What about justice for the shooter then? You believe [some] people are born fundamentally evil, I believe such people are sick. I can think of two systems whi

What about justice for the shooter then? You believe [some] people are born fundamentally evil, I believe such people are sick. I can think of two systems which are arguably more humane than decades in concrete cages or death: 1) Caste system, so you can create restricted high caste areas where non-criminals can be safe from criminals (with concrete caging in lieu of obeying these laws, so long term imprison is more of a last step than a primary go-to). China is kind-of doing this with social credit scores, I do not like this as it relies on automated surveillance and it is not a replacement for their cages and labor camps. Societies are by nature prisons already, I am advocating the lowest caste (imprisoned criminals) be given much more open access and normalized living conditions in large legally/materially walled off county/parish-size (or larger) Australia-like areas where they can live normal lives with other high risk individuals and away from the high trust low risk individuals. High caste can enter low caste areas, but not vice versa (without a visa and sponsorship, think gated HOA guests). 2) Expatriation with threat of long term caging, hard labor, or death upon return. We don't do either because statists rely on the fear of the future generated in you when you believe the state is inevitable and omnipotent, and not in any way shape or form a voluntary relationship.