4 ms·
The soyuz has the capacity to return crew to the Earth, but Dragon is actually the only unmanned capsule capable of returning significant amounts of cargo.
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
The soyuz has the capacity to return crew to the Earth, but Dragon is actually the only unmanned capsule capable of returning significant amounts of cargo.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoPart of the problem is that the name 'Soyuz' is the name for the whole thing, the module on top is called 'Progress' and the current generation, Progress-M [1]. From the wikipedia page (but I've heard this from my Russian space enthusiast friends as well) "The Progress M is essentially the same spacecraft as the Progress, but it features improvements based on the Soyuz T and TM designs. It can spend up to 30 days in autonomous flight and is able to carry 100 kg more. Also, unlike the old Progress crafts, it can return items to Earth. This is accomplished by using the Raduga capsule, which can carry up to 150 kg of cargo." [2] So in a strict language mapping Falcon-9 -> Soyus, and Dragon -> Progress if we talk about the various parts. And yes, the amount of cargo the Progress-M can return it quite limited compared to Dragon. But my Russian friends tell me that there are variants that are an equivalent to Dragon either available or designed but not deployed. I don't know one way or another and it takes NOTHING away from the huge thing SpaceX has accomplished. I would be hugely proud to be part of a team that has shown such a stunningly good ability to execute against their goals. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progress-M http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progress-M [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progress_%28spacecraft%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progress_%28spacecraft%29
- InclinedPlane 14y agoFor clarity: soyuz is the name of a launch vehicle as well as a manned spacecraft (the Soyuz-TMA-M). The Soyuz spacecraft can return humans to the Earth and of course has the ability to return cargo as well, but since the space is taken up by people that capacity is extremely limited. The Progress can return a very tiny amount of cargo (about 150kg) to Earth using a specialty capsule that was last used in 1994.
- adavies42 14y agoreminds me of the whole "shuttle" vs. "orbiter" thing