4 ms·
The problem with such services is, the moment they rear their heads just above the obscure line to even an iota of popularity, they get blocked, blacklisted and
by Brajeshwar 2y ago
The problem with such services is, the moment they rear their heads just above the obscure line to even an iota of popularity, they get blocked, blacklisted and what not.
For those who own their own domain for emails, there are multiple ways of doing it - aliases, temporary IDs, filters, etc. Or use such services' backbone/infrastructure that can route the emails but you own the domain.
`20240523@example.com` is valid for today.
- mikae1 2y ago> The problem with such services is, the moment they rear their heads just above the obscure line to even an iota of popularity, they get blocked, blacklisted and what not. I never ran into that problem with https://temp-mail.org https://temp-mail.org. They cycle domains constantly.
- jasode 2y ago>I never ran into that problem with https://temp-mail.org https://temp-mail.org. They cycle domains constantly. You didn't run into that problem with temp-mail.org because you happen to use them on websites that don't bother blocking disposable email addresses -- or -- they do try to block them but use simplistic domain name checks. But cycling domain names isn't enough to fool the more sophisticated disposable/throwaway email address detectors (especially the paid services) because they use extra heuristics of checking DNS MX records ip addresses. E.g. temp-mail.org assigned the following random addresses "bob531@mcatag.com" and "alice8224@javnoi.com". Both of those domains are easily detected as throwaway emails because they both share the same MX ip 24.199.65.21 : - https://verifymail.io/domain/mcatag.com https://verifymail.io/domain/mcatag.com - https://verifymail.io/domain/javnoi.com https://verifymail.io/domain/javnoi.com On the other hand, the "@mcatag.com", "@javnoi.com", etc used by temp-mail.org is good enough to get past the websites that copy&paste the code from these StackOverflow answers that just use simplistic string matching : https://stackoverflow.com/questions/10976706/how-to-block-disposable-email-addresses-in-your-websites-registration-form https://stackoverflow.com/questions/10976706/how-to-block-di... It all depends on how much effort and cost the websites want to put into blocking disposable email addresses.
- ccbikai 2y agoIf they use Cloudflare's Email Routing, the MX IP is more difficult to detect
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nubela 2y ago[dead]
- ronnier 2y agohttps://temp-mail.org/ https://temp-mail.org/ Is one of the harder ones to block. The use unique domains with unique Mx records and cycle through ip addresses. All seem to be on digital ocean though
- SebastianKra 2y agoIt seems to me that fewer and fewer websites actually bother to block these domains. Even if you go through all that extra trouble to maintain a list of banned domains, the user can still just whip out a Hide-My-Email address ending in @icloud.com.
- pquki4 2y agoThey could end in @privaterelay.appleid.com which is... easy to block.
- SebastianKra 2y agoOnly those emails generated by Sign In With Apple AFAIK
- iforgotmysocks 2y agoI don't think sites have problem with alias emails like iCloud Hide My Email. The issue is when they are used for creating spam accounts.
- evantbyrne 2y agoDo any HN commenters here know of any maintained lists of throwaway email domains?
- al_borland 2y agoIn my experience this seems to be true. For a while it seemed throw away emails were pointless to try and they would all be blocked. But over the past couple years I’ve had a lot of success using mailinator, which is probably one of the better known services which has been around for a long time.
- ronnier 2y agoYup. I just added this domain to our disposable list for one of the worlds largest social media apps.
- mike31fr 2y agoTo those who wonder which social media app Ronnie is talking about, that's Snapchat
- ruffrey 2y agoThe temp email services which support custom domains help. For example, Mailsac.com. But it has pivoted to more focus as a dev and qa platform.