6 ms·
Feynman's Clock
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoThe letter to his dead wife is deeply touching, and the last sentence made me laugh and cry. It seems important to note that those of great acheivement still feel normal human emotions, and those who aspire to great acheivement should not try to avoid feeling normal human emotions - lest they become, well the president of Syria. Thank you danso.
- voodoochilo 14y agoindeed.
- slurgfest 14y agoAlthough I liked this post, I don't know who is trying to avoid feeling normal human emotions. Is this directed at some group?
- TheSOB88 14y agoProbably something he's felt at some point or another.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoBit late but ... There is a meme that great scientists, all great achievers, are somewhat other, not normal, aloof unfeeling cold calculating machines. That's how they do it. The story of the stopped clock could be used to bolster that fallacy The letter clearly, lucidly, funnily, and touchingly blows apart any concept that Feynmann was cold unfeeling or somehow other. Just seemed important to note that great achievement is not incompatible with great passion and humanity. C.f. The president of Syria for how MIT to do it.
- hbvybwkjn 14y agoWhile reading the letter to his wife I felt a sense of guilt and stopped reading. Why is it that after a person's passing their right to privacy is no longer respected? While they are alive to read and publish such information without consent would be bad, but why is it OK after their passing? Even if they will not feel the pain of the invasion of privacy, that does not give someone else the right to expose such information. I think for the good of the group should only extend until it starting impinging on the rights of the individual.
- danso 14y agoI don't necessarily agree or disagree with you, because it's hard to make any argument given with how you frame the question. What does it mean that the deceased Feynman has rights? In life, it would be illegal (in America) for a hospital to disclose that he once came in for a flu shot. But it is completely legal to get a coroners report which explains the cause of death and all other related medical details. It doesn't make sense to discuss "rights" because Feynman as an alive human is not the same as Feynman dead. I know you're not talking about legal matters, but some of the issues behind libel and speech law are derived in part from moral concerns. As a side note, it's not all together clear that it would be illegal to publish something like this were he still alive, as he would be considered a person of public interest. Now, the issue of whether it's bad? That's strictly a taste thing. Had the author of e biography chosen to publish any and all seedy letters found in Feynman's private collection, I think we could agree that that is "bad", as in, bad taste...but I think the case could be made that the publishing of this type of personal letter is not in that same category, in terms of taste
- Drbble 14y agoThe way we treat agreements after death affects how much trust the living place in each other.
- quesera 14y agoImportant people arrange to have their papers handled by a trusted person or group. They usually select what goes where, and how it gets dealt with. While certainly a private thing that gave him happiness or solace or peace in life, I'm confident that he chose to include it in his collected record on death. This seems consistent with everything that (I imagine) I know about him from reading his own autobiographical stuff, as well as other peoples' attempts. (Aside: Klaus Fuchs, the guy whose car he borrowed, turned out to be the mole at Los Alamos, and that car was instrumental in the performance of Fuchs' activities.)
- ktizo 14y agoWe would have no Kafka. It would be burnt.
- akg 14y agoFeynman has a unique insight and perspective of the world. One of the lessons I learned from him, and I can't find the quote now, but when he was diagnosed with cancer he had this to say: Everyone knows that they will one day die, yet they find a way to "live" life despite that fact. They have ambitions, dreams, desires. The only difference for me is that that the time is now limited. Why would I be depressed about that when the basic principle of life is the same. The only difference for me is that the time is shortened. It's simply a matter of scale, but the philosophical conundrum remains the same.
- swombat 14y agoIt's interesting that the author of this article regards this as, somehow, evidence that Feynman was "scientific till the end". What I read here is an article about a man who so deeply felt love for another human being that he abandoned any rationality on the topic and loved her even long after she was dead, to the exclusion of others. What's the science in that? To me, this story illustrates that Feynman was a man of deeper beliefs than most religious people, and what the story illustrates, really, is that there is absolutely no contradiction between having a highly rational, scientific mindset and yet having very deep beliefs that transcend the reductionist scientific mindset that some hardcore atheist propose is "the way forward". Science and beliefs can coexist perfectly well, as they did in Feynman, Einstein, and many other of our greatest scientists.
- danso 14y agoWell, the clock part is what I consider "scientific". If you had told me that Feynman was so struck by how the clock stopped that he kept the clock enclosed in a crystal box and tattooed "9:21" onto his arm, I might believe you because it's natural to assign meaning to a number and object that would otherwise be unremarkable. In fact, people might do this anyway just to commemorate a moment of death. But when something very unexpected occurs at such a pivotal moment, it is practically irresistable to think it more than coincidence. What would Feynman Lose by just accepting that, in this moment, there appear to be more things between heaven and earth than what science could reveal, especially in matters of love lost? Instead, he took time out of his grief to dispel such a notion. And yet, he loved his wife and her memory as the deepest romantic. The "love" part can exist independently of logical, scientific method...or at leat it did in Feynman's case.
- slurgfest 14y agoWhere in the world did you get the idea that Feynman had beliefs that are irrational or unscientific? Because I read the article and all I could find was sincere feeling. The phrase "hardcore atheist" suggests that you may have some baggage that is clouding your view on what words like rational and scientific mean. They never meant that you can't love somebody or grieve. That isn't even a belief, and it has nothing to do with theological views.
- 14y ago
- geon 14y agoI hardly consider myself cold or heartless scientiffic, but I cannot imagine why someone would give up all reason and curiosity applied to the moment surroumding a persons death. If a clock stopped at the time of my wifes death, just how would it be natural to attribute it to something supernatural if I wouldn't usually do that? Just because it is a highly emotional moment?
- danso 14y agoConcerning young love, there's the perception that the world practically begins and ends with your partner. Given that she was assigned a tragic and uncommon fate, would it be surprising to think that Feynman, or anyone, might be more vulnerable to accepting the "magical" explanation, that the energy/soul of this unique being left a telekinetic sign? Its not just that you wouldn't, on average, consider a supernatural explanation. It's that the stopping of a clock at any particular moment is rare and the death of your first true love...is, well, also extremely rare. A scientific mind, under some stress, might cede to the supernatural comfort by framing it as: "well, the probability of those two events happening at once"...and this framing would be made even easier given the overwhelming acceptance of such an event being supernatural by a 1940s-era society
- zwischenzug 14y agoI think you would be more rational exactly at that moment than be emotional. People react in unexpected ways in extreme situations. The most common reaction is to revert to a default mode of operation. It takes time for the feelings and responses to work their way through you.
- bromagosa 14y agoA really beautiful article. It made me decide to put "What Do You Care What Other People Think?" first in my next-to-read list.
- bishnu 14y agoWow, what a misleading article. The "she's dead, and how's the project?" quip wasn't to show the scientific, rational way Feynman dealt with death but rather the unhealthy manner in which he'd internalized his grief. The book goes on to describe, at great length, how Feynman would spontaneously break down in tears when he saw something that reminded him of her, and how he'd continue to have conversations with her after her death (which I believe led to his disqualification from military service). I suppose that doesn't fit in well with the narrative of "Feynman is the ideal all rational thinkers should strive for!!!" this guy seems to be pushing though.
- danso 14y agoI'm the author of the OP and think you may have (understandably) missed the point. The headline is "Feynman's Clock" and how he thought through the stopped clock is the example of his always logical mind. But considering I kind of went on at length about what he did immediately after, then I can see your interpretation. But to answer your point, I don't pass judgment or approval of Feynman, just showing how his "distant" persona does not capture the entirety of his emotion and thought.
- bishnu 14y agoThat's fair. Yes, it seemed to me everything that came after what you wrote about the clock seemed to be there to support the overall point.
- powertower 14y agoWhat would be the point talking to people about this loss of a loved one, who merely ask you because social norm dictates it so? What would he have gained? He was obviously of sound mind and spirit, and did not require "grief counseling" from his analytical co-workers. So he ended that conversation.
- larrys 14y ago"because social norm dictates it so" Agree (as my comment indicates). This is an auto response that is triggered upon hearing certain news. While a person might also have an emotion many times you say it to someone you don't even know and care about. People hear something and they instinctively act a certain way. I'm not saying everybody is like this of course.
- jpdoctor 14y ago> His dogged investigation of the Challenger explosion is the most generally well-known demonstration of his mindset. IIRC: In his second book ("What do you care what other people think"), he essentially admits he was a tool in this instance. One of the generals had figured it out, but was politically unable to point the finger. He lead Feynman to the issue, who then ran with it. (I can't remember his name. He opens with "Copilot to pilot: Comb your hair" or some such.)
- danso 14y agoThis is true. This is why I say "generally well-known", as in, as the public sees it. But I would also argue that in spirit, Feynman showed a high level of determination and focus to get to the bottom of things. As it happened, the famous revelation was given to him.
- inetsee 14y agoIf the software would let me, I would spend all my karma points to upvote this post. I recently (yesterday) suffered the loss of a loved one, and reading Feynman's letter to his late wife is one of the few things giving me comfort right now.
- edawerd 14y agoI love peeking deeper into the hearts and minds of superhuman people and discovering just how human they really are.
- Nevaeh 14y agoGood read, but there's so much more to the story. His book "What do you care what other people think" is a homage to Arlene, partly because Feynman made the fatal mistake of trusting the doctor's judgement to disregard the blatantly obvious diagnosis. He wrote about his experience in much more detail here: Part 1: http://i.imgur.com/CSNop.png http://i.imgur.com/CSNop.png Part 2: http://i.imgur.com/7mDTW.png http://i.imgur.com/7mDTW.png He was depressed for a while but eventually his love for physics helped him recover. Feynman is the most logical and happiest human I have ever seen. Hans Bethe once said, "Feynman depressed is just a little more cheerful then any other person when he is exuberant." Feynman's magnificent exuberance and puzzle solving enthusiasm remained up until his last days, where his coworker Christopher Sykes remarked "Look at this man. He faces the abyss. He doesn't know whether he is going to live through this week. But he was consumed by it, and he worked on it all day long...." http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fzg1CU8t9nw#t=1h11m33s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fzg1CU8t9nw#t=1h11m33s A few days before his second operation, Feynman sang a bongos song about orange juice, an amusing take of Linus Pauling's advice to possibly cure his cancer. Just look at his smile at the end of this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HKTSaezB4p8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HKTSaezB4p8 I would also like to add that on Feynman's last days at the hospital, his last words to his artist friend Jirayr was "Don't worry about anything, go out and have a good time!" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fzg1CU8t9nw#t=1h32m15s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fzg1CU8t9nw#t=1h32m15s Anyone who thinks of Feynman as a cold-hearted scientist is incredibly mistaken.