3 ms·
How can we measure DNSSEC adoption? We could take the Tranco top 1M domain names and poll them to see how many are DNSSEC-signed. A recent scan of this domain n
by tptacek 2y ago
How can we measure DNSSEC adoption? We could take the Tranco top 1M domain names and poll them to see how many are DNSSEC-signed. A recent scan of this domain name list shows that 94,317 of these names are validly signed with DNSSEC, or 9.4%. The issue with this form of average statistic is that it equally weights all of these million domain names, whereas a more relevant statistic would be to weight each domain name by its relative “use” in some fashion. Perhaps there is a different approach that takes this relative use weighting between domain names into consideration.
It's so much worse than this, and I think he must know that. The Tranco list (which is very cool: it's like the Moz500 or other popularity-contest lists like that, but research-oriented, academic, and ostensibly rigorous) is ranked. The first domain on the list is Google, and so on.
He used the Top 1M for a reason. If he wanted to take the top 1000, he could just `head -1000` the list. But the impact on his 9.4% figure would be stark.