3 ms·
Effects of $9 Price Endings in Retail: Evidence from Field Experiments [pdf] (2003)
- grishka 2y agoIt's very unfortunate that this actually works on someone, this means everyone else would have to suffer forever even if it works on 1% of people. I always find those 9-ending prices infuriatingly manipulative. Like you have to actually engage the higher-level thought processes to round them up so they make sense. Once someone priced something at $300 instead of $299 and his ass fell off.
- Retric 2y agoWhile they “work” it doesn’t mean people would behave differently if nobody used it ever. People have finite money so over time spending habits end up balancing with incomes by necessity and most people end up spending everything they make over time. So whatever willingness people have to buy something at 19.99 would likely be reached at 20$ if that was the normal price everywhere.
- II2II 2y agoLet's say that you are pricing products and a competitor is charging $19.99. You know that one cent is not going to change the purchasing decision of potential customers. If it did, you would simply price your product at $19.98 (and maybe get into a price war one penny at a time). Yet you also know that the price ending with a nine will have an impact upon sales. It is not rational, but that's what the statistics appear to say. While it won't have any meaningful impact upon how much money people have to spend, it will have an impact upon where people spend their money.
- Retric 2y agoSure it’s a prisoner’s dilemma. If everyone charges 20$ then everyone gets to charge 20$ but as soon as someone uses 19.99 everyone is stuck charging 19.99. It also implies a rather large economic inefficiency where companies don’t charge 13.27$ because people don’t pay enough attention for it to matter.
- arprocter 2y agoThe one I've never been able to figure out is why gas prices can end in a fraction of a penny Presumably you can't buy less than a penny's worth of gas, so how is this allowed?
- grishka 2y agoThat must be a uniquely US thing. Outside of the US I've only seen fractions of cents in currency exchange rates.
- arprocter 2y agoSame in the UK (although a decimal instead of '9/10') https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/59/Shell_sign_97.9_99.9.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/59/Shell_si...
- curtisf 2y agoAn interesting paper, but some of the other numbers reporting how these catalog sales work are also interesting. Apparently mailing a catalog to 60,000 people will only generate single-digit purchases for each item, with only about 1000 sales overall. That's a shockingly inefficient result for all the advertising and junk mail we all put up with, but also not particularly surprising. It does mean that these kinds of businesses need far smaller stocks than I would guess off the top of my head of each item.
- madaxe_again 2y agoI used to build ecommerce presences, many of which were for old catalogue merchants making the jump to ecommerce. It was eye-opening. Even in the heyday of catalogue shopping, which this paper is from the tail end of in the early noughts, conversion rates were abysmal - and they were entirely acceptant of that, and didn’t believe it could be improved upon. Don’t even get me started on print and distribution costs. You’re looking at double digit CPAs on sales. Margins had to make up for it, which usually meant cutting everything else to the bone and really, really pushing finance options. An interesting part of this was that when they went online they often really, really, really wanted to replicate the catalogue experience on their websites - page flipping, etc. - took a lot of dissuasion, and in one case where they were particularly obstinate, we went ahead with their desires, with the proviso that they would allow us to build a competing site on more traditional ecommerce lines at no additional cost, with the proviso that we got a cut of sales. They dropped their catalogues entirely a year into the experiment. Catalogues suck.
- alexchamberlain 2y ago> conversion rates were abysmal Is that surprising? Email campaigns have similarly low open and click rates, which are also accepted as the norm.
- madaxe_again 2y agoYeah, but on email it costs you $0.002 to hit a target - catalogues, you’re looking more like $3-$15 depending on scale, catalogue size and quality. Those things cost money.
- darreninthenet 2y agoIt used to be irritating when cash was king but now I use card for 99.9% of everything it doesn't really make much difference to the way I see prices. Purchased a couple of ice creams at a small museum cafe yesterday and they only took cash... change was 40p (UK here) so I just told them to put it in their donation box, didn't really want a load of coins in my pocket.
- smokel 2y agoThe basic idea is that 99 seems less than 100, but to my primitive mind 9 is higher than both 0 and 1. So here is your data point. You can now safely end this nonsense and still get my money. More of it, even.
- oersted 2y agoIt's a good point, I think it works better when the first number is smaller. For example: 199 vs 200 It's reasonable that at first glance people would look at the most significant digit for a reference.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago[dupe] Mentioned in and being discussed as part of: People spend more when prices end in .99 (2018) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40474736 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40474736
- hermitcrab 2y agoI heard there was a second reason for pricing say 9.99 instead of 10.00. It forced the cashier to open the register and ring up the sale to give the 0.01 change, rather than just quietly pocketing the 10.00. No idea how true this is, but it sounds plausible.
- CalRobert 2y agoEven more bizarre is gasoline prices in the US, priced at nine tenths of a cent.