4 ms·
> "A model is any physical system whose behavior correlates in some way with another physical system." So when X is a model of Y, then Y is always also a model
by layer8 2y ago
> "A model is any physical system whose behavior correlates in some way with another physical system."
So when X is a model of Y, then Y is always also a model of X? (Since correlation is generally a symmetric relationship.) That seems like a strange definition of “model”.
- gavagai691 2y agoI agree that this is a problem with the above definition of model, analogous to the (IMO fatal) problems with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deductive-nomological_model#Weaknesses https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deductive-nomological_model#We....
- lisper 2y agoThat has to do with causality, which is a complicated topic that I was trying very hard to avoid at this point in the exposition. But maybe that was a mistake.
- lisper 2y ago> So when X is a model of Y, then Y is always also a model of X? Yes. > That seems like a strange definition of “model”. Yes, it does, but I can defend it. It's analogous to the definition of "information". If a system X contains information about a system Y then it is always the case that Y also contains the same amount of information about X. The distinction between "model" and "modeled" is purely artificial in the most literal sense: the thing we generally label "model" is the thing we humans made.