4 ms·
Copyright should only be long enough to encourage creation of content. Back in the days, when things moved a million times slower than they do today, 14 years
by josteink 14y ago
Copyright should only be long enough to encourage creation of content.
Back in the days, when things moved a million times slower than they do today, 14 years was more than sufficient to encourage mass creation of content. No author's life plus plus bullshit. 14 years. That's what you got to monetize. No more.
I see no reason it should be anything more today.
- glesica 14y agoI personally like this idea, or some variant thereof. Bringing the life of the author into the copyright term just muddies the waters with respect to corporate copyright (since corporations don't necessarily ever cease to exist). Additionally, if a creator dies suddenly, his estate can still exercise his copyright. This is important for small-time creators who may be supporting families and the like. The big counter-argument that I've heard is that movie studios (Disney especially with the "vault") still make money on movies that are decades old. But this is a fundamentally flawed argument. The point of copyright (both theoretically and in the US Constitution) is to encourage creation. So it doesn't matter if copyright doesn't maximize Disney's revenue, so long as it is enough to encourage them to make movies in the first place. A term of roughly 10-20 years should be more than enough to do that.
- toyg 14y agoIf anything, the Disney example is in favour of short terms: as it is, Disney could now just sit on their bottom and keep selling what they've produced in the 60s rather than creating new content.
- rmc 14y agoBringing the life of the author into the copyright term just muddies the waters with respect to corporate copyright (since corporations don't necessarily ever cease to exist) They've thought of that. Usually the law says "50 years from creation if the copyright is held by a company" or something like that.
- luriel 14y agoCorporate copyright is 120 years after creation or 95 years after publication, whichever is shorter: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_law_of_the_United_States#Duration_of_copyright http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_law_of_the_United_Sta... Can somebody please explain to me how this is not insane?
- rmc 14y agoAgreed. Remember that big budget creative works (games, films, tv shows) are considered a failure if they don't make money with 1 year of release. Very people wait 10 years before deciding if something is a success or not.
- k-mcgrady 14y agoTrue but what about musicians who write songs and don't release them until many years later (stuff that is written and not released until it fits on an album 5 years down the road). If we shorten the copyright period too much it could be problematic for them. It may just be an issue that we are trying to protect too many different types of work under one law. Having vastly different lengths for writers, musicians, software, movies, games etc. may help (although it could also make things 10 times worse).
- anamax 14y ago> True but what about musicians who write songs and don't release them until many years later (stuff that is written and not released until it fits on an album 5 years down the road). If we shorten the copyright period too much it could be problematic for them. That's solved by not starting the copyright clock until they make it available for copying, that is, releasing it. Do you have an example of a piece of music that sat around for more than 30 days before it was released unchanged? I ask because the last change starts a copyright clock....
- k-mcgrady 14y agoThat makes sense. I was thinking of the stories about artists like Michael Jackson having hundreds of unreleased tracks in vaults or bands like Nirvana releasing compilation albums with unreleased tracks 10/15 years after the band ends. Starting copyright upon release would solve the problem.
- pgeorgi 14y agoAs I understand it, the "life + x" idea came from Europe. The situation in Germany: It's not possible to preemptively put works in the public domain here (except by publishing anonymously and making sure no-one manages to associate that art with the artist). Our "Urheberrecht" (author's rights) is more along the notion of art being an expression of the author's personality, and thus needing appropriate protection. "copyright" (the right to commercially exploit these works) is merely a part of it. Under this model, it makes sense to protect works for life time + X years. (+ X years to make sure that things can settle down, instead of controversial art flaring up right after the artist's death). A good compromise could have been to restrict commercial value to 15 years after publication (or whatever) while keeping certain non-monetary rights to the author for life (recognition, the right to forfeit recognition, ...).