6 ms·
MSI Teases Z790 Project Zero Plus Motherboard with CAMM2 Memory Support
- verandaguy 2y agoNeat! I've only done some surface-level digging into CAMM2/LPCAMM2, and assumed it'd target the laptop market first and foremost. It's interesting to see it on an ATX board targeting desktops. It also seems a bit... weird... to have it laid out flat on the board instead of having some way to slot them in the same way as DDR sticks, at least as far as space saving goes.
- mschuster91 2y ago> It also seems a bit... weird... to have it laid out flat on the board instead of having some way to slot them in the same way as DDR sticks, at least as far as space saving goes. Thanks to ever more integration of discrete chips, space isn't as much a premium as it used to be.
- Tuna-Fish 2y agoLPCAMM2 takes less actual space on the board than 4 dimm slots, which is what it will be replacing. Mainly because wiring it is simpler and it can be closer to the CPU socket.
- nottorp 2y agoOne module - i.e. the equivalent of 2 slots - takes less space than 4 dimm slots? The customer loses here.
- _cenw 2y agoAlmost nobody runs 4 sticks of unbuffered DDR5 anyway, because you wouldn't be able to get them to run above 4800 and you'll be spending several minutes waiting for memory training. And you get a minimum of 16GB per stick unless you buy modules with dead ranks. There's so little margin to total signal degradation in DDR5, these improvements are actually necessary (and more upgrade friendly than the inevitable future of memory on SoC).
- nottorp 2y ago> And you get a minimum of 16GB per stick unless you buy modules with dead ranks. 16 Gb per stick means you need 4 sticks to have a reasonably future proof 64 G...
- _cenw 2y agoThat's the smallest size, 32 on a single module also exists. There is no conspiracy to deprive you of density. Most consumers will just appreciate latency over more than 64GB of memory. And yes, that's a real world performance gain, especially on larger AMD chips where L3 isn't shared among all cores. If you want density, use a workstation board and registered memory, which offloads a bunch of responsibility of a central memory controller to the module itself, so you can stick terrabytes of somewhat fast memory in there.
- Tuna-Fish 2y ago> Most consumers will just appreciate latency over more than 64GB of memory. Note that the choice here is not either/or, so long as you are willing to pay for it. For example: https://www.corsair.com/us/en/p/memory/cmk96gx5m2b6600c32/vengeance-96gb-2x48gb-ddr5-dram-6600mt-s-cl32-memory-kit-black-cmk96gx5m2b6600c32#tab-techspecs https://www.corsair.com/us/en/p/memory/cmk96gx5m2b6600c32/ve...
- _cenw 2y agoyep, that's hynix m-die. not sure what the status quo is, but you used to be able to buy a cheap kit as long as the timings indicated hynix, and they'd manually overlock quite high without issues.
- Tuna-Fish 2y agoThe slots are not independently upgradeable on DDR5. Firstly, everyone uses dual channel. You don't buy a single module, you buy two at a time. Secondly, speeds go down so much for 2DPC that if you currently have 32GB (total) and want to have 64GB, the correct update path is not to purchase an additional 32GB, it is to toss your current 2 16GB modules and purchase two new 32GB modules. CAMM2 just recognizes this, and first puts all channels on a single module, and secondly gets rid of that stupid unusable second connector, in exchange for having room in the standard for larger module sizes.
- nottorp 2y ago> CAMM2 just recognizes this Ah, recognizes that we customers are being fucked over by the vendors chase for bigger numbers in benchmarks. Got it, thanks. Edit: based on all the explanations I got, DDR5 reminds me of ... the Pentium 4.
- doikor 2y agoIt's not really a vendor thing but signal integrity issue. CAMM2 just makes a lot more sense with DDR5. And fact is that we most likely want our next standard to be even faster so the issue is just going to get worse with DDR6 or whatever the next one we are going for is.
- nottorp 2y ago> It's not really a vendor thing but signal integrity issue. So, running into the same limits that CPUs have been running into for a while?
- bayindirh 2y agoRAM signalization is very sensitive to data line length, more so if you use low power RAM modules. This is not a "bigger number in a useless benchmark" thing, if you can standardize the shortest and fastest routing possible with a socket, everybody can use faster RAM for less (RAM command waits are the biggest killer of responsiveness), and everyone can enjoy faster, more responsive systems. Moreover, bigger RAM means bigger caches in any OS, and having these caches on faster storage means snappier, faster systems. Lastly, games and other engineering software use great amounts of RAM and moves tons of data between GPU RAM and system RAM. Having faster pipes helps. It's not about benchmarks, it's about real world performance.
- _spl 2y agoNice! No more CPU cooler and RAM clearance issues.
- DaiPlusPlus 2y ago> Compression Are the overheads of compression worth it for CAMM2?
- Tuna-Fish 2y agoDifferent kind of compression than you are probably thinking about. It's a compression-attached connector, like a CPU socket, instead of an edge connector like DIMM. CAMM was made necessary because SO-DIMM could no longer support the kind of signaling that next-gen memory needs. CAMM allows both for much cleaner signal paths, and for more signals. It's coming to desktops too because there is no sensible reason to have a separate desktop memory standard. The split between DIMM and SO-DIMM only exists because SO-DIMM is worse, and DIMM is usable on both servers and desktops. CAMM2 is better than DIMM, and servers have mostly moved to different, incompatible memory types anyway.
- DaiPlusPlus 2y agoOoooh, okay. I was thinking of something horrible, like DisplayPort DSC… but for RAM, because in aggregate that would need less bandwidth and less pins.
- nagisa 2y agoOne negative I see is that there is no way to incrementally add memory to the system with a just single slot. The good news is that it should be possible for future products to have two (or more?) of these slots on the back side of the board, enabling the extensibility after all.
- doikor 2y agoWith DDR5 it is very unlikely that you are going to add more memory modules on consumer boards. This is because if you add more then 2 you half the speed on both AMD and Intel platforms (and you don't get full speed with just 1 stick). Also if the new module is not exactly the same as the previous ones you can very easily run into stability issues. This is why on consumer land you are pretty much always buying your memory as a kit (of 2 modules with DDR5). And if you want more you buy a bigger kit and sell your old ones or throw them in the trash. On server side the memory controller on the CPU is much more beefy and the motherboard better built to allow for more memory sticks to run at full speeds. But even then you usually have to go and find memory that the OEM qualified/teste for you.
- nottorp 2y ago> This is because if you add more then 2 you half the speed on both AMD and Intel platforms (and you don't get full speed with just 1 stick). Modules have been added in pairs since forever due to motherboards being able to use dual channel. Except on the cheapest cheapest options (not all laptops). That doesn't mean you can't add more than one pair. Did that change with DDR5? Also note that this CAMM module is already dual channel. You don't need pairs any more.
- Gracana 2y agoYes, four slot DDR5 is going to be much slower than two slot DDR5 due to signal integrity difficulties. Look at a DDR5 motherboard’s qualified memory configurations and compare the x2 setups to x4 and you will see the huge difference in clock rates.
- hatch_q 2y agoI wish for future CPU sockets to use CAMM-style compression boards. I've seen too many motherboards with bent/broken pins in past few years.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- snvzz 2y agoQuestion being: Does it support ECC?