24 ms·
What kind of copyright reform would you like to see? Is it to do with the years a person has copyright on something? My ideas: • Copyright lasts 10 years from
by rmc 14y ago
What kind of copyright reform would you like to see? Is it to do with the years a person has copyright on something?
My ideas:
• Copyright lasts 10 years from creation, maybe extensible to 20 or 30 if you pay a fee based on the amount of years you want extra. As with the existing system, copyright is instaneous and doesn't require a registration fee.
• Similar to trademark law, "everyone else is let away with it" should be a defence to copyright infringement. (e.g. You are being sued for using a P2P network, but you can find lots of people who weren't sued, ergo you get off the hook. This happens with trademarks)
• Bring the law into line with what the general public thinks are moral, e.g. format shifting, time shifting, should be legal.
• Gradual "Creative Commons-ification" of all copyright. After 10 years, all copyrighted material is also available as a CC-BY-ND-NC (creative commons, non commercial, attribution, no derivates) licence. After 15, CC-BY-NC etc.
• A work is only copyrightable in a country if the original copyright holder is commercially exploiting it (or was commercially exploiting it in the last ~5 years). Films made in the USA but not available in, say, UK, are copyrighted. If a book goes out of print, and you can't buy it, you can't photocopy it.
• Loss of copyright if there are too many false applications of DMCA-type take down notices for that work.
I have no problem with corporations holding copyright, artists should be allowed sell it.
- bad_user 14y agoFormat shifting is legal, falling under fair use. The problem is with DRM which can't be legally circumvented, even if you are the author of the freaking thing (trying to recover your own work from a Blu-Ray or something).
- rmc 14y agoFormat shifting is not legal in some countries, notable the UK.
- zrail 14y agoThe forced gradual opening of rights is interesting. After 10 years, you can still make money off licensing fees but everyone can use it for non-commercial purposes, then later on that drops off. I like it.