3 ms·
You're projecting pretty badly here, and are flaming where I really don't think it's appropriate ("People like you", indeed). For clarity, though, when you say
by ajross 14y ago
You're projecting pretty badly here, and are flaming where I really don't think it's appropriate ("People like you", indeed).
For clarity, though, when you say "the open source process", you mean the process where Google gets assigned ownership. An employee who wants to release something under an OSD compatible license without assigning copyright (for whatever reason, say because they want to use the GPLv3 and you don't, or because they simply don't trust a public company) does not simply fill out a 4-line form and get an answer in a day, as I understand it.
(edit: And you continue to euphemize this. It's not "special treatment", it's a flat out copyright assignment. Ownership isn't completely clear, so one of the parties needs to give up stake. And the process is clearly asymmetric in Google's favor. That's not surprising, really, but what is surprising is that you won't come straight out and say this.)
And my advice to you is that you consider the costs of this sort of thing to the employees and the engineering work when making your conservative legal pronouncements. As we've seen in the news today, even Google's rigorous IP process isn't enough to keep you from getting sued. The world is indeed not a happy pretty place; cavalier avoidance of process may not help things, but neither does paranoia.
- DannyBee 14y ago1. I'm perfectly comfortable with what I wrote. I neither believe it was inappropriately flaming given what you wrote, nor do I think it is "projecting pretty badly", as you say (The "people like you" was intentional, and given the evidence I have, seems correct. If it turned out not to be correct, i'd happily retract it). 2. Yes, people who want special treatment take time. We've made the common case fast, and the exceptional case possible. 3. We do consider the costs, and try to keep the process as simple as possible while still accomplishing its goals. Note that I am an engineer as well as a lawyer, and contribute to a large number of open source projects and so I have to go through the same process everyone else does. 4. You honestly don't know what you are talking about when it comes to things you've "seen in the news", and i'll just leave it at that.