3 ms·
Why Asia Stopped Having Kids
- syawaworht 2y agoAuthor is a right wing propagandist. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Hanania https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Hanania A web of potentially interesting data is presented, but no rigorous reasoning is involved. A lot of words to assert confirmation bias of “Asians are conformist”.
- gruez 2y agoFrom your link: >Richard Hanania is an American political science researcher and right-wing political commentator Being a partisan "commentator" automatically makes you a "propagandist" now?
- Fishkins 2y agoI don't have any prior knowledge about Richard Hanania, but the second sentence of that wiki page is > Between 2008 and the early 2010s Hanania wrote for alt-right and white supremacist publications under the pseudonym Richard Hoste. That seems much more serious than just being a "partisan commentator"
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gruez 2y ago>He acknowledged and disavowed his writing under the pseudonym when it was reported in 2023,[5][4] although a number of journalists note that Hanania continues to make racist statements under his own name.[3][7][4][6]
- throwaway5959 2y agoIn America? Have you been paying any attention to how insane the American right has become? We’re about to have a dude who fucks porn stars as President. Again. Oh and an insurrectionist.
- gruez 2y ago>Have you been paying any attention to how insane the American right has become? We’re about to have a dude who fucks porn stars as President. Again. Oh and an insurrectionist. The "the American right" isn't a monolith. So far as I can tell, he doesn't condone whatever trump did or the capitol hill attacks.
- markisus 2y agoNot a lot of substance to back up the author’s ideas. The author tries to explain why many East Asian countries stand out on different metrics like standardized testing and birth rates. He rejects “Confucius of the gaps” which is a cultural explanation while at the same positing a genetic disposition towards increased conformity and lack of ability to go off script. This is a “genetics of the gaps” explanation. There is no further genomic evidence put forward. Rather, the author creates many just-so stories to justify the data. Funnily, it seems that any way the data goes, the author can create a story. Here is what the author said after finding data that contradicted his prediction that Asian countries would have fewer traffic incidents. > I suppose we can save race science by invoking more race science. Asians are low on non-conforming behavior, but they’re also bad drivers, and maybe the impact of the latter is more important.
- simonblack 2y agoNot just Asia. It's a world-wide trend. The usual reason is: Better Female Health + Better Female Education = Lower Birth Rates. We need several generations of lower-than-replacement birth rates to reduce the world population down to more sustainable levels.
- Gibbon1 2y agoI follow someone that tries to do field research. What I get from her and stuff she links to is there are a few things at work. More education and opportunities for women means they choose to have fewer kids yes. And if motherhood is heavily policed and results in lost opportunities they have even less. Myself I think the drop from a fertility rate of above 6 to less than 3 is simply that taking care of infants and toddlers gets real old real quick. If birth control is available and child mortality is low that's what women (and men) choose.