5 ms·
Survival of the richest: Inside the short-lived fallout shelter bubble
- bhgf66478 2y ago[dead]
- atleastoptimal 2y agoSomething I worry about: I imagine rich people who mostly wouldn't concern themselves with long-term outcomes of environmental destruction or global catastrophe may still feel a bit of a pause going full force into risky plans for the future if their personal fortresses would require human labor for upkeep. They may feel a bit of a reluctance to pursue policies fearless of shit hitting the fan due to the chance that in a post-law world, nothing would stop their army of servants from killing them without remorse. That reluctance won't exist once humanoid robots are a sufficient replacement for human labor.
- schmidtleonard 2y agoThe whole economy is like that. Most people derive most of their societal power and relevance from labor. Structural decreases in demand for that labor are, by default, extremely bad.
- HPsquared 2y agoI think most rich people know, deep down, that their riches are purely a social phenomenon.
- bediger4000 2y agoMaybe the first generation wealthy, like William Gates Jr, but it looks like the inheritors of amazing wealth don't know that. They appear to think they just deserve it, based on some magical criteria.
- HPsquared 2y agoThey know that any usage of their money and assets requires a counterparty.
- bitmasher9 2y agoHow many monarchs fully believed in the Divine Right of Kings, that their rule comes from divine authority.
- chomskyole 2y agoNone. Just to state the obvious. If you are in for the fight, you do know the rules, so you know that there is no divine authority coming for your support.
- candiddevmike 2y agoI wonder if that is due to how they were raised. Maybe that's how their minds cope with that situation.
- chomskyole 2y agoMagical criteria and private schools. That's where this thinking is honed....
- chomskyole 2y agoI think this knowledge is at the base of their identity. That's why they push the narrative that their success is driven by personal merit. Having spent weekends with some of the rich, they are pretty aware of what is happening in a way that the rest / the poor are not.
- pmorici 2y agoThe notion that rich people aren’t concerned with long term outcomes seems like one of those things that isn’t true. In fact the reverse is often said the poor have, “nothing to lose”. Many wealthy people have gotten where they are by focusing on the longer term. The promise of your comment just doesn’t seem true.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bitmasher9 2y agoNeither party has provided empirical data, so it’s hard to say if I should agree with parent comment or grand-parent comment. I think it’s likely that a third variable like stress level, political affiliation, or time spent outside more greatly correlates with long term environmental concern. Both of your pure-theory discussions don’t feel convincing.
- atleastoptimal 2y agoMy argument is based on the revealed internal memos from Exxon regarding their awareness of CO2 and its effect on climate change, the number of world leaders who have been revealed to have aggressively pursued strike-first policies for nuclear war, anyone involved in environmental degradation, pollution, dumping chemicals into water supply, etc. All horrible long-term and even short term policies for the masses but provide short term profit to a class insulated from the worst effects. Of course it's not all rich people but there are enough of them with disproportionate influence that their influence is a sizable negative factor on overall human welfare.
- roenxi 2y agoOn the topic, stupid people in the military are a much greater threat. Groupthink in a strategic command force for example, or any similar mob psychology, could be catastrophic.
- nostrademons 2y agoI largely agree with you, but there's a kernel of truth in the OP's comment. Many of the very rich got to be very rich because they are very good at optimizing for money. They understand economics, business, and the financial system extremely well. And that's a weakness in a post-collapse world because it is very likely that money will be worthless and we won't have much of a financial system to speak of. They probably also pissed a lot of people off on the way up, or simply by virtue of being filthy stinking rich. And that sort of wealth is hard to hide, painting a target on them for millions of people. The folks who will do the best in a collapse scenario are likely the next social class down; the folks who perhaps sold a company for 8-figures (but not billions), or are in reasonably high-level managerial positions for 7-figure annual salaries. This class is pretty heavily networked and also knows how to work together. It's held together by social bonds of trust, geographic proximity, and mutual interest as much as by money. So when money goes away, those bonds remain, and you have a class of people who are long-term oriented, highly-skilled, but also communicate and cooperate with others. They are also relatively invisible (could you name a bunch of directors at major corporations, or solopreneurs with successful bootstrapped businesses?), so they can blend in and avoid becoming a target until defense systems can be established.
- throwaway22032 2y agoThinking that anyone with significantly more money than you are alien beings with evil tendencies is an unhealthy belief. It's both wrong and self limiting. If I had a couple of multiples of what I had, I'd build a bunker, but I'd still much rather live on a planet where I can go outside, play golf, visit national parks, do woodworking in the yard etc. The bunker is a backup to protect against outcomes you can't control, not the plan A to intentionally destroy the world.
- atleastoptimal 2y agoIt's not about them opting to aggressively pursue world-destroying policies, it's that, if some decision they make carries a long-tailed world-destroying risk, the weight of it in their mind is lower if a scot-free outcome still exists for them in the event that that happens. This is a psychological influence that would exist just as often in the poorest as it does the richest, it's just that the richest have the means to avoid the negative outcomes of their lack of more cautious foresight.
- jonathankoren 2y agoDouglas Rushkoff talked about how the bunker billionaires specifically asked about hot to maintain compliance by their “security forces” and asked him about how to withhold food rations. Putting aside the fact that there are always lackeys looking to show sempai how much the love him. The most effective way to not get killed an eaten for sport, is simply maintaining a community and stop trying to horde everything. But then again, I wouldn’t expect dragons to understand that.
- ThinkingGuy 2y agoRushkoff’s TED talk on this tpoic: https://www.ted.com/talks/douglas_rushkoff_how_to_be_team_human_in_the_digital_future https://www.ted.com/talks/douglas_rushkoff_how_to_be_team_hu...
- dyauspitr 2y agoI mean if you’re going to have an apocalypse bunker it will most definitely come with kill collars for the staff.
- candiddevmike 2y agoEh, you gotta sleep and eat sometime.
- dyauspitr 2y agoProximity kill when you’re asleep.
- WalterBright 2y agoRich people have the same concerns as anybody else.
- throwaway115 2y ago>Months later, New York Gov. Nelson Rockefeller proposed a bill mandating all state residents to build their own shelters, but it didn’t pass. Wow, the bill attempts to make the case that nuclear shelter is like other building codes and housing standards. It's a stretch. 1. https://www.cia.gov/readingroom/docs/CIA-RDP80B01676R003700040002-8.pdf https://www.cia.gov/readingroom/docs/CIA-RDP80B01676R0037000...
- bbminner 2y agoI happened to read a short story called "Foster, You're Dead!" not so long ago - which appears to have been Philip K. Dick's reaction to exactly these kinds of efforts.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ryandrake 2y agoFallout shelters seem flawed because, although they allow an individual or single family to survive, they don’t provide an enclave where civilization can regroup and rebuild collectively. They just assume that a bunch of surviving, rugged individualists would just magically -function- after the war. A very libertarian-optimist view of humanity. I think the more likely dystopian-post-apocalypse looks more like Elysium, with a small number of rich people grouped together, living in relative luxury, served by robotics and automation, physically separated from the rest who are barely surviving, subsisting in the wasteland.
- bitmasher9 2y agoIt doesn’t make any assumptions about what happens after the bomb. All it does is propose the question: how else do you plan on surviving if a nuclear bomb is headed in your direction. Some people are just fine clocking out in that event. Others decided that whatever was on the other side of the explosion, that would prefer to be there than not.
- hollerith 2y ago>They don’t provide an enclave where civilization can regroup and rebuild collectively. Your model of nuclear war is flawed, which is understandable given the immense amount of misinformation out there. If Russia and China launched every nuke they have at the US, about half of Americans would survive even without any use of fallout shelters. Most vehicles would "survive" (continue to operate or fail in ways that are easy to fix even under the new, degraded conditions in the country). At any given time, the US has enough food stored (mostly in the form of grains and soybeans intended to be fed to livestock) to keep the survivors alive for 3 years. In contrast, you seem to think that most people in attacked countries would die. Either that or you think most of the survivors would degenerate into a distinctly uncivilized mode of living, which is also unlikely IMHO. I can elaborate on this point if there is interest. My prediction is that the period of social chaos lasts only as long as it take for the radiation from the fallout to diminish to non-lethal levels, which is about 3 weeks after the last weapons exploded. (Less than half of the area of the US would be covered by lethal concentrations of fallout in the first place: fallout shelters are a good idea because there is no location guaranteed not to receive lethal levels of fallout: it literally depends on which way the winds are blowing.) The big unknown in an all-out nuclear war is nuclear winter, which might end up causing most of the deaths, i.e., after the silos full of livestock feed are used up, but IMHO it is unlikely that nuclear winter would be that severe. In summary: nuclear war will not cause a collapse of civilization or societal order, at least not one sustained for more than a few weeks or possibly a few months.
- someonehere 2y agoSomething I read about six months ago was somewhat disturbing to me. It seems there was a commission formed to determine the likelihood of survival after an EMP attack on the United States. I don’t know the name of the report, but I know it was published in 2008. At any rate, the report concluded that if the United States was hit with an EMP attack within one year 90% of the population would die. This was back in the 2000s when we weren’t as dependent on technology as we are today. I can’t imagine what that report would be like for today’s world.
- SkyPuncher 2y agoThe US getting hit with an EMP attack is essentially a nuclear war situation. It’s not shocking that 90% of people will die.
- WalterBright 2y agoI figure 99% would die. How many of us know how to live off the land? I've watched enough of "Alone" where even the experts cannot manage it. A farming community could survive, until an army of 100000 hungry people overruns it.
- egberts1 2y agoHow to live like a caveman in a post-nuclear age. Your first order is 3' of earth coverage for your shelter's wall and ceiling: this provides the most protection from initial nuclear blast radiation. Second order is ammos and firearms: they too must be stored in shelter due to metal radiation. Third order is 120-day iodine tablets per person: covers the residual radiation fallouts, prevents thyroid cancer. Fourth order is water supply for a year or more. A buried tank. Rainwater runoff after 3 raining months in a clean covered barrel, distill those before drinking. Fifth order is food supply, dry goods (beans, rice, corn meal) as well as seed supply for your Victory Garden (in your backyard); including garden tools and cookware Sixth order is bartering; tiny bars of gold and silvers as well as salt (meat preservatives), sugar and herb, including saffron (for rare item barters with one who has it all). These should be buried instead of inside your home or safe. Generators are a pain; learn to live without electricity. Cheap Chinese 2-way transceivers are good with rechargeable batteries. A solar panel or two is useful.
- fortran77 2y agoThere are many scenarios where just being able to be safe for 24 or 48 hours makes a big difference, like the people in Kfar Aza who were able to secure themselves during the Hamas massacre. You may be able to survive an invasion or massive civil unrest if you had a safe-room that was relatively resistent to gunfire, small explosives, or fire for even one day.
- s5300 2y ago[dead]
- jacobsenscott 2y agoThese scenarios are so rare as to not be worth the money or effort. Meanwhile people don't take the slightest effort to defend against things ruin lives on a wide scale - saving for retirement, exercising, eating healthy food, quitting toxic (jobs|relationships|habits)...
- Stratoscope 2y agoI was a young child in Eugene, Oregon around 1960. Our house was one of the first on the block. The next lot up the hill hadn't started construction yet, but they had cut down the trees. We made paths under the fallen trees, brought in blankets and had picnics there. We called it The Rough Country. The house just down the hill was under construction, but for some reason the construction paused for several months. They had built the foundation and the most awesome feature: a bomb shelter! We made this our clubhouse, brought snacks and held our neighborhood kids' meetings to discuss important issues like Duck and Cover. And of course we made frequent field trips up to The Rough Country. What a great time it was to grow up!