5 ms·
Ping Ff02:1
- rubatuga 2y agoUnfortunately blocked on iOS without special app entitlements ... Apple being Apple.
- chungy 2y agoNever heard of this trick, I go to try it and... nothing. TFA may have some funky network setup to allow this. Also calling web browsers made by "stupid people" without even properly evaluating the effectiveness of your own network hack seems rather hypocritical. :)
- lucb1e 2y ago> [The Fine Article / OP] may have some funky network setup It is very common (or perhaps almost ubiquitous since most routers will respond, idk) to get responses and works by default for most devices. It will not work if you: - Have no IPv6 devices on your network - The hosts on your network have a firewall that filters the packets or configuration that disables pinging (I think Windows disabled ping by default since Vista) - You have some fancy network with host isolation (trading usability for security), often seen with enterprise vendors - It autodetected the wrong interface to send the packets out on. I don't know how ping does this, perhaps it tries to just send it everywhere. Can't quickly find it but the Arch wiki says you have to specify the interface (for me it works without, so clearly that's not exactly accurate, but I imagine it may not do what you want)
- Latty 2y agoOn Arch, I get "ping: Warning: IPv6 link-local address on ICMP datagram socket may require ifname or scope-id => use: address%<ifname|scope-id>", and it doesn't work unless I do so.
- lucb1e 2y agoOh, interesting! Which ping have you got? Mine comes from the iputils-ping Debian package, which the man page confirms it's part of some broader iputils set of tools. I see there is also inetutils-ping which provides the same /bin/ping and /bin/ping6 commands, is that perhaps the one you've got? For anyone wanting to replicate this "provides" query on Debian, I use `apt-file search /bin/ping` to list what packages have a file with that name -- this will also match `/usr/bin/ping6` (both prefixes and suffixes will match) but that was fine in this case. (If you just do `apt search ping` or something, you get a huge list of any package mentioning the word ping, which may be what you want when searching for something more broadly; and if you use `apt search /bin/ping` it comes up empty because it doesn't have file path data.) Edit: now that I had looked up which utility it is, I figured I'd check the "is documentation enough" on how it finds which interface to use. It looks to me like it is `getaddrinfo` that decides it: https://github.com/iputils/iputils/blob/master/ping/ping.c#L648-L681 https://github.com/iputils/iputils/blob/master/ping/ping.c#L...
- Latty 2y agoYeah, I'm just using Arch's default iputils: > pkgfile $(which ping) core/iputils That doesn't provide a `ping6`, presumably as `ping -6` is the preferred solution.
- aftbit 2y agoI tried this on Arch and it didn't work at all. $ ping -6 ff02::1%eth2 Did I miss some kernel tunable or nftables setting? Unicast ping works fine.
- Latty 2y agoDo you have a link-local v6 address on that device? My first attempt `ping ff02::1%enp9s0` didn't work because I use VLANs and don't actually get addresses on the base device, using the VLAN virtual device (in my case `ping ff02::1%lan`) worked for me. You shouldn't need `-6`, given it's a v6 address.
- DanAtC 2y agoBrowsers not allowing completely valid URLs is stupid.
- johnklos 2y agoIs your result "nothing" because you 1) have IPv6 turned off, 2) are running a restrictive reverse firewall, 3) didn't pay attention to the fact that you likely have to specify your ethernet interface explicitly, 4) didn't notice that you need to use `ping6` instead of `ping`, 5) have device isolation on your wifi network, 6) any of a number of other things? You seem to be here to complain more than to actually learn, else you'd've said what results you got, and you'd communicate better by not using acronyms without context (TFA: trans fatty acids? Thanks for asking?) Regarding the comment about web browsers being made by stupid people, we're all allowed to have opinions. Most of the common web browsers have tons of stupid design choices, and generalizing that stupid design choices come from stupid people just sounds like a flippant remark, not a denigration of a whole group of people. The people I know who work on web browsers would wholeheartedly agree with the author's comment (I've heard many similar sentiments). The information in this article is useful, and everyone even remotely in IT would benefit by keeping this page bookmarked :)
- observationist 2y agoThe context for TFA is this site; it's common knowledge.
- Arnavion 2y agoThe Fine/Fucking Article. cf RTFM
- bhaney 2y ago> (TFA: trans fatty acids? Thanks for asking?) "The Fucking Article." Etymologically derived from "RTFM," but now mostly used as a casual abbreviation to refer to the article that a comment thread is about. People who have traumatic childhood memories of soap in their mouths sometimes pretend it stands for "The Fine Article" or "The Featured Article."
- aftbit 2y agoThanks! I have been on HN since 2014 and I still hadn't figured out WTF people were talking about with TFA. I just assumed it was some kind of reference to the article but I didn't realize the F was for fucking.
- Latty 2y agoThe stupid people thing annoys me, because you see so much of "man, the people doing this must be stupid for not doing that" in so much conversation, which ignores the reality that so many things are outside of an individual's control, and I think blaming individuals rather than systems leads to a lot of bad systems hanging around forever unchanged, as it tends to become a thought-terminating idea, just "don't be stupid". Often, something is (seemingly) bad because of a lack of time or other resource, because a boss or standard told them to make it bad, because there is some bigger issue being avoided, etc... Especially when it comes to browsers, vendors are making trade-offs, and supporting a very rare case like this when URLs are often very sensitive security-wise seems like one I could understand being wary of. Does a user understand what devices they are connecting to in that situation? It's probably intended as a joking remark, maybe even an "all people are stupid" thing poorly done, but even so, I think it perpetuates a bad way of thinking about flaws in software.
- scrps 2y agoSince you are making valid points and being downvoted for the pleasure. The platform-specific nature of <zone_id> makes it difficult to impossible to validate the well-formedness of the URL (see https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4007#section-11.2 https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4007#section-11.2 , as referenced in 6874, to fully appreciate this special hell). Even if we could reliably parse these (from a URL spec standpoint), it then has to be handed 'somewhere', and that opens a new can of worms. https://www.w3.org/Bugs/Public/show_bug.cgi?id=27234 https://www.w3.org/Bugs/Public/show_bug.cgi?id=27234
- lxgr 2y agoCouldn't agree more. This sentiment is the fundamental attribution error [1] in a nutshell: "Others do stupid things because they're stupid, I do stupid things because stupid circumstances and other people made me" :) And while I can see that it's being used flippantly here and not intended as an insult, I still don't think it's fair to the many decidedly non-stupid browser devs out there. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_attribution_error https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_attribution_error
- jeffmcjunkin 2y agoTitle needs a small fix, it should be `ping ff02::1` (with two colons) to be a valid IPv6 address, match the actual command, and match the original title.
- jedahan 2y agoI added discovery support to scuttlebutt for link-local addresses to create "routerless" (no DHCP/SLAAC/Manual address assignment) self-repairing networks. Always wondered how broadcast worked, so appreciate the detailed writeup.
- scrps 2y agoBugzilla issue on this: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=700999 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=700999 Also W3 issue: https://www.w3.org/Bugs/Public/show_bug.cgi?id=27234 https://www.w3.org/Bugs/Public/show_bug.cgi?id=27234 Edit: added w3 issue I missed linked in the bugzilla issue
- aftbit 2y agoHmm I tried this on my Arch desktop, and it didn't work. It did work on my OpenWRT router and on my Debian server.
- majke 2y agoThis is pretty cool, improved CLI on Linux: ping ff02::1%<INTERFACE> -c 2 -i 100 -w 4
- immibis 2y agoIt is indeed broadcast for all intents and purposes. IPv6 noticed that broadcast was just a specific case of multicast and decided to conceptually subsume it. One of the very minor changes that IPv6 brought along. "Broadcast" is just shorthand for "multicast to everyone".
- akira2501 2y agoWell they also expanded multicast into "limited group multicast" with the way Duplicate Address Detection works. There's a lot of cleverness baked into IPv6.
- wolletd 2y agoIPv6 link-local addresses based on MAC address are neat, I use that in production. We build a machine containing six cameras. All of them come with the same default IPv4 address, but the MAC address is based on the serial number, so the IPv6 address is, too. Employees enter the six serial numbers by scanning Datamatrix codes in order, and I can calculate the IPv6 addresses from that, connect and change their IPv4 addresses all in parallel. Ten years ago I did the same thing on a different product with weird ARP shenanigans. The IPv6 approach is way faster and cooler.
- therein 2y agoARP poisoning to get packets routed to a machine with a misconfigured default IP sounds cooler to me but that's just me.
- peterhull90 2y agoIt may be different on newer MacOS but on mine you will need ping6 > ping6 ff02::1%en1 for example. I wasn't able to get it to work on Windows (I can get the command to work in WSL but it seems to sit alone in an internal network). Any advice welcome.
- lucb1e 2y agoWasn't it that you have to specify the interface with something like -i in Windows? Or was that Nmap maybe... I don't have Windows to test with here, but have you checked the --help or /? to see if it allows specifying an interface with a separate option? It can also be that there are simply no other devices responding to this on your network, especially if those are also Windows (more infos/options in my other comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40503155 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40503155)
- g15jv2dp 2y agoI'm on Windows and I have the same issue. I specified the interface with the % notation (it clearly does something, because if I put a wrong interface number, it gives me "general failure" instead of a timeout). The flag -i is for TTL, not interface. However, if I do the same from my rpi, a few devices respond (my tv box, the rpi itself, etc)... including my windows machine! According to https://superuser.com/a/467559 https://superuser.com/a/467559, "The Windows ping program cannot send a ping request to broadcast addresses". That's multicast, there's no broadcast in ipv6; but maybe there's the same issue. I tried a quick https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/dotnet/api/system.net.networkinformation.ping.send https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/dotnet/api/system.net.netw... and it times out too.
- akira2501 2y ago> wasn't able to get it to work on Windows Windows has "ipv6-literal.net" as a helper. It's particularly useful if you're trying to smuggle link local addresses into a UNC path: https://ipv6-literal.com/?ipv6=fe80%3A%3A3%251 https://ipv6-literal.com/?ipv6=fe80%3A%3A3%251
- 2y ago
- amluto 2y agoTime to rant: why can’t I have a URL, in whatever format (special type of IPv6 address would work, although the available bits are a bit crunched), where the URL includes a public key? Then people could use HTTPS to communicate with local devices for which there is no practical way to provision certificates?
- semi 2y agoPublic keys should be rotated which would expire links. I think just having trust on first use would bridge most of the gap for local devices. .. Now if we could get local socket support for talking to your own device and avoid arbitrary port reservation on localhost, that would make me happy.
- amluto 2y ago> Public keys should be rotated which would expire links. Sometimes public keys should be rotated, and this would indeed expire links. And sometimes they shouldn’t be (a key pair in a TPM-like device in an embedded system would make a lot of sense). > I think just having trust on first use would bridge most of the gap for local devices. This has the exact same key rotation problem. And you can get quite close to TOFU with an HTTP page that links to a a hypothetical HTTPS+key link.