5 ms·
Milk watcher
- lbotos 2y agoDoes anyone use this? I'm surprised in my multi-cultural familial exposure, I'm not aware of any aunts/uncles using this in cooking, or cousins finding one in a drawer.
- brabarossa 2y agoYep, used a stainless steel one. Works great. I'm from Russia.
- ioblomov 2y agoJudging by the quoted patent dates, guessing it was most useful when mothers were still cooking for large families (and so had multiple pans/pots going on).
- brabarossa 2y agoIt's still useful if buying raw milk is cheaper then getting pasteurized one from the store.
- jamiek88 2y agoNowhere in the developed world is that true though. Economy of scale forbids it.
- Johnny555 2y agoUnless you happen to be a dairy farmer -- when I was a kid and we went to my grandfather's farm, he'd draw a pitcher of milk right from the holding tank and put it in the 'fridge for drinking. I'm not old enough to remember drinking it, but my older sister said it tasted better than store bought.
- BenjiWiebe 2y agoI live on a dairy. We sell raw milk self-serve (bring your own container too) for $3/gallon. Kansas.
- cooper_ganglia 2y agoNeat, I'll have to pick one up now!
- SomewhatLikely 2y agoI wonder if this would work in a rice cooker or if there's something equivalent. If I don't wash the rice beforehand it will tend to bubble starchy bubbles through the top that makes a mess
- softskunk 2y agonot washing the rice is generally a bad idea even disregarding this factor, because the texture of the rice will come out quite wrong.
- ioblomov 2y agoI normally rinse the rice too, but some think rinsing washes out some vitamins. I suppose the tradeoff is less vitamins or more pesticides?
- janalsncm 2y agoRinsing it can remove some of the toxic arsenic. https://health.osu.edu/wellness/exercise-and-nutrition/how-to-reduce-arsenic-in-rice https://health.osu.edu/wellness/exercise-and-nutrition/how-t...
- NeoTar 2y agoBut only about 20% of the arsenic. If you want to significantly reduce the arsenic, it is apparently better to cook rice like pasta in a large amount of water, and then drain it (in a sieve / strainer)
- CoastalCoder 2y agoI fancy myself a pretty decent cook, but rice has been the bane of my existence. I don't own a rice cooker, and I could never get it right. Then I learned about the pasta method. It probably closed about 80% of the quality gap in my finished product.
- inanutshellus 2y agoThere are so many things in my kitchen that we've gotten from relatives that have no discernible purpose. Like a ridiculously long knife with a slightly curved blade, rounded tip, and blunt edge. Or a serrated knife with that curves back on itself. I keep them because... one day, surely, I'll realize what they're for. These things need labels, people! Here's a good example, a little tiny hammer that you'd never ever use for anything. Oh wait, there's a label on it. Hm. Lemme look that up. OH IT'S FOR MAKING CANDY. https://i.etsystatic.com/7417371/r/il/5caf0a/4106895282/il_fullxfull.4106895282_hovy.jpg https://i.etsystatic.com/7417371/r/il/5caf0a/4106895282/il_f... I have one of these (though it just says "CHOCOLATE") and I mainly keep it around so that when I see it and feel that warm glow of knowledge, I can then be spitefully angry at all the mysterious, unlabeled niche-problem-solver tools in my kitchen.
- derefr 2y agoThese are the sorts of things that won't yield to a specific keyword search (because you aren't giving the search engine the "terms of art" used people who use the thing), but where you can probably figure these out pretty quickly if you just do a search to find some kind of index for the category-of-thing and start browsing. I'd recommend search queries like "types of knives", "obscure kitchen utensils", "what is this knife", etc. You can also try giving /r/tipofmytongue or a related subreddit a very detailed description of the object. Some of the results from the above queries point to people asking questions like this on subreddits like /r/tools. (Or you could do the same thing with ChatGPT — but that'll only work if someone has ever before described the object in a book or on the Internet somewhere, in the terms you're using. ChatGPT can only match your verbal questions to verbal memories. Whereas a person on a subreddit can take your description, conjure a mental image of it, and then correlate that mental image with a visual memory.) I'll also take a shot at giving you starting points, just because I happen to find learning about weird kitchen tools fascinating: > Like a ridiculously long knife with a slightly curved blade, rounded tip, and blunt edge. A cake-icing spatula of some kind? I would imagine one made specifically for smoothing the icing on the side of a cylindrical layer cake would have this shape. Usually cake spatulas are also offset (blade makes two complementary bends and so ends up parallel to, but not in line with, the handle), but they don't have to be. > Or a serrated knife with that curves back on itself. If the end can also be used as a fork, then that's a cheese knife.
- ZeljkoS 2y agoIn action: https://youtu.be/eVQDUoD_cJY?si=qNL3NZNQPGJCHMPn&t=40 https://youtu.be/eVQDUoD_cJY?si=qNL3NZNQPGJCHMPn&t=40
- metadat 2y agoWow, to my surprise, the sound is incredibly annoying and stress-inducing. At first I wasn't sure if it's some kind of poor-taste soundtrack, but that is only the background tune. The tap tap tap is the stainless steel device. Edit: @hombre_fatal - Steel on steel will always clang.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- genewitch 2y agoit's supposed to be alarming, so you can go turn the heat down once something starts boiling enough to boil over. Similar to a stove-top pressure cooker, you have to wait for the sound to know where to set the heat.
- bayindirh 2y agoI use a glass milk watcher while boiling milk for making yogurt, and the clak (not clank) sound is not that stress inducing. On the contrary, it's a heartbeat which says that your milk is safe from boiling over and tasty yogurt prospects are still strong. I think it's a matter of getting used to it.
- logrot 2y agoWould that not increase the chances of things getting burnt at the base?
- ajb 2y agoNot really, since milk contains water the max temperature you can reach is 100 degrees (given it has a path to atmospheric pressure). So the bottom can only burn if all the water boils off.
- BugsJustFindMe 2y ago"contains water" is very obviously insufficient for this to be anywhere close to true.
- smoothbran 2y agoA beautiful demonstration of the difference between theory and practice.
- bmacho 2y agoSounds interesting! I wonder what happens, when milk gets burned! - - - I gave it some thought, and a possible explanation is that water evaporates from the bottom of the pot, it leaves some waterless milk there, and that burns. But this assumes that the inside of the pot can be hotter than 100°C, I wonder if that's true, or milk keeps it ~100°C (water is very good at transferring heat after all).
- em-bee 2y agoi recently discovered that if i heat up milk in a waterbath (a pot of milk inside a pot of water) it also prevents boiling over. most likely because it doesn't actually bring the milk to a boil, but keeps it a few degrees below the boiling point. in most cases i just want to have hot milk, and i don't need the milk to have actually reached the boiling point. are there any cases where that is not enough? (assuming already pasteurized store bought milk)
- cbsmith 2y agoSo a double boiler?
- em-bee 2y agoyes
- kwhitefoot 2y agoAlso known as a bain-marie.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- leoh 2y agoDoes it work for pasta?
- Hnrobert42 2y agoI was thinking about that, and I would guess no. The bubble pushing through the pasta would likely break into small bubbles again. Placing a spoon across the top of the pot works alright. I just read something that said putting oil around the pot rim also helps.
- worstspotgain 2y agoYou don't want to use this for pasta. The ideal cooking temperature is just above the boiling point. Boil-over is your cue that the water is too hot: uncover more of the pot and/or turn down the heat.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jannyfer 2y agoIf you use this, then instead of a boil-over and a mess, you get a clang and no mess at the boiling point.
- gattilorenz 2y agoGelification of the starches should happen at around 80C (although a bit slower); you can literally turn off the heating after it reached the boiling point, put the lid on the pot, and it will cook (but it should take ~1/2 minutes extra). In what sense is "just above the boiling point" the "ideal temperature"? But in general... how can the water get "too hot" or "above the boiling point"? It will reach ~100 degrees, that's the boiling point (atmospheric pressure aside) and it will... just stop there? Technically salty water will have a slightly different boiling point, but it's not different enough to matter.
- worstspotgain 2y agoThis is the "Italian canon" I've been taught: a gentle boil, stirring often. It ranges from no bubbles, to a few bubbles, to a lot. A few bubbles are ideal. I'm not familiar with the chemistry, just with how the kosher al dente finished product is supposed to taste. I'm guessing the water temperature gradient goes from 100C at the bottom to something less at the top. If you prefer it cooked another way, then by all means.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kazinator 2y agoLooks like a saucer or soy sauce dish could be used for this purpose. Those things don't have notches, but it doesn't matter; they will release the large bubble one way or another.
- bayindirh 2y agoThey're not heavy enough and won't sink to bottom as fast as other watchers do. The trick is they don't lift up from the bottom of the container they're in, just tip up a little, release the bubble, but more importantly hit with relatively great speed to stir the liquid from the bottom.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kazinator 2y ago> They're not heavy enough Ceramics have a specific gravity of at least around 2.2 or so; they sink like rocks, since they literally are. > they don't lift up from the bottom [...] just tip I can easily see a saucer doing the same thing: accumulating enough steam for the buoyancy to tip it up to release a bubble. I don't suspect your physical intutition here is so accurate that you can declare that it wouldn't work, without any empirical trials. Milk watchers may be massive, but perhaps that may not be necessary to their function. It could just be marketing: differentiating them from other objects and justifying their purchase. Nobody would buy a milk watcher if it looked exactly like a saucer, of which they already have eight at home. Not everything that has mass actually requires it for function, and it can even be counterproductive. Bicycles don't have to weigh 50 pounds, but cheap ones do, and they look rugged for it to the layman eye.
- bayindirh 2y ago> Ceramics have a specific gravity of at least around 2.2 or so... I think I failed to make my point clear. All milk watchers have a specific crevice volume / weight ratio, making them very hard to tip even under extreme conditions. So, the lifting force accumulating under a watcher is tightly controlled with the hole and the capacity of the crevice. > I don't suspect your physical intutition[sic] here is so accurate that you can declare that it wouldn't work, without any empirical trials. The problem saucers is their volume/weight ratio plus their asymmetric construction. Since they're not heavy enough, they won't be able to hit the bottom with the force required, hence fail to stir the liquid adequately. Moreover, a milk watcher is symmetric. Even in an extreme case you can completely flip one, it'll continue to function. The moment the saucer flips, it's game over. Watchers have features to reduce their likelihood to fail. Lastly, the internals of glass and ceramic watchers are slanted to further prevent lift-off, but to enable tip and hit back. These features makes a watcher a deterministic device. Almost unflippable, with a tuned tendency to tip slightly and with a tuned weight to hit with enough force to stir the liquid. They are unhinged yet hinged wave machines. The saucer is the complete opposite. A dome with a tendency to launch, with a low weight to crevice volume ratio, and no built-in mechanisms to prevent and recover from flips. A saucer has a tendency to launch up, a watcher has a tendency to "flip". They are not marketing gimmicks. If they were they wouldn't be used in our home for 40 years, and I won't be continuing the tradition. > Not everything that has mass actually requires it for function, and it can even be counterproductive. Please, everything doesn't have to be light to function properly. Paperweights, door stops, wrecking balls, pool balls, throwing discs and throwing stones come into my mind. They won't work without their weight.
- PobedaRossia 2y ago[flagged]