9 ms·
Turning psychiatric labels into identities
- thunderbong 2y agohttps://archive.ph/RfTgj https://archive.ph/RfTgj
- bitmasher9 2y agoThis is a classic mapping problem
- dyauspitr 2y agoHITOP sounds even worse with a spectrum for everything. It sounds less like a system for diagnoses and more a subjective, self reported way of classifying all humans.
- Mathnerd314 2y agoIf you look at the suggested measures, you will see that for example, the Big-5 personality traits are on there. https://renaissance.stonybrookmedicine.edu/sites/default/files/HiTOP%20measures%20online.pdf https://renaissance.stonybrookmedicine.edu/sites/default/fil.... Although self-reported, I wouldn't say Big-5 is "subjective". The measures have good test-retest validity and many independent scales have been developed and found to be strongly correlated. I would argue this means Big-5 is not just "you answered this question on this scale" - it is measuring something deeper, maybe not personality per se but at least a mental attitude. I could easily see extending this sort of measurement process to all of the traits in DSM, and I think it is a worthwhile goal. There are two issues I have with HiTOP though. First, they haven't actually developed and published the scales, or even a concise and reliable description of them. For example, if you look for Big-5 scales, you will find that only extraversion and neuroticism are well-defined. The other dimensions aren't replicable. Just by listing Big-5 and not adding any caveats, it is clear that HiTOP isn't taking a critical view of these measures. In terms of actual, usable scales, there are just the ICD-11 and DSM-5 AMPD personality models, and combining these into a concise scale is active research. In this area, the HiTOP project has accomplished little so far besides drawing attention to these and other models. There is a 405-question battery https://hitop.unt.edu/clinical-tools/hitop-digital-assessment-and-tracker-hitop-dat.html https://hitop.unt.edu/clinical-tools/hitop-digital-assessmen..., but it hasn't been validated. Second, I find the goals somewhat confused and the distinction between categorical and dimensional somewhat artificial. For example in https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5811364/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5811364/, the proposal is to have a number of traits and to rate their severity. This model isn't particularly different from the current DSM - it is just that now rather than a "diagnosis of autism" one is rated as having a "severe autism trait". It is possible to have multiple diagnoses in the DSM and similarly in the proposed model it is possible to have multiple traits. About the only real difference is that diagnoses are going to be redefined to be one level above, what could be termed a meta-diagnosis in the current DSM. This is presumably going to be more strictly trait-based, and the traits are going to be de-duplicated, so that there are fewer differential diagnoses to deal with. You can see the proposed grouping here: https://renaissance.stonybrookmedicine.edu/HITOP/AboutHiTOP https://renaissance.stonybrookmedicine.edu/HITOP/AboutHiTOP. I don't see much issue with such groupings, but I also don't see it as a big change. Despite them saying it's a new framework that bears no relationship to the current one, I think all the current labels will still be around for a while, and it doesn't seem hard to fit all the DSM-5 labels into the new framework either as traits or as diagnoses (syndromes).
- BLKNSLVR 2y agoSometimes the 'label' seems to be an excuse to continue behaviours that, were they not-yet-labeled, an individual would be encouraged to change. The label can be a shield against change or a weapon used to slay any accusation of weakness of discipline or laziness. It can be used as a security blanket to maintain the lifestyle to which one has become accustomed, justify all the bad habits involuntarily picked up from bad parenting and the ubiquity of entertainment and communication with friends and the complete lack of familiarity with being alone with only ones thoughts for company for any period of time. I know, for myself, there are easy and hard choices. I'm sure there are impossible choices for some states of mind, but they're a long way from my experience, and so all of the above may sound incredibly insensitive to those to whom I cannot even fake to relate with. I mean no offense, I'd like to have it explained. Is mental illness ever a learnt behaviour? Is mental illness a crystallisation of habits we unknowingly locked ourselves into? What is mental illness and what is just unfamiliar, not yet modelled behaviour and reactions to behaviour? Can any of the spectrums be navigated downwards through the smallest of steps over a long enough time period? What if "domestic violence" was actually a mental illness? (I ask the above to invoke thoughtfulness about our definitions and limitations and reactions to labels. I do not justify domestic violence, but that's because I believe there is always some amount of choice in how a human can react to a situation).
- suroot 2y ago> complete lack of familiarity with being alone with only ones thoughts for company for any period of time. Riiiight…
- Apocryphon 2y agoWe’re all hanging out in the comments, none of us should be casting that stone.
- grugagag 2y ago> The label is a shield against change Surely it could be used for that. But it could also be used to get people who seem to fit the label to connect and discuss their own puzzling patterns of behavior, perhaps better understand why they never fit in no matter how hard they tried and so on. What is absolutely clear to me is that we as a population aren’t uniform at all in thinking and operating; being a minority could be a painful experience as you’re expected to conform to the norm. I think most discussion that expands this understanding is useful.
- mjfl 2y agoiatrogenesis - when a therapist gives a possible explanation for your problem, they actually harm you because you begin to see it and start acting it out. The world becomes a theater, and you are on stage, playing your part in your mental illness. But these problems have such a low bar for diagnosis, that the majority of people qualify for at least one. But if the majority of people have some trait, is it really illness?
- readthenotes1 2y agoMy understanding is that the DSM type labels are only appropriate if the character trait is having a catastrophic effect on someone's life.
- pseudalopex 2y agoSignificant. Not catastrophic.
- pseudalopex 2y ago> But these problems have such a low bar for diagnosis, that the majority of people qualify for at least one. What is your evidence? > But if the majority of people have some trait, is it really illness? Lifetime cancer rates in some countries is 1 in 2. Can we say cancer is really illness?
- throw383y8 2y agoPriviliges? Mental illness is quite common. Imagine you could not label people as "creepy" or "invel", because they are most likely on some sort of spectrum. With mental illness they would be protected group. If it's personality trait, they are just creepy loosers.
- TeMPOraL 2y agoWell, at least it would stop people from calling them names and feeling smugly superior about being on the lucky side of circumstances they likely had zero control over. At the same time, those "creeps" would have more therapy options available, helping at least some of them fit in better with the society at large. I understand that some types of people are inherently a problem for the majority of the population; I still feel that calling them "creepy losers" is a douchebag behavior that shows lack of empathy.
- throw383y8 2y ago[flagged]
- mrangle 2y agoTrained, high functioning people with the same condition are likely the best diagnosticians for that condition. At least for The Spectrum. As they would theoretically be better able to identify malingerers. The other side of the coin is that they could be more likely to flesh out a diagnoses in people whose symptoms are subtler or otherwise better covered.
- complaintdept 2y agoWhy are people so desperate to cling to labels? As I get older the notion of identity just seems increasingly absurd. Identities and labels have just become their own end. People seem like they don't exist anymore except on the terms and expectations already laid out by other people. It's no way to live.
- Teever 2y agoThey're filling a god shaped hole in their heart. They like most (all?) people don't understand the world or their role in it, or even worse they know they have no role in this world so they reach for what ever can give them fulfilment, belonging and direction, just like religious people do. I agree that it's no way to live.
- idontknowifican 2y agoit always felt a bit more reactionary to me. a lot of people feel like they were unjustly treated, and the label helps them feel better about that stuff. normally i have seen an adult with a fresh diagnosis go really hard in to that identity, only to realize they over did it and land in a more neutral space. as someone who has a bunch of adult friends getting autism or add/adhd diagnosed, there is an immediate phase of “all of my problems are caused by this”, followed by “how do i cope with this”, and finally “this is just helpful context for me”. there are quite a few that get stuck on one of those phases, but largely most people loop back around to a more reasonable view.
- pxc 2y ago> god-shaped hole This cliche phrase definitely takes me back! The problem here is of course that gods aren't capable of solving this kind of problem anyway; an external, instrumental purpose ('God made me to do X', or 'God created me to have Y effect on the world') isn't meaningful in the way people want intrinsic or subjective purposes to be anyway. In that sense religious institutions provide the same kind of earthly, banal, limited meaning that hackerspaces or secular charities or sports clubs or families do. But they're not any better at making existentialist yearnings well-formed than anything else is. I also don't think all that is necessary to explain the phenomenon at hand. That account is way too broad. Imo the drive here is more narrative; it's about making the stories of our lives make sense— often in the simple sense of making them unsurprising. Discovering a diagnosis can be very cathartic, and can (partially) explain lots of patterns and events from one's past. It also brings some relief because it tells us that we are not uniquely defective in our failings and points us towards examples of others who have managed to succeed or survive despite the same ailment. And it gives us a vocabulary for identifying similar people from whom we can learn and in whom we can find solidarity. All of those things being are rewarding and/or useful.
- azinman2 2y agoIt’s not surprising. People seek identities to confirm who they are, find companionship and community, and attach themselves to something bigger than one can figure out for one’s self. We see it in people who are “healthy” as an identity, now in “nerds”… so for mental issues it makes you feel bigger than just yourself. I think less-clear identities are part of the big culture war struggle in the US… the inability to handle a plurality.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kthejoker2 2y ago"Are turning" implies some sort of novelty. But it is the same as it ever was. We've had the xuè-qì, humors, hysteria, the zodiac signs, witch hunts, the "sensitive" type, type A, temperaments, IQ tests, Freud, Rorschach, Jung, Myers-Briggs ... People will always try to "fix" themselves and others to a particular set of traits and then predict and analyze their future behavior through that "fixed" lens. We're barely a century removed from phrenology being an accepted criminal forensic tool. We have always been susceptible to the simplicity of psychiatric labels.
- samatman 2y ago> We're barely a century removed from phrenology being an accepted criminal forensic tool. This, specifically, is a bad argument. Medicine is barely a century removed from using mercury salts to treat syphilis, but as it stands, can completely cure it with modern treatments, the rise of drug-resistant strains notwithstanding. If modern psychopathology is still largely prescientific, which one can make a strong case for, this is because of psychopathology now, not psychopathology a century ago.
- TeMPOraL 2y ago> Medicine is barely a century removed from using mercury salts to treat syphilis A very good point, worth reminding ourselves regularly in general[0]: almost everything around you and me, everything that our lives depend on, or that helps us day-to-day, almost everything we see or interact with that isn't wild nature - all that has been made possible in the past ~200 years. Most of that in less than 100. Science as we understand it today, is less than 200 years old. Medicine stopped being voodoo less than a century ago. Petroleum chemistry and materials engineering have defined most of how modernity looks in general; like every other field of endeavor, they really kicked into gear ~100 years ago. Circling back to GP's statement: >> We're barely a century removed from phrenology being an accepted criminal forensic tool. That's because we're barely a century removed from being a proper technological civilization - one that follows knowledge in a systematic fashion, instead of folklore in a haphazard way. -- [0] - Especially when playing with notions that current age is no different than all the ages before. It really is.
- bjornsing 2y agoI sometimes wonder how much of the incurability of some of these illnesses or mental states is a product of people making them a part of their identity, or having that identity forced upon them by others. Because as pg quipped on Twitter the other day: “Never make a fixable problem a part of your identity, because then you’ll never fix it!”
- thefaux 2y agoYeah, that's why I always raise an eyebrow when people self describe as say a java dev or a rubyist.
- TeMPOraL 2y agoI feel this is something you do early on, as it generates drive and gives some sense of belonging (and faux us-vs-them conflicts that can pump a lot of motivation). Eventually, you learn and experience enough to transcend identifying yourself with a single set of tools.
- mrangle 2y agoA problem with the article is the lack of differentiation, for stated or implied diagnoses, between potentially curable conditions and those that are developmental.
- rachofsunshine 2y agoHaving an understanding of what was wrong with me was an important part of understanding how to fix it, or more properly, how to work around it. I struggle plenty with depression and anxiety in the mental-illness sense of those words (as opposed to the current-emotional-state sense). What that means is that my brain is always over-sensitive to negatives and assumes bad outcomes in cases of ambiguity, to a degree that isn't rationally justifiable. I can't control that fact; it doesn't occur on a conscious level and those are inputs to my cognition, not outputs of it. But what I can do is recognize that because I am helpless to change those inputs, I need to know that they're warped and know how to compensate for them. I know that my brain will serve me aggressively negative examples and downplay positive ones, so I needed to practice both (a) not listening to it and (b) consciously recalling positive examples to counterbalance it. I know my brain will make me nervous and jittery, so I needed to consciously train myself to think "okay, even if I totally screw this up, it isn't the end of the world". I know I tend to avoid things that scare or stress me, so I needed to train myself to confront or remove them. What my brain tells me still "feels" right to me, and it probably always will, and in that sense I cannot not have the mental health struggles I do. They are, in that sense, cognitively incurable (and so far I have not found a medication that lastingly cures them either). But understanding the fact that that is a fundamental part of the mental world in which I live has given me a lot of tools to do better than I could in the past.
- pseudalopex 2y ago> People’s symptoms frequently evolve according to the labels they’ve been given. This could be true. But the anecdotes and claims in the article are weak evidence. > Following Layle’s visit to the psychiatrist, her mother observed, “You’ve been acting more and more autistic since we got the diagnosis.” Reduced masking after diagnosis is common. Or her mother could have noticed and related behaviors she didn't before. > In 2006, a student at a Mexican boarding school developed devastating leg pain and had trouble walking; soon hundreds of classmates were afflicted. A fifteenth-century German nun started biting her companions; eventually, the strange hysteria infected convents from Holland to Italy. This is argument from analogy. Mass hysteria spreads without labels. And it is rare. > Ian Hacking, the philosopher, argued that such a dynamic fuelled the epidemic of multiple personality disorder in the late twentieth century, and something similar seems to be playing out now with the growing portrayal of dissociative identity disorder, the current name for M.P.D., on social media. This is begging the question. People more qualified than a philosopher have argued many perspectives about DID diagnosis. > One of Kriss’s patients, a student who went by Haku, developed a multiplicity of selves after being introduced to the concept of dissociative identity disorder. “It’s not that I thought he was faking it,” Kriss recalls. “It seemed more that Haku wanted to have multiple personalities, even if that meant he had to force himself and others to believe in it.” But does it occur frequently?
- pxc 2y ago> People more qualified than a philosopher have argued many perspectives about DID diagnosis. Idk why you'd think a medical practitioner would be more qualified than a philosopher of science about when it comes to methodological issues, but you're wrong.
- TeMPOraL 2y agoPerhaps because without having their theories reality-checked on a regular basis, a philosopher of science effectively turns into a protein-based LLM: saying convincing things, but unable to realize when some of it is wrong and invalidates everything said from that point on. Medical practitioners live and breathe methodology; they experience both the process and its output. They are the reality test.
- kristianp 2y agoOne mental health problem not mentioned here is schizophrenia. Having a family member afflicted, I don't think having a label makes things much better. The schizophrenia treatments available just make me feel that we understand so little about it. The drugs used are such blunt weapons that can be debilitating in themselves.
- throw18376 2y agomy theory is that schizophrenia is so difficult that most people prefer not to think about it. People seem to have a mental block or resistance about the fact that some people have the disease of schizophrenia, and about what its symptoms and prognosis look like. if true, maybe that’s why it’s usually not mentioned in discussions about the politics of mental health, and why people don’t even consider “schizophrenia” when they see someone behaving strangely.
- richardatlarge 2y agoWe’re trapped once we believe a common set of symptoms means the same cause- it just ain’t so. It helps even less to confuse biological correlations to the mental/behavioral symptoms as the causes of those symptoms, as if seeing a state of love in an MRI leads use to think it’s a brain disease
- chipdart 2y ago> The schizophrenia treatments available just make me feel that we understand so little about it. The drugs used are such blunt weapons that can be debilitating in themselves. It's interesting to point out that this is also true in most health fields. For example, dentists still base their practice around drilling and pulling teeth. Wooden dentures have been replaced with the same concept using fancier materials.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 2y agoHN editorialised title: "Turning psychiatric labels into identities" Author's title: "Why We're Turning Psychiatric Labels Into Identities" Print edition title: "Read the label"
- Lockal 2y ago"editorialise = express opinions rather than just report the news" It is a anti-clickbait practice to remove "you" or "we" (implying reader) from titles on HN, not editorialization.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 2y agoCorrection: HN edited title: "Why We're Turning Psychiatric Labels Into Identities"
- JohnMakin 2y agoThis article is so insulting to anyone suffering from a psychiatric illness. The reason people "cling" to labels, is because when you're suffering from something as severe and difficult to live with in normal society such as complex/chronic PTSD, answering the question "What the hell is wrong with you?" becomes extremely difficult without these labels, and will drive one to despair trying to explain and maintain normal relationships. That's why people are so happy finally being given one, because they themselves have had no real explanation for a long time to their friends/family as to what's going on, get labeled as "crazy" or "unstable" or all the other million horrible words people use to describe someone undergoing mental issues. This isn't even to mention that these labels are often useful in obtaining the care you actually need rather than the care the doctor thinks you need based on his biases, which may or may not be correct (often it isn't). More than that though, using the PTSD example - it becomes an identity because when you suffer from something like that it informs every waking moment of your existence and needs to be considered before nearly any activity. How else would you expect someone to cope? That is their identity, they have to live with it every day of their lives, unlike the author of this ludicrous, puffy "thought" piece. /rant
- chipdart 2y ago> The reason people "cling" to labels, is because when you're suffering from something as severe and difficult to live with in normal society such as complex/chronic PTSD, answering the question "What the hell is wrong with you?" becomes extremely difficult without these labels, and will drive one to despair trying to explain and maintain normal relationships. I think this point of view ignores the main point of the article: the social labels, not the trait that substantiates those social labels. There are people who self-assign those labels in spite of not actually having been diagnosed with any condition, and go as far as making the label a central part of their identity. The fact that using these labels is not necessarily correlated with actually having the conditions is the key aspect.
- JohnMakin 2y ago> There are people who self-assign those labels in spite of not actually having been diagnosed with any condition so what? >The fact that using these labels is not necessarily correlated with actually having the conditions is the key aspect. fact according to who? the evidence in this article is weak. and even if you assume it is actually true, what is the actual problem here? you cannot simultaneously proclaim that self diagnosis is invalid while proclaiming that the same DSM professionals use to make diagnoses is invalid, without doing a lot of explaining and gap-filling. It is one or the other.
- thebigspacefuck 2y agoI have struggled to find a label that accurately describes myself. While diagnosed with ADHD before, I don’t really feel that is accurate. There is a huge difference in diagnosis in the US vs the EU. I currently go with “gifted” or 2e which I understand as high IQ, some amount of ADHD and/or some amount of ASD. However gifted has a couple issues, one being as a label it implies I’m better than, so is less socially acceptable than a “disorder”. It also is currently being done away with in schools because IQ is racist or something. If there was a high IQ disorder, this would be a perfect label as it acknowledges the drawbacks. Neurodivergent is currently where I’m at just to acknowledge I’m different but not the exact reason why.
- OptionOfT 2y agoThe reason I had to make it my identity is to get other people to understand that it isn't just something I can change, ignore, or just do differently.