3 ms·
Do these fake papers have real authors trying to take credit for them? Or are they just noise to break science?
by Animats 2y ago
Do these fake papers have real authors trying to take credit for them? Or are they just noise to break science?
- ant6n 2y agoPerhaps the San Ti at work? This is much easier than breaking every accelerator experiment at an atomic level.
- em-bee 2y agogood theory, but the san ti can not lie or deceive. breaking the accelerator is honest work. faking papers isn't.
- gus_massa 2y agoIn most universities you need some ammount of papers to get a position or to not be fired. So I guess it's real people in places where the administrators are morons and can't check the quality of the journals. (Checking the quality of the journals is a very difficult task. We have that problem from time to time to select the graduate teaching assistants. Let's say that each time the list of good journals is sligtly differentand every time nobody is happy.) (Checking the quality of the papers is even harder. Just count them, or count the citations, or something.) Another posibility is borderline crackpots. You can spot them when the journal has too many single author papers. They essentialy pay and get a very credulous peer review and later nobody reads the paper, but the author is happy to have a published article. (From time to time there are good single author papers. It's geting rare, but it's possible. Anyway, it's a red flag, and if you see many of them in a journal you should get suspictious.)