5 ms·
I sort of believe the thesis behind this piece, but it's written so viciously that I have trouble taking it seriously. For instance, however ineffective the "Fr
by tptacek 2y ago
I sort of believe the thesis behind this piece, but it's written so viciously that I have trouble taking it seriously. For instance, however ineffective the "Freedom Project" in Seattle is, its finance director, who "once shot up a man’s house as an intimidation tactic to prevent him from snitching on Howell’s drug dealing", did so 20 years ago, served his sentence, went to college, then grad school at Penn State, and started a career. It seems extraordinarily unlikely that the crimes he committed when he was 21 have much of an impact on "Freedom Project" now.
The author knows that, but includes the innuendo anyways, which makes me think he can't make a better case than that. Ick.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- scrubs 2y agoWhether viciously written or no, isn't the salient question: why give tax payer dollars to non profits if either (a) no net low cost housing built (b) the customers of non profit are displeased.
- mattmaroon 2y agoYes, and think how much more convincing the argument would be if it relied on its merits (which are substantial) rather the what amounts to ad hominems.
- tptacek 2y agoYes. This. I think the writing is doubly despicable for discrediting an important argument I agree with. Also I'm irked that the author has so little respect for his readers that he thinks none of them will Google any of the names in his piece.
- mattmaroon 2y agoYeah. I am sure that arguments that appeal to people like us might be somewhat different than once that appeal to the general public, but this seems like the kind of argument that is aimed at people like us. I have done a good amount of work with not for profits in the last 10 years and have definitely seen a small piece of the dark side of the industry that he is talking about.
- tptacek 2y agoI do a bunch of local politics stuff, and we have problematic nonprofits. You could write a compelling piece about poorly managed nonprofit contracts fucking up their missions, and it wouldn't need to rely on unrelated 20-year-old criminal records.
- ta20240528 2y agoYou now know why libel and slander laws in the UK don't allow the factual truth to be an absolute defense. His history with the criminal justice system is a fact, but the intention in the article is to discredit him for a debt to his community that has long been paid. This is just libel.
- auggierose 2y ago> You now know why libel and slander laws in the UK don't allow the factual truth to be an absolute defense. That probably has more to do with Russian oligarchs being enabled to sue critical news organisations into bankruptcy. If factual truth is not enough, you are in deep shit.
- perihelions 2y ago- "This is just libel." It's not libel; it's just an opinionated argument that you dislike, so much so that you want to stop the other person from speaking.
- CuriouslyC 2y agoI don't know. If you were to say the man is a drug dealer, criminal and untrustworthy based on something >20 years in the past, unless your language clearly indicates that stuff was LONG in the past it seems intent on causing material harm to the person by misleading readers which is literally libel.
- perihelions 2y ago- "it seems intent on causing material harm" It's intent on changing public policy by persuading voters with argumentation. This is the most protected class of speech. That it publishes ugly true facts about individuals (which is also protected!) is an incidental step towards the author trying to paint a persuasive political narrative. (I can't help but want to break this down. You say it's misleading, but the case docket is hyperlinked inline with the text you say is misleading—that's far more than adequate in US jurisprudence. No "reasonable person" (a technical standard) is misled on a fact that's plainly disclosed, just one click away. You say the criminality is in the "distant past"—but the person's felon status is current, ongoing, and in fact relevant to the author's line of arguing, which is that these nonprofits are a form of "laundering" federal government grants to people the federal government otherwise disqualifies. You think (and I'm sympathetic to this) that crimes committed 20+ years ago are not strongly reflective of the current human. But, this is a subjective interpretation—not an objective truth beyond reasonable debate; and the fact that the US government itself disagrees, by permanently disqualifying felons shows how ludicrous it'd be to argue, in a US court, that "he's a convicted felon" is speech without social value).
- michtzik 2y agoI strongly disagree with your thinking that the author can't make a better case. The previous sentence before the one you quote is this: > Freedom Project’s executive director at the time was David Heppard who was convicted as a teenager for taking part in the gang rape of a pregnant seventeen-year-old. And here's what the author COULD have said: > On February 18, 1994, Heppard and five of his friends spotted a five-months pregnant 17-year-old who is referred to in court filings as “J.H.” Cecil Morton III, one of Heppard’s co-defendants, proposed raping J.H. Morton stopped the car and he, Heppard, and a third member of the group forced the pregnant girl into the back seat. She begged them not to hurt her and Morton threatened her into silence with a machete; someone in the vehicle told her that if she didn’t shut up, they would kill her unborn baby. > They drove her into the woods where five or six of them raped her orally and vaginally. J.H. was then forced back into the vehicle completely naked and was ordered to direct them to her apartment. Some of the boys threatened that if she failed to do so, they would murder her and dismember her corpse. > Along the way, Heppard orally sodomized the terrified girl a second time and she was raped by two of his co-defendants upon their arrival. As the pregnant 17-year-old girl was being raped for the third time that night, the boys who weren’t otherwise occupied robbed her apartment, stealing a number of items belonging to her and her boyfriend. They then left the apartment, telling her that if she ratted them out, they would come back to kill her. > Once the boys were gone, their victim called a friend, who contacted the police on her behalf. Coincidentally, Heppard and his partners in crime were pulled over by Pierce County police officers at the same time the rape was reported. A call came over their radio regarding the assault, but the cops did not make the connection between the rape and the teenagers they were questioning; however, the rapists heard the report and were now aware that their victim had contacted the police. Heppard and Morton allegedly began plotting to have the girl murdered, but were arrested before she could be silenced.
- kbenson 2y agoThat's a horrible story, but pulling it out seems to indicate you didn't understand what the GP was trying to convey at all. The point was that to use a crime from twenty years ago for which a person was convicted and served time for as indicative of problems with the current project he's the head of seems to indicate they could not not find anything relevant to the project itself to criticize. Doubling down on the details of that crime doesn't change that or counter the claim at all. If you want to make a claim that rehabilitation is impossible, or that he's not rehabilitated, then do so. If you want to state that it goes to the point being made in the article, that hiring felons with a violent history is common, then do so. I don't think the article is indefensible, but these additional details without context to make them relevant don't add much.
- selimthegrim 2y agoFurthermore, he insinuates the LA homeless advocate lost both legs to Skid Row-related diseases, when it was only the first one.