7 ms·
All of Microsoft's MacBook Air-beating benchmarks
- zer00eyz 2y agoAll for the low low price of M$ screen shotting everything I do.
- deagle50 2y agoTrivially multi-threaded benchmarks comparing 12 big cores vs 4 big / 4 little :/
- underlogic 2y agoIt doesn't matter, Windows is insufferable. Like a giant advertisement pretending to be an operating system. They need to start again from scratch or just simply give up and ship Ubuntu
- crims0n 2y agoIt has really gotten bad… hoping tradition holds and Windows 12 is better because there is potential here.
- bitwize 2y agoWindows, since 7, appears to suffer from a "law of conservation of awesomeness": any improvement in one area must be counterbalanced with at least a commensurate drawback in some other area.
- 9cb14c1ec0 2y agoI used to think it unlikely that ARM would take over Intel x86 on the desktop. Now I'm starting to believe that Intel's days are numbered.
- betaby 2y agoServer workloads are predominantly x86. Even with AWS/Azure/Oracle push it's not changing that much.
- tapoxi 2y agoHow many workloads are running in a compiled language though? I'm at a Java shop right now, and I realized I can save a ton on node costs by just running those existing workloads on ARM.
- fumeux_fume 2y agoIs there a benchmark for how many times my laptop gets bricked after an OS update?
- kyriakos 2y agoYou can blame windows about spying, telemetry and advertising but bricking your pc is not one of its problems.
- crims0n 2y agoKinda conveniently ignoring the elephant in the room that is M4.
- numpad0 2y agoNot really, Snapdragon X score is 14000 claimed in Geekbench MT, Apple M4 is 13401 published. Microsoft's requirement for these 1st gen "AI PC" is 45 TOPS of NPU performance, M4 "faster than any existing AI PC" is 38 TOPs advertised. It's marketing. Both sides. And those are just ARM laptop CPUs after all.
- kyriakos 2y agoM4 is not in a laptop product at the moment.
- jpalomaki 2y agoIs Surface Laptop using active cooling? It is pretty well known that MacBook Air sustained performance is limited due to thermals. People have been doing mods which transfer the heat to the frame. This gives big performance boost at the expense of hot computer on your lap.
- JohnTHaller 2y agoThe laptops with the new Snapdragon chips that folks have gotten actual hands on do use active cooling.
- peblos 2y agoYes, and fan is both loud and regularly running
- c6400sc 2y agoBut do we ackshually want to use Windows? The HN crowd is probably in alignment against, but Windows still rules outside of the major metros and tech sector. Sadly.
- vsnf 2y agoWhy sadly? I’m quite happy with windows, thank you very much. I have just as many gripes against MacOs as I’m sure you do against windows.
- emptiestplace 2y agoOhh, I don't know about that...
- NoPicklez 2y agoAbsolutely, I don't have a problem with it
- mattigames 2y agoThe less thing I want to use is MacOS[0], the only real alternative for me is a Linux flavor, which may be the case soon enough if keeps trying to pushing Copilot and other AI crap down my throat. [0] https://ivanca.tumblr.com/post/615979862803562496/ https://ivanca.tumblr.com/post/615979862803562496/
- noirbot 2y agoThat's... a 4 year old writeup that's mostly complaining about things that have since been fixed and were generally considered flaws at the time even by people who liked the OS/Hardware, and some of them are specific flaws to a specific model of laptop at the time. You're free to not like it, but if you're still holding on to that list of reasons, it's a bit like abandoning Windows because of the W10 rebooting issues and disliking the original Surface. There's been a lot of change and there's other options.
- 2y ago
- hajile 2y agoThere's so much wrong here: * 12 big cores vs 4p+4e CPU * active vs passive cooling * Ignoring that M4 exists * completely avoids single-thread performance even though that's what is most important to laptop users.
- dotnet00 2y agoIs ignoring M4's existence really 'wrong' given the fact that it isn't in macbooks yet? Are the benchmarks they mention possible on the iPad? Do the iPads benchmark similarly to the macbooks with the same chip? Does Apple also have to somehow properly benchmark against the not-yet-available highest end models of their competitor's chips for their numbers to not be wrong? It looks like it hasn't even been a month since the M4 was publicly announced, I think it's fair that that's just too soon for the benchmarks to make it into these early comparisons.
- DavidPiper 2y ago> Is ignoring M4's existence really 'wrong' given the fact that it isn't in macbooks yet? I don't think so, but it is a risky position to take. Presumably plans to publicly lean on that benchmark were in flight before the M4 was announced, so they went ahead with it anyway. I think it's risky because: assuming the M4 delivers the performance we'd expect from another Apple Silicon evolution - and releases in non-mobile devices this year - your marketing headline effectively becomes "hey, our best is only better than our competitor's last generation [and our competitors are already better]"
- dotnet00 2y agoThat's a risk they all take. AMD and NVIDIA (or Intel) have the same thing happen all the time, one of them has to go first, and usually there's not much of a gap between their announcements, and thus each risks being overshadowed by the other or sometimes even forcing them to cut prices or cancel a product as a result because the first one's announcement happens to make it completely pointless.
- 2y ago
- heywire 2y agoWhat I want to know…can it run Linux? And can it run Linux better than a M3 MBA? I don’t want Windows. I don’t want MacOS. I want a thin, efficient, fast, light, affordable replacement for my aging Latitude 7370 running Linux.
- numpad0 2y agoWhy would you be so obsessive about thin and light? Making hardware thin and light costs money and performance.
- dotnet00 2y agoThin and light is better for portability, if I didn't care about portability I'd just use my far more powerful desktop.
- noirbot 2y agoBecause the point of a laptop is to be portable? And a large chunk of that is being small and light? I could haul my full desktop and monitors around with me, but it's not worth the tradeoff. If I can get a computer that does 70% of what my desktop can do at a tenth of the weight and size, that's worth the money.
- jitix 2y agoIMO for many people a laptop means highly portable, wire free 'desktop' computing experience that you can't get on a tablet. Therefore the comparison for mobility is with a tablet and not a powerful Windows laptop. Plus many people working in tech have specific systems for specific tasks; I use a spec'ed up Windows laptop for heavy lifting and games, and an M1 Air as my main computer.
- numpad0 2y agoBut at the same time, many people also asks for performance improvements, and sometimes extra few USB A ports too. Plenty people makes hyperbolic claims such as which Apple Mx CPUs has x times more computation than which NVIDIA GPUs, superficially focusing on raw CPU performances. I know deep down that thinnest laptops with brightest displays sells the most in reality, marketing wise, but it just sounds a bit hypocritical to me.
- joshmarinacci 2y agoI’m not a regular Windows user, but now when someone asks what’s the Windows equivalent of a MacBook Air I’ll have a decent answer.
- NaOH 2y agoLifetime Apple user since before there was even a Mac. I just hope these are great pieces of hardware, whether in one area or another Macs or these perform better. Good quality, affordable hardware available for any OS platform would be great for users.
- qnleigh 2y agoAre there benchmarks that test usability? I don't care how long it takes to encode a 4k video. I care about how long the UI hangs while doing basic tasks or how many work-arounds I have to look up on Reddit to get my Bluetooth headphones pairing reliably. Looking at you, Windows...
- mikeweiss 2y ago"It’s also important to note that, unlike Apple’s MacBook Air, Microsoft’s new Surface Laptop isn’t fan-less, allowing it to squeeze more performance out." And there ladies and gentlemen is the catch... What a totally laughable and unfair comparison. Wake me up when it's fanless
- bitsandboots 2y agoThere's nothing unfair about fans. They're not new technology and apple is allowed to use them too. And they do, in a way that is barely noticeable. If you do it right it's fine.
- mikeweiss 2y agoApple DOES use them and Microsoft chose not to compare their product to the MacBook Pro clearly because it wouldn't have benefited them to do so "There's nothing wrong with fans" -- sure nothing wrong with them as long as you don't mind the extra noise, energy usage, point of failure and an entry point for dust and other crap into your laptop. Give me a break! Passive cooling is the future for personal computing.
- bitsandboots 2y agoBut as you point out, apple does have fans and in the m-series laptops they're done in such a way that they're nearly silent, or off. So, they really do not contribute meaningfully to noise, energy, or failure. They help with the burst workloads that a PC may encounter. Designing a PC to require the fan always be on is a sign of inefficient design, but designing a PC to specifically avoid a fan is to just let your competition beat you.
- EternalFury 2y agoDoes performance degrade over time like with all other Windows installations? What I like about Linux and macOS is that performance remains stable and battery life is excellent.
- dantiberian 2y agoThe Surface Laptop scored 1,745 on the Procyon AI Score, while the MacBook Air managed 889. Qualcomm’s Snapdragon X Elite has 45 TOPS of AI acceleration performance, much more than the 18 TOPS found on the M3. TOPS (Trillion Operations Per Second) is a meaningless score without including the precision. Are they INT4, INT8, INT16 or FP16? Microsoft's qualifications for a Copilot+ laptop require 40 TOPS at INT8: https://www.theregister.com/2024/05/21/qualcomm_windows_microsoft/ https://www.theregister.com/2024/05/21/qualcomm_windows_micr.... The new Snapdragon X Elite can do 45 TOPS at INT8. Apple's M3 has 18 TOPS, and their M4 has 38 TOPS, but the M3 was measured at INT16 and the M4 at INT8: https://www.anandtech.com/show/21387/apple-announces-m4-soc-latest-and-greatest-starts-on-ipad-pro https://www.anandtech.com/show/21387/apple-announces-m4-soc-.... Cutting the precision in half lets you do ~twice the amount of work. The Snapdragon is very impressive, but it's silly to see TOPS claims from companies repeated by journalists without adding some context.
- zhyder 2y agoAs a long-time Mac user, I'm actually eager to switch to Windows: more hardware innovation happening with more options in that ecosystem (e.g. in dual screen laptops like Asus Zenbook Duo). Windows has a few rough edges but my usage is dominated by the browser and terminal, which are similar on both Mac and Windows. Great to see these ARM-on-TSMC benefits of performance and battery life land in the Windows ecosystem.
- ssahoo 2y agoHow is the battery performance?
- ngcc_hk 2y agoWhen your advertisement is all about your enemy which does not, unlike old intel version, cannot even run yours and hence is totally different market sort of … one should be worried about you.
- thunkshift1 2y agoThis should be a comparison with mac pro not macbook air.