5 ms·
EV startup Fisker's collapse: how the company crumbled
- PaulHoule 2y agoIt ain’t easy making cars. Because cars are so familiar we don’t see them for the advanced, mature, technology they really are.
- mr90210 2y agoAlthough I don’t disagree with your statement, I think that Fisker’s issue was primarily rush to push something to the market. From what I saw in the reviews, perhaps with a little bit of patience, they could have release a solid product.
- constantcrying 2y ago>It ain’t easy making cars. Fisker doesn't make cars. They design and develop some parts of cars (e.g. they even bought an existing platform) to be produced by others. The product was far too late and underestimated how hard it is to just design the passenger facing elements of a car.
- flemhans 2y agoAfter Bollinger's no longer making cars, what's a good EV with no BS at all? No spyware, touch screens, etc?
- constantcrying 2y ago>what's a good EV with no BS at all? No spyware, touch screens, etc? Illegal to sell new, at least in Europe and US (see e.g. driver drowsiness detection) and very few people actually want such a car. The only reason to ever make such a car would be for low cost, production, but in the car industry low cost can only be achieved with high volumes and since such a car absolutely has no mass appeal it is a pretty dead concept.
- Angostura 2y agoYou can do things like drowsiness detection and keep it entirely local and private - in theory.
- roywiggins 2y agoIt kinda of has to be local, otherwise the car would be illegal to drive outside of cellphone service, wouldn't it?
- constantcrying 2y agoYes, but the drowsiness detection alone implies a huge variety of electronics inside the car. Besides drowsiness detection there is also emergency calling in case of a crash. So your car already has to have a significant central processor, GPS, cellular connection and all the other interconnections needed to make that work.
- dhbradshaw 2y agoI don't think we're as rare as you think we are.
- smt88 2y agoYou can be "not that rare" and still not worth producing a car for. We've seen the same thing with small phones.
- constantcrying 2y agoBesides the legal aspects (which prohibit sich cars from existing), such a car needs to be largely developed from scratch, as it obviously can't use any of the existing E/E, so a new one has to de developed, this includes essentially a new platform development with the new E/E. I can only guess the development costs, but they will be somewhere in the billions. There is no way any car manufacturer is stupid enough for that.
- renewiltord 2y agoNiche markets always think that. But often the cost of providing approaches the cost of independent design partnering with a manufacturer. So you're probably only 20% price increase away from co-opping it. And everyone who has tried to sell anything knows that "I would pay for that" are words most commonly spoken by people who assuredly would not pay for that.
- kwhitefoot 2y agoJust buy a car and get someone competent to do an EV conversion. That would probably be cheaper than a Bollinger anyway. "Bollinger says its pickup and SUV will each cost $125,000" https://www.inverse.com/innovation/bollinger-b1-b2-release-date-price-specs-range-hybrid https://www.inverse.com/innovation/bollinger-b1-b2-release-d... Sounds rather optimistic to me.
- smt88 2y agoNot sure about spyware, but Mazda committed to getting rid of touch controls for the actual functions of the car (shifting, A/C, etc.)
- moogly 2y agoYou're going to have to wait a while before Mazda releases a real EV. I think the MX-30 (their only BEV) is probably underrated as a very short range city car (I dunno why it's so reviled and the BMW i3 is a cult classic, and I've driven an i3s), but it does not work outside a city IMO.
- Marsymars 2y agoI've had the same thought about the MX-30. It's too pricey for my blood, but spec-wise it looks perfect for my two-car household that is going to maintain an ICE for out-of-city trips.
- pornel 2y agoMX-30 is a compliance car. It's a hybrid with the engine ripped out - there's literally huge empty space under the hood, but they haven't even bothered to move things around to make a frunk.
- Marsymars 2y agoSure, but the state of the market means there’s nothing better. The reasonable competitors don’t have equivalent battery capacity and extra space under the hood, they have extra battery, which for my use is worse than empty space, it’s extra cost upfront plus extra weight to lug around.
- pornel 2y agoMX-30 is not particularly light, nor spacious compared to other "city" EVs. I get that Mazda has a reputable brand, but MX-30 is just an F.U. to the state of California. Mazda sells less than 10 of them per month. Not ten thousand. Just ten. There are small-battery trims of many EVs in the similar price range, usually with faster charging and better range: Kona, MG4, e-C4, Zoe, e-208, Fiat e500, for a slightly higher price there's Volvo EX30. And among short-range difficult-to-charge cars Leaf is cheaper.
- semi-extrinsic 2y agoI haven't tried one, but the Dacia Spring looks to nicely fit this bill. Hopefully they will do a larger EV soon, something like a next-gen fully electric Duster or Jogger.
- throwaway4good 2y agoThe Sinclair C5.
- surfingdino 2y agoMelex!
- ajross 2y ago> no BS at all? No spyware, touch screens, etc If that's your definition of BS, then there's basically no vehicle on the market for you, with any energy source. But we can read the subtext: you want an EV but don't want to buy a Tesla. My advice to you is to rent a Model 3/Y LR for a few weeks from Turo or wherever and see if your actual problems are with the actual technical details you think are your problem. Most likely they're not, and in fact you're probably going to recoil from the idea of driving the car at all. In which case, well, at least you know to have the fight on the right grounds. "I hate Musk" is unfalsifiable, so the rest of us can stop trying to explain how well the UI actually works.
- AlbertCory 2y agoMaking cars is largely a manufacturing problem and a big company problem. It's not remotely like a software startup, or indeed, any startup.
- constantcrying 2y agoFisker isn't a car manufacturer. They didn't do the manufacturing. They even didn't do that much development on the actual car.
- dingaling 2y agoIronically, Henrik Fisker's first Fisker company (2007-16) was a coachbuilder for luxury marques, doing bespoke manufacturing.
- Rinzler89 2y agoFrisker doesn't really have manufacturing issues because they're not a manufacturer. They subcontracted manufacturing to a a partner with ~80 years of experience in car building and design.
- AlbertCory 2y agoOK, sorry, I missed that. But that bit about the wheel spacers is a classic "I don't understand the car-building business" mistake. And the customer service and spare parts issues are, as well.
- wannacboatmovie 2y agoCreating a "fabless" car company is up there with such great ideas like building basement apartments in Venice.
- Rinzler89 2y agoIDK what you mean. There are loads of niche fabless car companies. They won't be the next VW or Toyota so you wont find their dealerships everywhere and models for every budget, but they're fine catering to the wealthy man or woman who wants something different than your average mass produced luxury German, British or American car, to stand out.
- throwup238 2y ago> Fisker also did not set aside money to cover warranty repairs, according to the employees – marking another departure from a standard industry practice. Fisker sounds like an amateur operation through and through. On top of the spare parts reserves, one of the things manufacturers often do for a hardware product, especially something as expensive as a car, is find a warranty insurance underwriter. Their underwriter would have easily helped them avoid most of these problems as they've got a lot of experience auditing manufacturing lines and products for serviceability. > Many were told at the time to tackle the backlog of unprocessed title and registration paperwork, which had left hundreds of customers without permanent license plates. > The company had already scrambled to perform an internal audit to track down the missing $16 million in customer payments. Is there a phrase that means the opposite of "attention to detail?" Every little detail is a shitshow
- bink 2y agoI don't really get the criticism of spare parts availability. Obviously that's incredibly frustrating for people who need service, but it seems unrealistic to expect a vehicle manufacturer who is producing only hundreds of cars per year to keep a surplus of spare parts around for every possible part. Each part they keep in surplus is potentially one less car out the door. It's one of the risks of being an early adopter.
- cjbgkagh 2y agoThey should be keeping a surplus of components for supply chain disruption reasons, bulk discount reasons, on top of the 100% necessary customer replacement parts reasons.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- throwup238 2y agoIf the manufacturer doesn’t have spare parts to repair vehicles, customers can trigger state lemon laws. In California that means either refunding the full purchase price or replacing the car entirely. That’s what the lemon lawsuits mentioned in TFA are about. Without spare parts, entire sales get nullified and the refunded cars can’t be resold as new.
- jsemrau 2y ago“The lack of processes and procedures was kind of mind-blowing,” sigh
- Rinzler89 2y agoThey're where Tesla would have been years ago without the charismatic visionary hip billionaire and the charging network and the low interest rates.
- AnotherGoodName 2y agoThey are currently pointless to buy at any price due to the collapse at this point. Eg. a common problem is the key fob stops working and you can't get into the car. Without any company behind the car how to you get this fixed? It'd be really nice if documentation+code for these was made public but this likely won't happen so you can't buy one of these even as a hacking hobby.
- solatic 2y ago> you can't buy one of these even as a hacking hobby I'll pay $100 for your massive paperweight. Maybe I'll figure it out, maybe I won't, but the potential of getting a car like that for a price like that is definitely worth the $100 + towing fees to me.
- ein0p 2y agoFirst of many, I feel. Viability in this space depends heavily on economies of scale, and whoever gets there first has a massive moat. On a positive note, Fisker really helped to separate the wheat from the chaff by heavily and obviously bribing the reviewers on social media. It was like “what am I to believe, your review or my lying eyes?” when it was obvious in the video the car was poorly made, yet the reviewer provided glowing commentary.
- nixass 2y agoIt's like Android phones 10-12 years ago. There were dozens of manufacturers who sold all kinds of crap. Eventually market consolidated, companies died and here we are with few major companies and some niche players. EV market will follow with expectation that one or two major companies will collapse too
- bilbo0s 2y agoLast minute design change: Wheel Spacers Why? It makes car look cooler. Just. (Facepalm) The engineers probably loved that. /s Folks, the geometry of your drive train was painstakingly designed by engineers who put a lot of effort into getting a lot that geometry correct. Wheel spacers? Just don't. Pick a reason. Change in geometry causing sub optimal shifts in loads. Or poorly designed spacers causing wheels to fly off. Or even the fact that the bearings weren't designed with the spacer in mind, and all the problems concomitant with that fact. Just don't. That executives at a car company thought this was a good idea? I don't even know what to say to that? But I do think that for an experienced engineer it should have been a kind of canary in the coal mine. If this can happen? Yeah, this company is going nowhere fast.
- surfingdino 2y agoI'm trying to resist the urge to list the number of times an idiot "non-technical visionary" overrode design and implementation of the software the teams I was on were building.
- wslh 2y agoI wonder why TechCrunch doesn't link to their (own?) Crunchbase info about the company [1] to analyze the history of the company further. Also Yahoo Finance [2] gives more context beyond the bankruptcy. Saying this because I was not following the company and many times quantitative information gives you a quick insight. [1] https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/fisker https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/fisker [2] https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/FSRN/ https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/FSRN/
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> many times quantitative information gives you a quick insight Did you happen to find one with these data?
- wslh 2y agoI don't know if a confussion arised? There is quantitative information available because the company is public.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoI asked if those data lead you to any insights. I wasn’t able to find anything compelling that the title, noting the company’s collapse, didn’t convey more concisely. More data absent insights just lowers the SNR.
- wslh 2y agoI said that there is more quantitative data. It is not noise because it is data about a public company. I see in your profile that you know about what we are talking about so I assume you can go to places like [1]. [1] https://investors.fiskerinc.com/financials/quarterly-results/default.aspx#:~:text=Fisker%20reports%20preliminary%20Q4%202023,be%20recognized%20in%20future%20periods https://investors.fiskerinc.com/financials/quarterly-results....
- 2y ago
- agrippanux 2y agoI've seen several Oceans driving around my city and the only thing I think is, "oh boy now there's someone who enjoys living on the edge".
- Animats 2y agoNone of the problems mentioned have anything to do with the cars being electric. They just sucked at running a car company. Could be worse. Remember Faraday Future? Even worse, Nikola and their fake truck.[1] [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4226hQc6-UU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4226hQc6-UU