3 ms·
I mean, come on. Yes, Ben-Gurion, by modern standards (incl. the standards of his time), not a great moral leader. But neither was Thomas Jefferson! What you've
by tptacek 2y ago
I mean, come on. Yes, Ben-Gurion, by modern standards (incl. the standards of his time), not a great moral leader. But neither was Thomas Jefferson! What you've left out of that summary of who Ben-Gurion was: he founded Israel.
But more generally, you just haven't rebutted the parent comment. It would be weird for anyone to suggest Israel has human rights moral authority at this point (or at least any more so than any other major world power). But all the parent commenter said is that the UN doesn't have any either, which seems like a pretty easy argument to defend.
(As always, just nerding out).
- ben_w 2y ago> But all the parent commenter said is that the UN doesn't have any either, which seems like a pretty easy argument to defend. Do you need to defend the UN to make my (even earlier) comment about the UN criticising Facebook? I think my point still works even if the UN can only catch really egregious cases, those performed by those not of strategic political importance to one of the permanent members of the SC; and likewise also remains valid in the face of the organisation having a functional requirement to honour dead leaders who can at least pretend to have not been secret masterminds to the degree that Iran isn't officially at war with Israel despite the open acrimony.
- tptacek 2y agoNo idea. I was just making a nerd point.
- racional 2y agoI maintain that the UN actually does have some credibility (despite having also the same order of flaws as any humongous organization). If Israel disagrees, then it is welcome to withdraw its membership at any time.
- tptacek 2y agoPart of the point of the UN is that it never makes sense to withdraw your membership, even if you're at odds with the whole body. It's a useful forum, even if it's absolutely preposterous as a governing authority. At any rate, scoffing at UN decisions is hardly an Israeli idiosyncrasy. It would be weirder if a country of Israel's scale showed it reverence.