3 ms·
> As far as I understand it's a jury trial which means it wasn't up to the judge to make the call. IANAL but I've done some jury-duty: As a general rule the ju
by Terr_ 2y ago
> As far as I understand it's a jury trial which means it wasn't up to the judge to make the call.
IANAL but I've done some jury-duty: As a general rule the judge is responsible for determining things like "which laws are involved here", and when there's a jury the judge creates instructions that cover the rest of it like: "The law says X. The question of Y is not relevant and you should not let it affect your decision. You must convict if ((A and B) or C)."
So in a jury trial the judge might rule "those aren't actually charges you can make", but not so much "that evidence is fake" or "that person is lying" etc.