3 ms·
Perhaps because without having their theories reality-checked on a regular basis, a philosopher of science effectively turns into a protein-based LLM: saying co
by TeMPOraL 2y ago
Perhaps because without having their theories reality-checked on a regular basis, a philosopher of science effectively turns into a protein-based LLM: saying convincing things, but unable to realize when some of it is wrong and invalidates everything said from that point on.
Medical practitioners live and breathe methodology; they experience both the process and its output. They are the reality test.
- AndrewKemendo 2y agoI also have an extreme bias towards practitioners in terms of any practice being the exegesis of whatever the embedded epistemology is. However, I believe you’re over indexing on this in that across pretty much every industry that I’ve ever dealt with, practitioners are notoriously terrible at implementing anything close to theoretical optimization Why? simply because the organization does not incentivize that, so if we were then to use this as our standard, then we would be betraying what is effectively the idealized implementation of some epistemological process instead you’re simply lowering the bar on what is a more correct way to do things I think this is one of the few places where from a philosophical perspective The categorical imperative is actually very helpful - that is to say a medical professionals epistemology should be the highest standard and all other standards of rationality or let’s say decision-making should strive for In short, much like practitioners need to keep the philosophers grounded , philosophers need to keep practitioners from lowering the bar on the epistemological robustness
- snapcaster 2y agoI think the scoreboard indicates differently. I've never once come across a meaningful problem outside of philosophy addressed or solved by a philosopher
- cd4plus 2y agoYou haven't looked very hard then
- TeMPOraL 2y agoOkay, name three examples then. Bonus points if they happen to be pure philosophers, not philosopher-practitioners.
- cd4plus 2y agoAre you not a practitioner if you contribute to the field...? Seems impossible to meet your criteria. What's a pure philosopher? Are Frege and Decartes not philosophers because they also did math? Does Alan Turing count? What about Popper and Kuhn? Are they philosophy enough for the philosopher club? Where, when, how and by whom do you think the concept of 'empirical science' was derived? To be clear, everyone, including scientists, do philosophy every single day. You don't think Darwin did some philosophy in on the origin of species?
- alan-hn 2y agoSure you can argue about the specificity of the question but do you have any examples of pure philosophers?
- cd4plus 2y agoJerry Fodor? Noam Chomsky? Hilary Putnam? Patricia Churchland What is a pure philosopher??!? I'm not arguing the specificity of the question, I'm saying that question is nonsensical.
- alan-hn 2y agoSomeone who does not test hypotheses
- zaat 2y agoThe characterization of the scientific method as proposing hypotheses and then putting them to test was given by a philosopher in the previous century. While the hypotheses that this is the character of the scientific method is still very common, it was refuted long ago, both by observations and by logic reasoning.
- AndrewKemendo 2y agoI’m not aware of this scoreboard Please provide a link or otherwise reference to this scoreboard Unless you were writing metaphorically in which case you’ll need to write a lot more to describe it
- snapcaster 2y agoSorry thought it was clear but maybe a little poorly phrased. My point is: the number of meaningful solutions to problems by practitioners is infinity. The number of meaningful solutions to problems by non-practicing philosophers is zero as far as I know. Open to it being non-zero, but don't think the score is remotely close edit: I think often theoreticians are unable to appreciate the constraints or nuance of actually "doing it" so frequently their "solutions" don't survive impact with reality
- AndrewKemendo 2y agoCan you differentiate between implementation quality of a tool? The “platonic wheel” is not a concern for someone trying to make money selling tires - but nor do those tires by being a function of successful commerce describe a “platonic wheel” Perhaps the platonic wheel is in some intersectional saddle point between theory and practice but to say that only that which is commonly adopted has measure ignores the philosophical genesis that precedes and impregnates the production process.