6 ms·
> imaginary threat Err... while I'm not stepping in to defend the TSA, I think that to call the threat imaginary ignores recent history.
by davidw 14y ago
> imaginary threat
Err... while I'm not stepping in to defend the TSA, I think that to call the threat imaginary ignores recent history.
- fghh45sdfhr3 14y agoThe threat is absolutely imaginary. Obviously we have real threats, but that is NOT what the security theater is about. The security theater is mostly about purely imaginary threats. And is in fact worse at stopping the few real threats we have. Original security theater idea is from Bruce Schneier, Wikipedia link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Security_theater http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Security_theater
- davidw 14y ago> The threat is absolutely imaginary. Obviously we have real threats I'm not following you. Nor am I saying that I think the TSA is a good thing or an appropriate response to the threats.
- bestes 14y agoCan you please cite your example(s)?
- cjdavis 14y agoWhile the threat of terrorism is not imaginary, it is certainly negligible compared to other threats.
- jerf 14y agoThe physical terrorism threat is negligible. The generalized cheap-attack-with-disproportionate-damage threat I can't in good conscience write off quite so readily. Biological attacks are still scarily possible, and if we start talking computer viruses it becomes scarier again. Recall Stuxnet didn't merely inconvenience people, it destroyed hardware. If someone manages to write a virus that, say, destroys a significant number of power plant turbines, we're talking about a disaster that does in fact start killing people in addition to general inconvenience. Electricity really really is one of the lifebloods of civilization, and while the phrase lifeblood is obvious not literal it's more literal than it may appear on first glance. Cut it off and real people will really be hurt and killed. Personally I'd rate this class of threat comfortably above asteroid impact or solar flare-type disaster.
- kbolino 14y agoTerrorist victims in 2001: 3,000 Murder victims in 2001: 15,000 Car collision fatalities in 2001: 42,000 Cancer deaths in 2001: 550,000 The only thing that's disproportionate is how we react to terrorism. (statistics are for United States)
- jerf 14y agoThat's a canned knee-jerk response, not one that shows you read my message. That's not relevant data to the question of what future bioattacks or computer attacks are possible... and note my continued avoidance of the term "terrorism". Once an attack is launched the source isn't very relevant. Failing to secure our infrastructure because "terrorism isn't something to be afraid of" is still a stupid move because it leaves you open to not-terrorism just as much.
- ThomPete 14y agoBut the problem is that it ends up being a self-fulfilled prophecy. People without any part in the original conflict is getting affected by it and then suddenly they are part of it. That is the root of problems here.
- kbolino 14y agoMy original response was more thoughtful, but I felt that summed up my point better. The question is not what's possible, but what's likely and how much it will cost. If the likelihood is low and the cost is small, then you cannot justify extravagant preparation. An attack against civilian infrastructure is terrorism no matter who does it. It may be a singular event, part of a chain of attacks, or a prelude to a full-scale military offensive. It's still terrorism, because it terrorizes the civilian population. Irrational fear should not dictate our budget priorities. We can certainly take some precautions, and develop contingency plans. But at the end of the day, if someone is capable and determined enough, it's going to happen, regardless of how many much money and how many contractors and consultants we throw at the problem. The best we can do is take it in stride and rebuild.
- davidw 14y agoYeah, that's certainly something you can argue in good faith. I just disliked the "imaginary", which clearly is not true.
- mistercow 14y agoIt is an imaginary large threat based on a real small threat. Wolves that attack Puerto Rican goat herds in the night are real, but the mythological chupacabra based on them is still imaginary.