5 ms·
Mathematicians Attempt to Glimpse Past the Big Bang
- light_triad 2y agohttps://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/JHEP10(2023)182.pdf https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/JHEP10(2023)18...
- kromem 2y agoAttempt, but at least so far seem to be on the side of "nope, we probably won't be able to."
- function_seven 2y agoIf a mathematician can determine the square root of -1, I have faith they’ll be able to “see” “prior” to the Big Bang.
- Qem 2y agoThey didn't actually determine it. The cheated by giving it a single letter variable name, and ran with it. It's the mathematical equivalent of buying using a rubber check that is never cashed, so everything is OK.
- kromem 2y agoI mean, you can have faith in whatever you want, but if you read to the end of the article the mathematicians themselves are the ones saying the conditions seem more to agree with the scenario where they won't.
- SubiculumCode 2y agoIf the Big Bang happened.
- nico 2y agoI have no mathematical justification for this However, my intuition and direct perception of my reality, makes me think of the universe more like a big (potentially never ending) cycle I don’t think there is a beginning (probably no end either) Was the chicken or egg first? To me that doesn’t make sense. They both need each other, there is no first, there is just both in an alternating cycle Kind of like everything… at least that I can observe, from my own subjective point of view
- brookst 2y agoAs I understand it, the big bang is not a moment where everything started and time just went from not existing to existing as we know it now. Instead, it’s more like a singularity, where the ideas of “beginning” doesn’t even make sense, in the way that 1/sin(x) has a discontinuity that you really wouldn’t call “the beginning of sine”.
- nico 2y agoThat is a great observation I can think of states of cycles “mediated” (or alternated), by “unknowns” For example, if I have a cycle that produces 1,0,1,0,1,0… I could say there is an unknown between 0 and 1 that flips between the two, but it’s something different than 0 or 1 (like an operation/action) To me, it seems like the universe is an “unknowably” large/complex fractal of recursive cycles Or in other words, turtles all the way down Actually, it’s more like superimposed (rather than recursive or going in any direction) Recursion needs to have a base case to terminate. But the basic cycle of the universe doesn’t seem to terminate (although it’s also technically unknowable for my limited finite perception in time, which it seems certain will terminate at some point)
- XorNot 2y agoI'm more surprised you don't take a more quantum mechanical view of the problem. At vanishingly small scales, we know particles can come into existence provided they leave existence quickly enough to not effect the overall energy balance - but they're quite real, they mediate how forces in our universe operate, and have measurable parameters. It does not seem inconceivable that all of space-time could be a similar sort of event: an bubble of higher-rules coming into existence spontaneously, and necessarily structured to not violate the rules of whichever higher-level system governs it (moreover: this could just be quantum mechanics, the same rules as us, operating at a large scale). Which then gets to the interesting stuff: Poincare recurrence[1]. Dynamical systems after long but non-infinite times return to existing states - aka if the universe were regarded in such a way, then there is large but not infinite amount of time before it will return to either the "big bang" start state, or on an even longer timescale, any actual moment in time that ever happens. Which is somewhat solipsistic of course, because it's all infinities anyway: an exact version of your atoms re-existing at multiple distantly separated points in time would be a multi-verse of sorts, just across another dimension: and of course if it's the same atoms, doing deterministically the same things, then it's essentially the same consciousness - so all those spaced repetitions of events aren't meaningfully distinct, so they're kind of the same...except they're also infinite, because they can just keep recurring. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poincar%C3%A9_recurrence_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poincar%C3%A9_recurrence_theor...