3 ms·
Is the amount of mining to be done actually a serious concern of any real policymaker? This seems like a nitty-gritty detail argument between, as the article d
by bee_rider 2y ago
Is the amount of mining to be done actually a serious concern of any real policymaker?
This seems like a nitty-gritty detail argument between, as the article describes them, “traditional” and “pragmatic” environmentalists. Does it matter who wins? Does either have the bribe money to challenge petrochemical companies?
As far as I’ve heard, the main obstacle to overcome for nuclear power is that the permitting process is too slow, because the public is irrationally frightened of the stuff. On one hand this is not a fair problem for nuclear power. On the other, unfortunately, the uninformed general public is making all the decisions, not people who care about % differences in quantities of rocks mined.
- ender341341 2y ago> Is the amount of mining to be done actually a serious concern of any real policymaker? Mines are job providers, so at least some policymakers are actively opposed to reducing it.
- djbusby 2y agoThe things that replace the mines provide jobs too. What if we compare the count, wage and type of labor? It's not like one has jobs and the other has zero.
- klyrs 2y agoManufacturing and installing heat pumps, solar panels, etc. could be a huge source of blue collar jobs too, but it isn't just about the jobs, is it?
- ender341341 2y agoright, I'm 100% on board with that, but there's a sizeable population of voters whose jobs would be disrupted that are very against it, so their representatives like Manchin are against it.
- bee_rider 2y agoAnd they are attached to those particular jobs unfortunately. I don’t get it at all. I mean, who would want to work in a coal mine? I’d think the change of coal mine worker to solar panel maintainence would be a massive QoL improvement. Go around outside. Get some sun and fresh air. But I guess we can’t tell people how they want to work.
- bobthepanda 2y agoThat’s one of the problems but not the only problems. Plants that are completed on time and under budget are rare and they also suck up billions if not tens of billions of dollars. The amount of entities with that kind of investment power is very small, and only a few of those are interested in nuclear power because of the delays and cost overruns. Small modular reactors are supposed to fix at least the “tens of billions of dollars” problem but there aren’t any working examples, and the closest one I am aware of (NuScale) pulled the plug on its demonstration project, so the benefits of SMR remain theoretical. Compare that to a solar or wind project where individual units are small so it’s easy to scale up, scale down, and iterate through economies of scale.
- rbanffy 2y agoIt would make sense for an oil company to buy SMR IP just to bury it.