4 ms·
How many holes does the universe have?
- perihelions 2y agoDoes the topology of the universe mix the space and time dimensions? Or would it be nonsense to have timelike loops on a cosmological scale? (Like with the torus example–one loop in a spatial coordinate, the other in a time coordinate). They're talking about *three*-dimensional manifolds so I assume it's an automatic no, but I don't have the background to understand why it's an obvious no.
- pavel_lishin 2y agoI also share your assumption, and also share your ignorance! I have no idea. Closed time-like loops are possible (mathematically, at least), but I don't know if that's something that can be a consequence of the universe's shape.
- soulofmischief 2y agoIt's important to understand what "time" is. To construct a clock, we must have some sort of device which exhibits exact periodicity, and use it as a frame of reference. This is the only way we can measure the passing of "time", via referencing some periodic phase change. Modern atomic clocks observe the oscillation of states in a Cesium atom to define the Second. The quantum nature and energy potentials involved at this atomic scale lead to an exact, measurable periodicity. Einstein essentially describes a "clock", wherein a particle (or EM wave) periodically travels between two spatially distinct points A and B. First it travels from A -> B, and then back from B -> A, striking a sensor on both sides. That is one pulse. We would then reference all timekeeping via some coefficient of that pulse. Let's assume this particle is traveling at the constant "speed of light", the highest possible speed for a massless particle that we have observed. In a "stationary" frame of reference, the amount of "time" it takes for the particle to go from A -> B should be the same as B -> A, so we can say 1 pulse is 2AB, twice the distance of A to B. But what happens if A and B are both moving in the direction of A -> B at the same speed? Well, we could imagine that it would take the particle longer to travel from A -> B than before, but quicker to travel from B -> A by the same factor. Yet, when we conduct such an experiment from the same co-moving reference point (when we move alongside A and B at the same speed), we discover that sensors on both ends confirm that the "time" it takes for the particle to travel from A -> B is still the same exact amount of time that it takes to travel back from B -> A. What gives? How can this be possible, if the particle is not able to increase its speed while traveling from A -> B, since it already is traveling at the maximum observed speed of light? Well, when we instead measure the particle's travel from a stationary reference point outside A and B, we do in fact measure the results we expect. It does take longer to travel from A -> B than it does from B -> A. What??? How can we get two different measurements? Isn't there a single, objective reality? Well, it turns out, if we measure the distance from A to B while in the stationary outside frame, the distance shrinks with proportion to the speed of the moving A & B system. So because the distance shrinks, the "time" it takes to complete a round trip actually shortens. The particle doesn't gain more speed; it just has to travel less. But when we measure the distance while comoving with A and B, we find it hasn't shrunk. To make things worse, imagine A and B are inside a box. How would they ever know how fast they are really moving? Maybe they seem still, but are they orbiting a star? A galaxy? A cluster? So we can only discern movement by observing from an outside frame of reference, in the context of two or more distinct frames/objects. We can only measure a relative speed of any given object. From any particular frame, the "speed of light" seems to hold. That was the mental experiment which led Einstein to uncover the principle of special relativity. And we have since experimentally confirmed both spatial and temporal dilation. Because if space is dilating, our perception of time must be dilating as well, seeing as how the entire measurement of "time" in this scenario is rooted in the spatial distance traveled by the particle. Does this make sense? This is why we have "spacetime". Time is a direct consequence of measuring the spatial difference between two states of the universe. It's crazy, it's weird, and it asks the question of "what is the speed of light, and why is it relative?", but it's internally consistent and experimentally verified. To answer your question about timelike loops on a cosmological scale: the energy involved in maintaining the stability of such a system would be astronomically insane. Even the smallest of theoretical wormholes are rifled with issues concerning temporal stability. Under a very particular, theoretical construction of the universe, stable closed timelike curves could be possible, but it's not likely. Further reading: On the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/www/ https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/www/ Don't be scared to take a peek at the paper, it involves some light maths, but is largely conceptual and surprisingly digestible.
- drdeca 2y agoI don't see what the first part of your comment brings to the last part of your comment, the part which addresses the question. I think the question asked is maybe something along the lines of, "If we consider the pseudo-Riemannian manifolds with signature (3,1), considered up to topological equivalence, are all the topological differences between these, determined by the 3-dimensional spacelike slices (independent of choice of foliation)?"
- soulofmischief 2y agoI took it as OP seeking to understand how the topology of space and time are intertwined, and asking whether a spatially closed universe would also be somehow temporally closed. With this in mind, I felt like establishing the exact relationship between time and space might explain how a spatially closed universe would not necessarily be temporally closed, as the measurement of time involves the measurement of relative distance over multiple frames, which wouldn't necessarily change when measuring at the "boundaries" of a closed spatial loop (since these boundaries are themselves relatively defined) Apologies to OP if I misunderstood the question.
- jiggawatts 2y agoAn error in this type of thinking is that it assumes that the observer isn’t also made of light. In our physical reality all scientific instruments are made of matter, the behaviour of which is almost entirely determined by electromagnetic interactions. Any effect that changes the light clock somehow also changes co-moving observers identically! It’s like asking an a 2D character drawn on a rubber sheet if they think that the things they see on the rubber sheet are changing as that sheet is uniformly stretched. Relativity was formulated in a time before we were even sure that atoms exist.
- perihelions 2y agoI don't think you can have computational objects on lightlike (null) trajectories? If light is interacting with light (to have computation), it's effectively moving slower than the vacuum speed of light and the information is not on a null trajectory.
- antognini 2y agoYes, it does. Gödel found a solution to the Einstein field equations that shows that it is possible to have closed timeline curves on a cosmological scale under particular conditions. (The universe is rotating and has a carefully chosen value for the cosmological constant.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%B6del_metric https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%B6del_metric
- deadbabe 2y agoIf the universe is a donut, that means there could be an outer side and an inner side? Which one are we in?
- feoren 2y agoNo, that is a mistaken visualization that comes from embedding the donut in a higher space. No embedding is necessary, nor does anyone think the universe is embedded in anything larger. Think about PacMan, or the old Asteroids game, where going off one end of the screen would put you on the other side. That's a donut. (The 4 corners of the screen make up the single hole*.) Which "side" is the inside? The question doesn't make sense. *Edit: as rightly pointed out below, the location of the hole is an arbitrary choice that comes from trying to map the space to a sphere, and does not actually exist anywhere in the space itself. An interesting experiment is this: imagine yourself existing in the space, which is otherwise empty. PacMan alone in the middle of the screen. Throw a stretchy rope to yourself, horizontally or vertically, catch the other end, and tie it together. Then walk around the space without turning the rope at all. Notice that no matter how you walk around, the rope will always be the same length. Now imagine the same thing on the surface of a sphere. Walking around makes the rope larger or smaller, and there's always a point you can walk to where the rope will completely collapse to a single point.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- francoi8 2y agoI don't understand why the 4 corners of the screen make up the single hole. You could scroll the screen by 1 "square" which would change the corners which makes me feel there is nothing special about the original four corners.
- contravariant 2y agoYeah the corner can correspond to any one point on the torus. They are all the same point, but other than that there's nothing really interesting about the corner(s). The edges are more interesting, two of them go around the 'hole' of the 'donut' and the other two wrap 'around' the 'donut' itself (i.e. around the dough if it was an actual american style donut). There's no way to tell which is which. These edges have the interesting property that you can't shrink them to a point (compared to say a loop on a globe which you can make smaller until its a single point). Except when the donut is not hollow in that case one of the loops becomes contractible, turning the space into the equivalent of a circle.
- jbstack 2y agoI'm struggling to understand why the analogy of folding a piece of paper into a torus works. I can see that I can easily roll the paper up into a cylinder. But if I then want to bend that cylinder so that the two ends meet, I'd have to stretch the outer part the torus. This is clearly visible on their diagram where what were squares on the flat paper are wider on the outer part of the torus than on the inner. If I then unfold it, I won't have a flat piece of paper anymore. In other words, it seems to me, you cannot in fact make a torus from a flat piece of paper and the surface of a torus is therefore not flat. Additionally, looking at the torus diagram, straight lines that run from the outer part to inner part get closer together as they approach the inner, meaning that the distance between two "parallel" straight lines varies depending on where you are on the line. I didn't think a flat surface can have such a property. What am I missing here? EDIT: here is a stackexchange answer claiming that the surface of a donut-shaped torus is indeed not flat: https://math.stackexchange.com/a/4377256 https://math.stackexchange.com/a/4377256
- Icy0 2y agoYou're right that there are no (smooth) flat embeddings of a torus into 3-space. To understand how a torus can be flat, it's best to replace the idea of folding with the idea of placing portals on edges. Start with a square and put portals between the north and south edges and between the left and right edges. Intuitively this is flat, and this intuition does indeed capture the mathematical notion that a torus is flat.
- dmurray 2y agoWhy can't I do the same thing with the surface of a sphere? Take two circles, side by side, connected by an infinitesimally small overlap, and put portals all around the circles to their equivalent point in the other circle. Then fold this over and inflate it into a sphere. If you're suspicious about the discontinuity where they overlap, I think that's a red herring - no one is claiming the sphere is isomorphic to two disjoint surfaces of any shape. Alternatively, make it a cube. I can definitely fold a single piece of paper into a cube, or equivalently, I can put portals on my piece of paper to give it the topology of a cube. Intuitively that is flat. But the cube isn't one of the 18 forms proposed for the universe. Nor is any of the other millions of 3d shapes I can make with the same process.
- raldi 2y agoCan someone post a quick clickbait antidote for those of us stuck behind the paywall?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- moomin 2y agoSome theoretical physicists have demonstrated there are some theoretical models of the universe consistent with current observations that aren’t just regular spacetime. There’s no evidence _for_ exotic spacetime. Just there isn’t evidence that rules it out. The rest of it is an ELI5 explanation of topology concepts and pablum about how important this research is.
- loaph 2y agoWhat about more clickbait? > Because of the many twists, the universe could contain copies of itself that might look different from the original, making them less easy to spot in maps of the cosmic microwave background.
- ridgeguy 2y agohttps://archive.ph/czrqx https://archive.ph/czrqx
- labrador 2y agoI read the news today, oh boy Four thousand holes in Blackburn, Lancashire And though the holes were rather small They had to count them all Now they know how many holes it takes to fill the Albert Hall - The Beatles – A Day in the Life
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Optimal_Persona 2y agoI am not a physicist, astronomer, mathematician or anything like that. But as a lifelong musician who's learned a thing or two about acoustics, I am familiar with the topology of a space affecting the perception AND measurement of vibrations produced within it. Example - take a speaker with good bass response, play something through it holding it above the floor in the center of the room, then on the floor in the center of the room, then where the floor meets a wall, and finally in a corner where 2 walls meet the floor. You will perceive (and measure) a 3dB increase of low-frequency for each of the boundaries at that position. This is a trick I've used as a DJ to fill rooms with sound from very small speakers. Is there any way that the topology of the universe/higher dimensions could affect measurements of things like dark matter, etc.? Again probably a very naive question as I know not all modes of vibration are identical.
- wizardforhire 2y agoYou may know the reason why but for those that don’t… Bernoulli’s Principle, think thumb over a garden hose. The effect is most pronounced with low frequencies but occurs at all frequencies. We perceive loudness as an increase in pressure.
- bgoated01 2y agoI’ve not heard it described that way before; I would love to hear more of what you mean by this. The way I learned it in my upper level acoustics courses in college was image sources: hard surfaces are effectively mirrors for sound, so just like you see a copy of an object in an actual mirror, you hear a copy of the speaker coming as if from inside the wall. With three surfaces meeting in the corner, you effectively get 8 sound sources instead of just one. For low frequencies these virtual sources constructively interfere and make louder sound. Of course, this is just a more intuitive way of thinking of the effects of boundary conditions to a partial differential equation.
- mendelab 2y agoLight reflectors (e.g., for bikes) are also made out of many little corners to reflect the light to its source. For sound, it should be the same with a corner of a room, it ~doubles the sound in the vicinity of the corner, hence a ~3dB increase
- Simon_ORourke 2y ago> How many holes does the universe have? Well, there's Bakersfield CA, that's definitely one to start with. And a goodly part of New Jersey too.
- HocusLocus 2y agoOnly one. All back holes are connected in spirit. Occam's Razor also suggests it is all the same hole because there can only be one 'singularity'.