4 ms·
So Microsoft will sign just about any bootloader for a one-off fee of $99? What's to stop me setting up a legit-looking company, writing a fake bootloader, get
by rwmj 14y ago
So Microsoft will sign just about any bootloader for a one-off fee of $99? What's to stop me setting up a legit-looking company, writing a fake bootloader, getting it signed, then adding malware to Windows? If the key is blacklisted, I'll just sign up for another one.
The whole idea of secure booting on hardware that you don't physically control is ridiculous anyway. You're trusting everything in that chain of software, from the bootloader, through the OS, through to every ring 0 driver, to not contain any exploitable bug. We know how well that worked out, just look at consoles & Android.
Microsoft aren't stupid. They know this isn't going to provide real security. I think the intention is (a) prevent people easily repurposing machines to run Linux, (b) provide a sop to Big Content, (c) set expectations that you don't own the hardware you bought.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tzs 14y ago> I think the intention is (a) prevent people easily repurposing machines to run Linux Serious question: are there really many people who • know enough to take a Windows machine, obtain a Linux boot CD or boot USB drive, do whatever voodoo is required to make the computer boot from that instead of from the hard disk, and then go through the Linux install, but who cannot easily • figure out how to invoke the BIOS settings menu and change the secure boot option from "enabled" to "disabled" ? I understand that Linux is getting friendlier to non-techies, and many people report success in getting Grandma using Linux, but in almost all of these stories they installed Linux for Grandma. They did not just toss her a CD and say "try this!".
- rwmj 14y agoIt's an extra step in the process. Plus if you're dual booting, you have to switch the BIOS back and forth every time you switch between "secure" Windows 8 and Linux.