4 ms·
EU doubles down on penalising privacy-friendly and encrypted messaging services
- palata 2y ago> they will score worse on the risk scale, and will be more likely to be served a detection order mandating scanning of all communications content What does that mean? Say a service collects no data at all: what's the point of a "detection order mandating scanning of all communications content"? They will get all the data collected by the service, which is none.
- vaylian 2y agoChatcontrol is mostly about data in transit. Anything that is sent to the internet can be scanned.
- jand 2y ago> They will get all the data collected by the service, which is none. (disclaimer: not rooted in knowledge, but in pessimism) If the web service / whatever cannot provide the requested data, it would be in violation of the order. So all you really need are harsh fines for not complying with the order and the problem morphs from a technical one to a business decision.
- kvdveer 2y agoUnder current law, you cannot be compelled to share more data than you're already collecting. However, the term "collecting" is a bit wider than the most common use. If you receive some piece of data, you are collecting it, even if you don't keep logs, or don't do anything with it. It's not much different than how detective work is done in the physical domain. You cannot be compelled to ask a customer for more info, but you can be compelled to share info that the customer gave to you, even if you didn't ask for it or never wrote it down.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- iamkonstantin 2y agoIs this even legitimate? The post as well as the "leaked" document look so dodgy.
- grunder_advice 2y agoHow long will it be before I won't be able to post a comment like this online without providing my government ID?
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoDepends on what country you're in. In the US, it's going to be a while. In the EU, maybe not.
- hedora 2y agoIn the US, they don’t bother asking for your ID because wouldn’t give them much more information than they already have.
- GardenLetter27 2y agoAnd think of what it's like for startups too - if you want to make your own social media competitor now you have tonnes and tonnes of bureaucracy - the GDPR, privacy policies, cookie banners, the DSA (and stopping "disinformation"), the Cybersecurity act, and now IDs.
- raverbashing 2y ago> on the approach pursued by the Belgian Council Presidency To be noted The more noisy and outrageous this gets at this stage I can see more people making noise about it
- dsign 2y agoIn some places, the mask of this being a child-pornography problem is falling down already, see [^1]. The Swedish Social Democrats, which is the biggest political party in Sweden, wants for everybody to use their IDs to comment in social media just so that the party can wage their electoral war. [^1]: https://www.euractiv.com/section/politics/news/swedens-social-democrats-want-eu-id-verification-to-fight-social-media-trolls/ https://www.euractiv.com/section/politics/news/swedens-socia...
- Duralias 2y agoReading the article it isn't just that though, privacy problematic as it is, troll accounts spreading misinformation is an issue, especially for elections, and real weird for one of the major parties to admit to employing against even their supposed allies. And while that mask fell off, a similarly hard to argue against reason that they bring up is the russian state, which no one here likes, so it isn't like they actually pulled off the mask, just swapped it for something almost equal, assuming they stick to that reason.
- andai 2y agoThis legislation confuses me. Why would a party /its lobbyists care about trolling? It seems that a greater effect would be that sockpuppet accounts can no longer be used. Wouldn't this represent a loss to authoritarians? e.g. ones who openly conduct psychological operations on their own citizens: https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/article/explainer/nudge-unit https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/article/explainer/...
- beardyw 2y agoI think the argument should be about making people care, not the dashed unfairness of it all. I doubt more than 1% are aware or care.
- PartiallyTyped 2y agoIs this really where we are going? We have freedom of movement but not the freedom to speak to each other without prying ears/eyes? Is this really what the European project has come to? Do we really not have more important problems than this? I guess it's easier to squash dissent and fight electoral wars than to take meaningful actions for the people. Dear HN'ers; what can we actually do about this instead of preaching to the choir?
- grunder_advice 2y agoWe have neither. Look at what happened to Yanis Varoufakis.
- hiatus 2y agoWhat happened to him?
- shkkmo 2y agoHe was recently banned from entering Germany or engaging in any political speech in that country. https://jacobin.com/2024/04/yanis-varoufakis-germany-banned-palestine-gaza https://jacobin.com/2024/04/yanis-varoufakis-germany-banned-...
- hiatus 2y ago> not just a ban from visiting Germany but also from participation in Zoom events hosted in the country. I can’t even have a recorded video of me played at German events. This is just crazy. How is this allowed in a so-called democracy?
- arlort 2y ago> Dear HN'ers; what can we actually do about this instead of preaching to the choir? Lobby and get involved in national/EU politics. You can start by voting next week
- sampa 2y ago
- croes 2y agoEU: secure communication is bad and helps criminals The same EU: the Russians/Chinese intercepted confidential messages. We don't know how that could happen.
- ben_w 2y agoI suspect this is a fundamental mindset issue between thinking as a lawyer/law maker vs. thinking as a programmer. https://benwheatley.github.io/blog/2024/05/25-12.04.31.html https://benwheatley.github.io/blog/2024/05/25-12.04.31.html We can see how machines fail, and make the mistake of applying those standards to laws and money and so on, where they don't fit; law makers expect humans to be the ones actioning any given requirement, and cannot understand why it's so hard to only encrypt good content from good people and not bad content from bad people.
- omginternets 2y agoSee also: - “thou shalt not process user data” - “make your data available to us”
- this_user 2y agoNo amount of encryption will save you if you run your top secret meetings on an open Webex session.
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoMore recent: Let yourself be monitored: EU governments to agree on Chat Control https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40515358 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40515358
- avianlyric 2y agoThe title of this article is very misleading, suggesting that EU governance is some kind unified body, and that these documents actually represent what “The EU” wants to do. EU governance is far more complicated, and these documents only represent the view of one part of the EU governance system, the EU Council. The EU council is basically made up of people sent by the state governments of all the members, and basically represents the views of those state governments. The council is the only legislative writing body in the EU, but it has no power to enact legislation. It can only write proposed legislation, and present it to the EU parliament for voting on. The EU parliament is made up of directly elected MEPs and represents the interests of EU citizens as a whole, and not as individual member states. To get legislation passed, the parliament and council need to work together to get legislation written that the council is happy to write, and the parliament is happy to enact. The council is small body of 27 people, representing the interests of state governments, and the parliament 705 MEPs and represents “the people”. There’s currently no evidence that these proposals by the Council will have any success in the parliament, if anything quite the opposite. The EU parliament has made I quite clear they don’t like this type of draconian legislation, and won’t vote to enact it. Obviously that doesn’t mean we should ignore these proposals. It’s important to make it clear we don’t like it, and lend weight behind the arguments being put forward by MEPs to block this legislation. But to say this represents the EU “doubling down” on penalising privacy-friendly services is ridiculous. It represents the EU council doubling down, but that only one small part of the EU governance bodies, and the other bodies are actively fighting back.
- brevhtff 2y agoThanks for explaining a bit how things work in the EU. Pretty interesting, and not something I would have thought or cared to look up. In this light it feels a bit like some of the grandstanding bills US politicians write or even pass in the House, knowing they haven’t a chance in the Senate, or whatever. And perhaps the audience is folks in the home country or even other politicians in the home country?
- denton-scratch 2y ago> not something I would have thought or cared to look up. Wikipedia articles on the operation of EU institutions are awful - barely any better than the official EU documentation. You'd be led to guess that the Wikipedia articles were composed by EU officials. > In this light it feels a bit like some of the grandstanding bills US politicians write It's more sinister than that. The Commission is the permanent secretariat of the EU; the Commissioners are usually political has-beens in their home country, and they don't need to grandstand, because they are not elected. So what happens is that the Commission settles on some horrible scheme, and proposes legislation accordingly. Parliament duly wrecks the proposal, and sends it back. This continues until someone gets tired. But Parliament is subject to elections; the Commission isn't (and it doesn't seem to get tired, either). So the same horrible proposals keep coming back, until elections bring in a Parliament that is more favourable to the proposal.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- helsinkiandrew 2y ago[dead]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- frank_bb 2y ago[dead]