3 ms·
Fallout shelters seem flawed because, although they allow an individual or single family to survive, they don’t provide an enclave where civilization can regrou
by ryandrake 2y ago
Fallout shelters seem flawed because, although they allow an individual or single family to survive, they don’t provide an enclave where civilization can regroup and rebuild collectively. They just assume that a bunch of surviving, rugged individualists would just magically -function- after the war. A very libertarian-optimist view of humanity.
I think the more likely dystopian-post-apocalypse looks more like Elysium, with a small number of rich people grouped together, living in relative luxury, served by robotics and automation, physically separated from the rest who are barely surviving, subsisting in the wasteland.
- bitmasher9 2y agoIt doesn’t make any assumptions about what happens after the bomb. All it does is propose the question: how else do you plan on surviving if a nuclear bomb is headed in your direction. Some people are just fine clocking out in that event. Others decided that whatever was on the other side of the explosion, that would prefer to be there than not.
- hollerith 2y ago>They don’t provide an enclave where civilization can regroup and rebuild collectively. Your model of nuclear war is flawed, which is understandable given the immense amount of misinformation out there. If Russia and China launched every nuke they have at the US, about half of Americans would survive even without any use of fallout shelters. Most vehicles would "survive" (continue to operate or fail in ways that are easy to fix even under the new, degraded conditions in the country). At any given time, the US has enough food stored (mostly in the form of grains and soybeans intended to be fed to livestock) to keep the survivors alive for 3 years. In contrast, you seem to think that most people in attacked countries would die. Either that or you think most of the survivors would degenerate into a distinctly uncivilized mode of living, which is also unlikely IMHO. I can elaborate on this point if there is interest. My prediction is that the period of social chaos lasts only as long as it take for the radiation from the fallout to diminish to non-lethal levels, which is about 3 weeks after the last weapons exploded. (Less than half of the area of the US would be covered by lethal concentrations of fallout in the first place: fallout shelters are a good idea because there is no location guaranteed not to receive lethal levels of fallout: it literally depends on which way the winds are blowing.) The big unknown in an all-out nuclear war is nuclear winter, which might end up causing most of the deaths, i.e., after the silos full of livestock feed are used up, but IMHO it is unlikely that nuclear winter would be that severe. In summary: nuclear war will not cause a collapse of civilization or societal order, at least not one sustained for more than a few weeks or possibly a few months.
- candiddevmike 2y agoI don't think half of Americans would still be alive a year after the bombs fell.
- xyzzy123 2y agoSeems quite difficult to predict what would happen at a psychological level. Think what 9/11 did to the American psyche, that was 3k deaths, about the same as die every year from accidental food poisoning and < 1/10 the number of people who die in car crashes every year. I'm not sure but I also wonder if you are under-estimating the overall supply chain complexity that underpins modern urban living. There might be 3 years of soybean supply in the US under ideal circumstances, but how do you distribute that to people when communications, roads, pipelines, electrical generation, fuel refining, private & commercial vehicles etc are all damaged at the same time? Plus the supply chain required to keep those things running? Not to mention record-keeping and the political fabric itself.
- op00to 2y agoFor most Americans, 9/11 changed nothing. Hell, for most in NYC 9/11 changed very little in daily life after the initial attack.
- nostrademons 2y ago9/11 didn't do much to the American psyche. It did a lot to American discourse. But discourse != psyche, and most ordinary people just went about their business the way they did before 9/11 while rolling their eyes (privately) at the new government policies.
- xyzzy123 2y agoIt seemed to have a pretty big impact on domestic and foreign policy. Perhaps homeland security, gitmo, TSA, expanded NSA powers and the global war on terror were just "on trend" and inevitable? I find it hard to tell. When people feel threatened there's typically a drive towards authoritarianism and top-down control, a desire for a sense of security and certainty. I find it hard to predict how this would play out vs the US's unique cultural takes on freedom.
- toast0 2y agoWay back when, community fallout shelters were a thing too. Some buildings may still have civil defense fallout shelter signs on them. But, it's a lot of expense to build, maintain, and stock those; and there was no desire to keep it going. Same thing happened with pandemic supplies after 2009's H1N1 pandemic; it was a big deal, supplies were gathered, and it cost too much to maintain, so by the time covid rolled around, there wasn't a suitable stockpile of ppe for medical workers. Unless the shelters and the stocks for the shelters are in regular use for something else, it's just not reasonable. There's also questions about time from detection to detonation vs time from detection to dissemination and if it would be better for people to shelter in place, wherever that is, or travel to better shelter.
- WalterBright 2y ago> A very libertarian-optimist view of humanity Libertarians are not anarchists. Libertarianism requires a functioning government to protect our fundamental rights.
- padthai 2y agoFunny enough, historically anarchists have been called libertarians and were not against institutions and governance per se. Maybe you are caricaturing a bunch of movements that you do not agree with or are not well informed about?
- WalterBright 2y agoPeople often conflate anarchists with libertarians. They are quite distinct, and the post I replied to clearly was referring to libertarians as not having a government. The US was a reasonable approximation to libertarian up until perhaps FDR or so.
- corinroyal 2y ago> The US was a reasonable approximation to libertarian up until perhaps FDR or so. Wouldn't it be great if somehow the titans of Silicon Valley could figure out a way to bring back sweatshops, company towns, employment sharks, Pinkertons, and child labor? Oh, wait.
- WalterBright 2y agoI'm not going to claim the US then was a paradise. But when you're complaining about conditions in the US in those times, the fair thing to do would be to compare with conditions before 1800, not after 1930. The fact remains that 1800s US raised several scores of millions of people from poverty in the middle class, and achievement that occurred nowhere else in that time. You can also see it in the statistics - average height improved dramatically throughout that time period, as did longevity. The immigrants to the US had barely enough for a ship ticket. The wealthy did not immigrate here, the poor did to escape the miserable poverty in Europe. You can see for yourself if you take a tour of Fort Henry. They have an exhibit of clothing from the Revolutionary War period. They look sized for children. Then visit a museum in Gettysburg where they have uniforms on display. They look like uniforms for boys. That'll give you some idea of how live improved in the US. Expecting the US to go from 0 to 60 in a month is absurd.