6 ms·
3-D Printing's Legal Morass
- iwwr 14y agoThis may be a storm in a teacup. 3D printing doesn't make sense for mass manufacturing, nor in the possible future lest for at least one order of magnitude increase in speed and cost of raw materials. We're still talking of hours to build a small figurine and $50/kg in material prices. If we move out of plastic and into metal, the process is again 100 times slower (or very energy intensive) and the machines are priced in multiples of $100K.
- jeffool 14y agoI get what you're saying, but if the tech is left untouched, any advancement gained in a few decades time will likely be less impressive than a few decades of commercial and niche amateur interest. No one is saying let's shut down factories yet. (I don't think.)
- Wilya 14y agoI agree. "Photocopying" an object is still way more expensive than buying it. The price of machines, especially for plastic printing, can and will probably go down (1000$ seems high, I think the small ones are more in the 400/500 range right now). The price of material ? I don't see that happening.
- Anderkent 14y agoThat depends what kind of object it is. Take the example of warhammer figurines - these things are incredibly expensive and cheap to manufacture.
- bradleyland 14y agoThis is dangerous thinking, IMO. Look at where we are with other media (music and movies). Years ago, the same thinking was applied to music and movies. "Well, this isn't a big problem, because duplicating the content is expensive and time consuming." The technology advanced, and now copying digital goods is very nearly free from a time and money standpoint. Should we wait for things to get as sideways as they are with music and movies before we put some weight behind reform?
- smacktoward 14y agoThe difference is that music and movies can be translated into digital format, which makes copying effectively free. 3D printing is physical, not digital. Every copy you make will require raw materials and will cause wear and tear on the printer. That creates costs. Those costs will probably come down over time, of course, but nowhere near as fast as the cost of digital duplication has. The price of plastic doesn't obey Moore's Law.
- vecinu 14y agoMusic and movies used to only be available on physical media until internet connections became quick enough to be able to download files from geographically anywhere. One could say the same for CD/DVD/Blu-Ray burners...one needs energy to run the burner and a laser to inscribe the data onto the physical media. I think the same logic applies to 3-D printers.
- stan_rogers 14y agoI think the same logic applies to 3-D printers. How? In the one case, you have a situation where it is no longer necessary to have (or produce) the "thing" in order to use it. That is to say that you no longer need the CD/DVD or other physical medium in order to use the bits they carried. Printed (or otherwise rapidly prototyped) physical artifacts are quite a different thing. Having the 3D model or CNC cutting paths of a physical thing is in no way equal, or even equivalent, to having the thing itself. If the time and cost involved in making a replica is greater than the time and cost of popping down to the shop to pick up the genuine article or of ordering it online and waiting for delivery, then printing's not at all cost-effective. That's not to say that 3D printing (or subtractive RP) has no utility at all. One of its advantages is that it can be used as a relatively cheap substitute for maintaining parts inventories over extended periods of time—but only for some types of parts. And it is a good way of distributing low-volume decorative works, since the print price is not much higher than the per-unit price of low-volume tooling. (Or at least it will be when the resolution is sufficiently high, since most users are not likely to want to spend a lot of time chasing and filleting their print results.)
- debacle 14y agoLong term, it's going to be cheaper to ship raw materials and print toys on demand in the stores. The amount of resources we waste and pollute on packaging today is an atrocity, and 3D printing will go a long way to destroying that.
- brohee 14y agoCost wise, between buying a plastic figurine off the Internet and printing it, printing is already competitive (possibly more expensive to manufacture but you save shipping and handling). Printing a figurine is also faster than getting it delivered, or even than going to a brick and mortar shop unless it's really close. So for decorative stuff 3D printing is already there (if the design is printable and if you can live with limited choices in material), but the real revolution will be when you can print replacement parts to fight planned obsolescence, entire industries may crumble.
- enjalot 14y agoYou miss probably the major disruption that 3D printing brings to manufacturing, it turns it into a software problem. We've seen what happens when something is reduced to bits that can be manipulated by software, and now we are going to watch it happen to the physical world. What happens when you don't just torrent a model to print, but you distribute your job to hundreds of printers? We have all seen what happens when you network a bunch of cheaper and lower quality things relative to a monolithic system, and I can see this happening with digital fabrication as well.
- alexqgb 14y agoA fine example of a headline editor stating one thing ("morass!") and the author stating another ("probably no morass right now, but in a corrupt congress, that could change.")
- debacle 14y agoIt is a legal morass, we just are only on the edges of it now. The 3D printing battle will be bloodier than the digital copying battle, precisely because there is much more to lose.
- planetguy 14y agoI have my doubts. I think there's more money in selling copyrighted content than in selling the fairly narrow range of products that can be produced with a 3D printer. Looking around the room right now, the number of objects here that could be cranked out with any 3D printer is pretty darn small. For those that could, I doubt it would be any cheaper for me to 3D-print the darn thing, even if I already had the 3D printer, than it was for me to buy the real mass-produced deal. The article's example of "little figurines" is the only example I can think of, and the little figurine industry isn't large compared to music or movies.
- joshuahedlund 14y agoThe range of products that can be produced with a 3D printer today may be significantly smaller than the range of products that can be produced with a 3D printer in X years.
- zephjc 14y agoIf you view 3D printing as a baby-step to Trek-like replicator technology^, then you may see that its more of a moral imperative that 3D printing technology become as cheap and elaborate as possible, as quickly as possible. The only bottleneck to providing material objects for free or next to free should be in finding raw materials that can be printed out, and as a start, there's lots of that filling up the world's landfills. Where sharing music and movies was pretty much zero real gain for file-sharers (you can live without the latest Lady Gaga album or Transformer movie), having access to super cheap working replicas of things like refrigerators, water purifiers, clothing, house-building materials, etc., can dramatically affect countless lives, especially in developing countries. The rug absolutely must be pulled out from under the feet of the manner in which material objects are created and distributed, hopefully diminishing the number of have-nots in the world. ^ Not necessarily real energy->matter conversion, but something nearly as cheap and elaborate.
- vecinu 14y ago> The rug absolutely must be pulled out from under the feet of the manner in which material objects are created and distributed, hopefully diminishing the number of have-nots in the world. I don't necessarily agree with this statement. I believe that even though overpopulation IS a pressing issue at the moment, its effects aren't as devastating because half of the world's population does not have access to a lot of materials. If everyone in developing nations suddenly manufactured their own parts, we would see a huge strain on non-renewable resources really quickly. I'm still curious if we have enough copper available to keep up with the demand for housing, electrical components and all the wires we are using to power our devices.
- ktizo 14y agosee a huge strain on non-renewable resources With a plastic chipper, feedstock extruder and a suitably stocked waste dump, this becomes less of an issue.
- simcop2387 14y agoTwo thirds of that is being attempted to be provided by a kickstarter that ran a while ago [1], he hasn't shipped anything yet but once he does I'll probably write up a review of how well it works. So far it looks to be shaping up to be working but how well it'll work altogether is another question that can't be answered by me yet. [1] http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/rocknail/filabot-plastic-filament-maker http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/rocknail/filabot-plastic...
- ctdonath 14y agoWe've been thru all these battles before. Look for the viable/profitable solutions already achieved. How long to "iTunes Match" for MakerBot et al? 3D-scan all your stuff, your rough scan is "matched" to an existing high-res model on an all-licensing-settled server, so you can download and "print" all the copies you want for private use.
- reustle 14y ago> so you can buy, download and "print". If we're already scanning it, why not just replicate the original?
- grabeh 14y agoI believe in the same way as iTunes Match works, you would be legitimising your own creations to ensure that they were free from potential infringement actions.
- ktizo 14y agoPrinting for your own use is non-infringing anyway, and a 3d model of an object is effectively a drawing of it and so therefore the creator of the drawing holds the copyright, not the holder of any patent of the object. Copyrights can be infringed, but only where there is copyrighted detail, which is usually only an issue for things like toys and fashion.
- grabeh 14y ago> Printing for your own use is non-infringing This may be true in relation to fair use/fair dealing exceptions, but not as a general statement. > 3D model is effectively a drawing of it They may hold the copyright in it, but it can still infringes a pre-existing third party design right. > Copyrights can be infringed, but only where there is copyrighted detail I don't understand what you mean by this. If something attracts the protection of copyright, it will be infringed if the usual tests are satisfied - where does 'copyrighted detail' come into it?
- 14y ago
- grabeh 14y agoThe article suggests that it is preferable to have an action under patent infringement rather than under copyright infringement because patents expire. I think this is a gross over-simplification of the matter as if I were advising a manufacturer I would prefer to go down the route of copyright infringement as it would be a cheaper option than full-scale patent litigation. Although this would be with the slight caveat that copyright infringement requires evidence of actual copying and will not succeed if independent creation can be shown. I think it essentially still boils down to whether copying in this instance has actually taken place. In the instant case, I would love to see a comparison of the Games Workshop creations and the third party's creations. My guess is the third party works were inspired by GW rather than being substantially the same. In any event, it seems heavy handed of GW. I would say overall that patent references are a red herring. In the instant case, GW will not hold a patent over each of the models of course. The focus on 3-D printing is interesting, but again it boils down to whether copying has taken place. I would also add that under UK law, this would also be potentially dealt with under design rights law where protection is far more limited. In fact, because of mass production nature of the models, a claim would have to based on design right law rather than copyright, as they would not qualify as sculptures in my view.
- mellis 14y agoFor more details, see "It Will Be Awesome if They Don't Screw it Up: 3D Printing" by Michael Weinberg: http://www.publicknowledge.org/it-will-be-awesome-if-they-dont-screw-it-up http://www.publicknowledge.org/it-will-be-awesome-if-they-do...
- brohee 14y agoAlso "Rule 34" by Charles Stross is a pretty good novel about some of the consequences of personal 3D printing being pushed underground by regulation.
- GenericAlias 14y agoDon't forget "Makers" by Cory Doctorow, which discusses some of the legal implications of personal 3D printing as both an attraction and as a way of cheaply producing a variety of things. http://craphound.com/makers/download/ http://craphound.com/makers/download/
- Sukotto 14y agoAlso Cory Doctorow's 2007 short story "Printcrime" http://craphound.com/?p=573 http://craphound.com/?p=573
- mistercow 14y agoI get depressed whenever I read about these people who get bitten by the DMCA and then don't do the 5 minutes of internet research needed to figure out how to fight it. It sounds to me like this guy had a clear case of DMCA abuse. If he designed the models himself, from scratch, then the best claim Games Workshop could have against him would be trademark infringement, and that's not what the DMCA is for. Therefore, all he has to do is send Thingiverse a counter-notification and, unless Games Workshop files a lawsuit (which they almost certainly won't), Thingiverse will restore the content in 14 days (they are required to do this in order to receive safe harbor protection under the DMCA). Chilling Effects even has a page for automatically generating these counter-notifications, so there's really no excuse for not protecting yourself from abuse: http://www.chillingeffects.org/dmca/counter512.pdf http://www.chillingeffects.org/dmca/counter512.pdf
- Anderkent 14y agoExcept you're a single person and they're this scary huge corporation. If they do sue, what are you going to do? Not many are willing to take that risk.
- mistercow 14y agoBut see, that's the same boat we were in before we had the DMCA. It's a problem that there's a two-week blackout on your stuff if someone files a takedown notice, but it does protect you from being sued right off the bat. In other words, if he's unwilling to risk filing the counter-notice, then without the DMCA, he wouldn't (or shouldn't) have been willing to risk uploading the models at all. But to answer your rhetorical question, if they do sue, you contact groups like the EFF and ask for help. (Better yet, contact them before filing the counter-notification). They would likely be happy to work to establish a good precedent in a novel situation like this.
- grabeh 14y agoI think it would be useful to see the his models and relevant GW models side-by-side to assess whether any similarities are present. He has obviously had sight of GW models which would allow GW to argue a form of copying has taken place. Also, contrast this story with the outcry over EA's alleged copying of GW models albeit digitally. http://www.reddit.com/r/gaming/comments/s4s7f/tank_in_new_cc_mmo_is_a_baneblade_from_40k/ http://www.reddit.com/r/gaming/comments/s4s7f/tank_in_new_cc...
- zemo 14y agothe article fails to mention the food industry, despite the fact that the French Culinary Institute is very publicly developing food printers. You can imagine how Nabisco will feel when you can download the plans to print out Oreos in your own home.
- HeyLaughingBoy 14y agoHow do they feel knowing that I can bake them at home right now? http://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/oreo-cookies-recipe/index.html http://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/oreo-cookies-recipe/index...
- ktizo 14y agoI think of this as more of Patent Law's 3d Printing Morass.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]