5 ms·
I am a little tired of the "ideas are a dime a dozen" mantra. It implies they are all equally "cheap". Yes, anyone can dream up some silly idea and spout off al
by Mz 14y ago
I am a little tired of the "ideas are a dime a dozen" mantra. It implies they are all equally "cheap". Yes, anyone can dream up some silly idea and spout off all day long about it and accomplish absolutely zilch. My dad was an armchair politician who had a "brilliant solution" to every social ill imaginable and never got off his duff to implement any of his ideas. So he never really got real world feedback concerning which ideas had merit and which were him just blowing smoke up everyone's ass.
But that does not mean all ideas are equally cheap and worthless. They aren't. Good ideas are like the DNA of a product or service. Separating the wheat from the chaff is the purpose of executing and iterating. And don't confuse ideas with how people initially attempt to express what's rolling around in their head. People often don't know how to really effectively communicate such things. Iteration is often just an exercise in trying to figure out how to properly express the underlying idea. That is what pivoting is often about.
Good ideas are not a dime a dozen. They aren't all that common. They are testable, the way Einstein's Theory of Relatively is provably a more accurate concept than Newtonian gravity.
- j2labs 14y agoThe artist is nothing without the gift, but the gift is nothing without the work.
- joshu 14y agoI think what people typically call ideas should actually be called something else. I like the term "seeds" - plant it and it will grow into an actual idea. Execution is the water with which it grows.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoA big difficulty I think is that some people have a tendency towards idea reductionism. The idea for the iPod was a great one, but reducing that idea to its bare essentials of "I want to create another mp3 player" leaves a lot to be desired. But there are also some ideas that are so elegant and straightforward to implement that they can't be diminished by over simplification and they are valuable all on their own (hesco barriers being a perfect example). And there are some ideas that are tricky to express correctly and to execute but are still incredibly valuable. Ideas aren't everything, but they're a lot more than nothing as well.
- Mz 14y agoWith genuinely new ideas, communication can be extremely hard. Existing language is rooted in existing context. If the idea is paradigm changing, the language to express it doesn't really exist. Attempts to talk about it can be very frustrating. The listener may hear something completely different from what the speaker was trying to convey. I run into this all the time when trying to talk about how I got myself well. It is a proven concept in some sense as it worked for both me and my sons. But that doesn't automatically give me the ability to effectively convey it to other people. I continue to struggle with that piece of it.
- keithpeter 14y ago"My dad was an armchair politician who had a "brilliant solution" to every social ill imaginable and never got off his duff to implement any of his ideas. So he never really got real world feedback concerning which ideas had merit and which were him just blowing smoke up everyone's ass." Part of what I do outside work is help out with housing cooperatives in the UK. We put ordinary not very rich people in charge of their homes. They become the landlord. Targets include < 4% void rent in any year, < 28 days property vacant &c. Real decision making and budget responsibility (landlord liable for repairs) works wonders. You can see people grow taller, and many now have supervisory jobs...
- Mz 14y agoI and my two sons are currently homeless. One of our big complaints about many of the programs intended to help us is the assumption we are incompetent, lack agency, should be "grateful" to a degree that amounts to agreeing to be their bitch, etc. Kudos on being involved with something better than that model.
- keithpeter 14y agoUK: housing cooperatives are incorporated as Housing Associations. Many in the Scandinavian countries as well. I thought the values of the coop movement would translate to US quite well (independence, responsibility &c) assuming you are in US. Coops are fully mutual, you can't buy only rent, but there are self build schemes for participant purchase as well. I do envy the rental sector in US. UK has issues with artificially high prices (my opinion) preventing a free market rental sector from emerging.
- Mz 14y agoLast I heard, coop housing has serious barriers in the U.S. I think those barriers are largely rooted in the housing finance infrastrucure born post WWII. The "boys" came home, often had high savings and no kids, "Rosie the Rivetter" was encouraged to quit her job so a man could have it, many women did so quite happily so they could have kids and the fulltime mom thing. Prior to the war, we were deep in The Great Depression and many people moved every thirteen months to take advantage of one free month's rent if you could pay rent in full and on time for twelve months straight. People were doubled up in small homes, etc. Levittowns were born to meet the sudden demand for single family homes. The nation created finance mechanisms to facilitate the birth of these instant suburbs. We are still living with the legacy. It can be extremely difficult to arrange financing for anything other than a single family home.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoActually ideas are very much like armchair political solutions. Often easy to state, and often very hard to do. There is even an axiom that goes "For every difficult problem there is a solution that is both easy to do and wrong." or something like that. The reason ideas are so cheap is that they are only the reflection of an action, not the action itself. Often folks take what they 'want' and then ponder a way to 'get' that and poof! idea. Like "I 'want' to work on my car's engine computer, all I need to do is take the engine out and mount it on an engine stand and hook it up to my laptop!" Simple idea, remove the engine and instrument it, but actually doing that is a lot of work. (doable, just a lot of work). But this can also be a useful tool. Ideas that aren't a lot of work to implement but seem to have high value are usually useless. And if you can't tell why they are useless then it is sometimes worthwhile to pursue them enough to understand where the real work is. But take something that is pretty much pure software. Let's take electronic publishing briefly. You have no doubt read a paperback book, you've no doubt read one (or looked at one) on an e-reader. All words, no pictures, just chapter breaks, perhaps the occasional font change to represent internal vs external dialog. Why can't I cut the spine off my old paperback, feed it into my Fuji Scansnap1500, and have it drop a .epub file that works on a kindle/nook/ipad/whatever ? The scansnap will give me a nice PDF of that book, even searchable. Caliber will convert it into a horrendous epub file. Why isn't this a no-brainer? I'd pay $20 for that software, no problem. Idea, no execution. Marginal return on investment (while I would buy it if it worked well, there is no assured market here) There are bodged together ad-hoc solutions out there. Clearly there is some demand but as Gabe called out, you need passion. You need to want to build this because you want it to exist. And that, that passion, is not there. I tell armchair politicians, hey run for city council. Solve problems. If you are good at it people will give you bigger and bigger problems to solve. If you aren't you'll both have an appreciation for what politicians are up against and a compassion for what they do get done. Not nearly as fun though. At a Tom Campbell said at a fund raiser once, its hard to appreciate the job from the outside.
- billpatrianakos 14y agoNo, ideas are a dime a dozen. You seem to think of ideas as "thought + action" but then it's not an idea anymore; it's a real product with an idea behind it. Your example of your dad is a perfect example of why ideas really are a dime a dozen. That mantra isn't about saying that ideas themselves are worthless, it's about the idea that ideas alone with no action are worthless. I think the mantra stands as correct still.
- Mz 14y agoSorry, I don't agree. There are some very important game changing ideas. The concept of zero is historically important. The concept of gravity is historically important. Those were not companies, they were only ideas. Yet they changed the world. So I don't think it is that simple.
- Negitivefrags 14y agoThe theory of gravity may just be an idea, but without execution it is still useless. Newton had to write a book to get his ideas out there and accepted.
- gaborcselle 14y agoThat "ideas are a dime a dozen" mantra upset a fair amount of people, especially combined with my assertion that I could easily brainstorm up good ideas in no time. I changed it (accurately asterisked) to "ideas are easy", which more accurately reflects what I think.