4 ms·
I think of it in terms of degrees of freedom and statistical likelihood. If I throw a bunch of marbles on the floor and a few of them form a interesting shape
by _xerces_ 2y ago
I think of it in terms of degrees of freedom and statistical likelihood. If I throw a bunch of marbles on the floor and a few of them form a interesting shape that is one thing as they can only move on a plane. If I throw them in the air it is less likely to form a circle as now they are free to move in multiple directions and are not constrained to the plane. If 4 of those marbles align that is less likely than 20 of them happening to do so in a recognizable shape. 20 marbles in the air, each one being in just the right place relative to the 19 others in order to look like a circle when they can be in any position in space (vs. limited to a flat plane) is exceedingly unlikely.
Even more unlikely is that an arc appears next to the ring, that would make me start to wonder if something is affecting the marbles I throw into the sky.
- financypants 2y agoIs it less likely even if we can view the marbles in the air from any angle?
- jjk166 2y agoBut your view is a 2D projection, so you are eliminating that degree of freedom. It's equivalent to forcing them all to fall to the floor. If they form an actual ring in 3D space, that is far less probable.