6 ms·
Civil society in Latvia, Lithuania, and Poland targeted with Pegasus spyware
- CherieGarza 2y ago[dead]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- betaby 2y ago"Polish media reports say Poland purchased Pegasus in 2017, using money from the so-called Justice Fund, which is meant to help the victims of crimes and to rehabilitate criminals." from the older 'scandals'. https://www.euractiv.com/section/politics/short_news/polish-government-accused-of-illegal-purchase-of-pegasus-software/ https://www.euractiv.com/section/politics/short_news/polish-... At that moment it's safe to assume that all EU govs use Pegasus against the public in general.
- eigenket 2y agoI don't think it's reasonable to assume all EU governments (or even all Polish governments) will act the same as PiS do/did.
- Etherlord87 2y agoAFAIK all uses of Pegasus were conducted after an agreement (a warrant) was issued from Polish courts - which were in opposition to the PiS government. If I'm right about this, doesn't it mean this particular affair unnecessarily demonizes PiS? Either way, I think it's very reasonable to *do* assume the worst of governments - as in we should strive to design the system to be able to withstand as much malice from people in power as possible.
- eigenket 2y agoI don't think it's accurate to say the courts were in opposition to the PS government. PiS appointed lots of their own judges in their years in power who often decided along lines that PiS wanted. The biggest example of course being the Constitutional Tribunal. Sure there were judges who opposed PiS, but there were plenty who did not. This guy, who is now in Belarus, is an example of one of PiS's pet judges https://notesfrompoland.com/2024/05/06/polish-judge-flees-to-belarus-seeking-asylum/ https://notesfrompoland.com/2024/05/06/polish-judge-flees-to...
- Etherlord87 2y agoSure, but - again AFAIK - the judges issuing the warrants weren't the judges appointed by PiS.
- eigenket 2y agoI have seen no evidence either way on that.
- betaby 2y agoI think it is in fact reasonable. Private persons are unlikely to have means/connections to acquire Pegasus while victims are all around EU, see another link below. https://www.dw.com/en/spain-court-reopens-investigation-in-pegasus-spying-scandal/a-68901546 https://www.dw.com/en/spain-court-reopens-investigation-in-p...
- eigenket 2y agoThere are not many examples of the government hacking opposition politicians an en leaking damaging material to friendly "news" agencies for political gain https://notesfrompoland.com/2023/12/18/polish-state-tv-ordered-to-apologise-over-publishing-messages-of-politician-hacked-with-pegasus-spyware/ https://notesfrompoland.com/2023/12/18/polish-state-tv-order... Law and justice are a particularly extreme example.
- peterfirefly 2y agoDidn't Merkel have the Bundesamt für Verfassungsschutz spy on her political opposition?
- eigenket 2y agoI haven't seen anything about that, but if she did then thats disapointing
- d_theorist 2y agoWhat is meant by "civil society" in this article?
- swifthesitation 2y agocivilians
- nonameiguess 2y agoIt would appear the targets are all journalists. I think they're using this phrasing to denote that they're civilians.
- lupusreal 2y ago"Civil society" implies the existence of uncivil people; it's good guys vs bad guys, not civilian vs military. If Ukraine targeted civilian organizations in Russia, the headline wouldn't call it an attack on "civil society" (but Russian media might.)
- samatman 2y ago> "Civil society" implies the existence of uncivil people It does not. You are conflating: civil 2b: adequate in courtesy and politeness : MANNERLY with civil 4: of, relating to, or involving the general public, their activities, needs, or ways, or civic affairs as distinguished from special (such as military or religious) affairs https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/civil https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/civil You can see that 'uncivil' does not include in its meanings an antonym of civil 4: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/uncivil https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/uncivil
- lupusreal 2y agoYou're being naive. Propaganda often employs double meanings, subtext and implications. This kind of language would not be used if the actors were reversed.
- bragr 2y agoThis kind of spying seems necessary and appropriate to me, provided it is done under the appropriate legal framework. The security concern with Russia and Belarus are self evident now, and the security concerns around hosting a large dissident population must be enormous. You don't want extremists within the dissident movements (it'd bad if the Putin assassination was planned on your soil), nor penetration of the dissident movement by foreign intelligence (it'd be a bad if the opposition leader got novichoked on your soil). I'm not sure how else to address these kinds of problems in society except with some kind of well regulated security apparatus (making the big assumption that it is well regulated here).
- logicchains 2y ago>I'm not sure how else to address these kinds of problems in society except with some kind of well regulated security apparatus (making the big assumption that it is well regulated here). The whole populace being under surveillance is a much worse outcome than the chance of some politician being assassinated being relatively higher. Mass surveillance to prevent the latter seem absolutely in the worst interests of the average citizen; spying on people to protect the elites is what every nasty dictatorship does.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- trustno2 2y agoI think Russian security services work fully legally under Russian legal framework.
- duxup 2y agoI think we can differentiate between the rules, level of judicial independence, and different systems too. It's not all or nothing as far as the words "legal framework" goes.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- holmesworcester 2y agoI think a lot of people are mis-seeing these Pegasus attacks as a problem of political will ("we need sanctions on NSO/Israel!") or memory safety ("rewrite it in Rust!") when there is a deeper problem: parser complexity. Specifically, we're using context-sensitive and Turing-complete parsers up and down the software stack, which (at the Turing-complete level of complexity, says Gödel) guarantees that determined attackers can expect to discover an exploitable "weird machine." Folks should watch this panel and other talks by Meredith L. Patterson (co-collaborator and wife of the late Len Sassaman) and Sergey Bratus (previously at DARPA, now Dartmouth) to get a sense of the problem and the solution. https://youtu.be/8tAxHrntBJs?t=806 https://youtu.be/8tAxHrntBJs?t=806 These folks are saying that, just as the industry handled over-the-wire insecurity with TLS and e2ee (and not rolling our own crypto) we can handle device exploitability with well-described data and automated parser generation from those descriptions (and not rolling our own parsers, which these folks say should be verboten for the same reason as rolling one's own crypto: parsing is too hard for non-specialists to get right). Moreover, we don't have to redo the whole stack for it to be meaningful: big players can start using this tooling (e.g. https://github.com/UpstandingHackers/hammer https://github.com/UpstandingHackers/hammer) for parsers handling data from very untrustworthy inputs, such as message payloads sent to a phone number. Apple's Lockdown mode is a step in this direction, though in such a crude, "burn the village" way that it makes the phone almost unusable. But sacrificing usability shouldn't be necessary with current methods. If these folks can make safe parsers for PDF (https://www.darpa.mil/program/safe-documents https://www.darpa.mil/program/safe-documents) it should be possible for anything. Another great talk: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3kEfedtQVOY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3kEfedtQVOY
- divan 2y agoThank you for sharing these talks! I will never look at parsers the same way again.
- hulitu 2y ago> Pegasus attacks as a problem of political will ... when there is a deeper problem: parser complexity. There is a "problem of political will" but also the problem of stupid SW which tries very high to decode everything you throw at it. Some time ago it was "file format not recognized", nowadays it is a root exploit.
- myth_drannon 2y agofrom the article "...there is also no evidence suggesting that Russia, Belarus, or Lithuania are Pegasus customers. Latvia appears to use Pegasus, but the country is also not known for targeting victims outside of its borders. ...., Estonia does appear to use Pegasus extensively outside their borders, including within multiple European countries. " It would be very surprising to see Russia using Western tech such as Pegasus, you can't just outsource your spy tools to your enemies. They most likely have as powerful if not more technologies. This whole NSO spectacle is more about the subversive BDS movement than a genuine care about political suppression and spying on the citizens.
- lupusreal 2y agoIf they could get their hands on Pegasus tools, their use might be ideal for Russia if for no other reason than because it would sow uncertainty and confusion.
- myth_drannon 2y agoIt's like using GPS. Russians created Glonass because GPS is under US control and can be used to subvert their operations. Pegasus is linked to a West allied country and can be used to feed them false information.
- krzyk 2y agoPegasus is Israeli, I'm not sure it is "western". Israel is very lenient towards Russia.
- neoromantique 2y agoUsed to be lenient
- Etherlord87 2y agoI'm surprised this was the case for so long as Iran is a close ally of russia.
- greenish_shores 2y agoSide note: Just checked are non-Android Linux OSes targeted by this spyware. Apparently, there's no public info in favor of such. So probably, nope. It looks mostly targeted against Android and iOS only.
- servus45678981 2y agoThen I am switching to a feature phone Nokia by HMD
- alephnerd 2y ago> feature phone Nokia by HMD Sure, but it runs Android Go (embedded Android) or KaiOS (embedded Linux) out of the box. Any vulnerabilities that arises in Linux can also be weaponized on those OSes as well depending on when the OS image was deployed and whether or not the OEM supports upgrades and patches (generally they don't)
- greenish_shores 2y agoCheck out postmarketOS. Can run on a Nokia you're specifying, but not only :)
- alephnerd 2y agoEqually open to vulnerabilities. For example, there's an unpatched GLIBC vulnerability in Alpine Linux (which is the distro postmarket is built on).
- greenish_shores 2y agoCVE-2015-0235? What the hell? -2015- and still unpatched? But apparently it looks like the case. Anyway, Alpine seem to use musl instead of glibc.
- alephnerd 2y agoPackages will still call and use GLIBC - especially those that are cross-platform, because migrating your codebase to support a new ABI is a PITA. This is a classic example I use when explaining the need for SBOMs and Software Supply Chain Security to non-software C-suite.
- lupusreal 2y agoSecond time this week in which I've seen "civil society" used in a headline on HN. It's such a blunt euphemism they may as well write "the good guys".
- mikeyouse 2y agoIt’s a bog standard term that has nothing to do with 'good guys' or 'bad guys' - civil as in infrastructure not civil as in polite...
- hehdhdjehehegwv 2y agoLet’s not forget this technology all comes from IDF spying on Palestinians who basically have no legal rights. Injustice breeds further injustice.
- g8oz 2y agoSee the book "The Palestine Laboratory" for more on this. https://www.versobooks.com/en-ca/products/2684-the-palestine-laboratory https://www.versobooks.com/en-ca/products/2684-the-palestine...
- hehdhdjehehegwv 2y agoThanks for the rec!