4 ms·
Eh, also in legal practice there are key skills like selecting the best billable clients, covering your ass, building a reputation, choosing the right market se
by lazide 2y ago
Eh, also in legal practice there are key skills like selecting the best billable clients, covering your ass, building a reputation, choosing the right market segment, etc. which I’d also argue LLMs suck at.
- gadflyinyoureye 2y agoI don’t know. There was some talk this weekend about CEOs being replaced by AI. Given the overlap in skill, I’d say there is a distinct possibility an LLM could do that. https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/companies/ceos-could-easily-be-replaced-with-ai-experts-argue/ar-BB1nrhSA?ocid=BingNewsSerp https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/companies/ceos-could-easily-...
- lazide 2y agoBwahaha. This is like the ‘everything can be a directed graph db’, ‘everything should be a micro service’, etc. fads. No one who has been a CEO, or frankly even worked closely with one, would think this could be even remotely close to possible. Or desirable if it was. But that is probably 1% or less of the population eh?
- EGreg 2y agohttps://www.dqindia.com/company-makes-ai-robot-its-ceo-makes-record-breaking-profits-in-stock-market/ https://www.dqindia.com/company-makes-ai-robot-its-ceo-makes... Seems your claim's been disproven already
- lazide 2y agoBwaha. Funny the company named as doing so doesn’t mention it on their actual management team [http://www.netdragon.com/about/management-team.shtml http://www.netdragon.com/about/management-team.shtml], listing an actual human CEO instead. But it makes for a fun soundbite eh? Especially when the article claims it was in the past, and totally was awesome. Sucker born every minute.
- threeseed 2y agoPhoebe Moore who that quote was attributed to has never been a CEO or even worked at a non-academic organisation. So much of a what a CEO does is fostering culture, hiring people and setting a unique vision for the company. Imagine thinking people would be inspired to work for a chatbot. Hilariously ridiculous.
- pojzon 2y agoIf that chatbot had Steve Jobs voice ? I dunno, I would probably prefer to work under that chatbot than my current CEO that only tries to squize as much as possible out of ppl already working for him.
- lazide 2y agoLike the chatbot wouldn’t squeeze you 10x harder. At least a human CEO has to worry about being arrested or someone setting their house on fire.
- mrguyorama 2y agoSteve Jobs didn't even worry about cancer enough to save his life. Why the fuck do you think he would have an even remote understanding that squeezing people could result in consequences for him?
- lazide 2y agoI don’t think you’re making the point you think you’re making here.
- paulcole 2y ago> which I’d also argue LLMs suck at OK, I’ll bite. What’s your evidence for this argument?
- lazide 2y agoEvery bit of interaction I’ve ever had with an LLM. And all the research I’ve seen. They’re plausible word sequence generators, not ‘planning for the future’ agents. Or market analyzers. Or character evaluators. Or anything else. And they tend to be really ‘gullible’. What evidence do you have they could do any of those things? (And not just generate plausible text at a prompt, but actually do those things)
- paulcole 2y ago> What evidence do you have they could do any of those things? Every bit of interaction I’ve ever had with an LLM.
- Terr_ 2y agoYeah, I fear a lot of human exuberance (and thus investment) is riding on the questionable idea that a really good text-fragment-correlation specialist engine can usefully impersonate a generalist "thinking" AI without doing too much damage. ("LLM, which rocks are the best to eat?") But there's a scarier further step: When people assume an exceptional text-specialist model can also meta-impersonate a generalist model impersonating a specific and different kind of specialist! ("LLM, create a legal defense.")