that politicians have to rely on experts they choose to call in or listen to, it is then up to the people to decide if said politician does a good job effectively.
- robertlagrant 2y agoAnyone who cites "accuracy" instead of "sensitivity and specificity" is automatically disqualified from any serious conversation.
- Scarblac 2y agoSame for anyone who cites "99.99%" in this discussion. Because for one the problem isn't well defined enough for such percentages to be possible (two human experts judging pictures will disagree on far more than 0.01%) and two that number isn't remotely close to the specificity that would be needed.