4 ms·
You write "It's not a new market". Schnier writes "This is very different than in 2007, when researcher Charlie Miller wrote about his attempts to sell zero-da
by dalke 14y ago
You write "It's not a new market".
Schnier writes "This is very different than in 2007, when researcher Charlie Miller wrote about his attempts to sell zero-day exploits; and a 2010 survey implied that there wasn't much money in selling zero days. The market has matured substantially in the past few years."
I believe Schnier's point is that it's now an active market where it's much easier for buyers and sellers to meet, not that this is the first time exploits were for sale.
To think that Schneier believes that there was no market would be to think that Schneier did not accept the reported prices listed in the linked-to PDF by Miller.
- iuguy 14y agoHe uses the words new market to describe the thing four times in the article. It's very clear that to him it's a new market. Having said that his definition of new may be different to yours or mine. 5 years may still be new if you've been in an industry for several decades. Immunity Canvas has been on sale since the early 2000s, same with Core Impact. A lot of their marketing went into releasing 0day exploits. Exploit trading is as old as the exploits themselves. The value of an exploit is based on it's utility and effectiveness. A remote code execution in Windows is worth a fortune because Microsoft's strategy has been specifically to increase the cost and effort required to develop a reliable exploit.
- tptacek 14y agoAnd of course, 0-day exploit trading isn't news to Schneier; in the early-to-mid '90s, many serious Unix vulnerabilities were traded among vendors and admins on secret mailing lists. Of course, those lists were the laughingstock of the hack scene, and posted to tfile BBS's right next to cDc zine issues. They made the list participants feel a little more special, though, and they did keep vulnerabilities from being disseminated... to the majority of system operators.