4 ms·
Nvidia denies pirate e-book sites are "shadow libraries" to shut down lawsuit
- even_639765 2y agoI have another take on this dispute. We permit copyright because we reckoned it incentivizes a social good. AI is a bigger social good. An additional condition of copyright should be to submit your text to the pool of text available to AI. AI is that important, that revolutionary, that beneficial.
- bediger4000 2y agoIncentivizing a social good (increasing the public domain) may have been the rationale many years ago, in the days of the venerable founding fathers, but we now treat copyright as ownership of ideas.
- DowsingSpoon 2y ago>AI is a […] social good. Citation needed.
- squigz 2y agoJust out of curiosity, do you believe the Internet is, on average, a "social good"?
- e44858 2y agoAI is good for the elite that control it, not so good for the rest of society.
- impossiblefork 2y ago> "Nvidia [...] denies that hosting data in or distributing data from the data repositories necessarily violates the US Copyright Act," Nvidia's court filing said. What's allegedly claimed seems extremely strange since downloading copyright works without having obtained a license has been prosecuted very actively. I don't see how there's any legal uncertainty at all here. If you own a book you can scan it and train AI on it, but if you don't, you can't legally download it even if you're only training AI on it. Simply, if this is permitted there's no copyright. After all, this is a matter of commercial activity, not just some person downloading a book which he can't afford and is curious about.
- Rochus 2y ago> downloading copyright works without having obtained a license This is not illegal in all countries. If Nvidia did that e.g. in Switzerland, there would be no legal issue. Only making copies or publishing works without permission would be an issue. So why should those sites be shut down for the whole world, if there are many countries where it is legal to download books from them? Countries where such downloads are illegal could use different technical means instead to prevent their citizens from doing so, not affecting the rest of the world.