3 ms·
Another US state repeals law that protected ISPs from municipal competition
- ranger_danger 2y agoMinnesota, because it was too hard to put in the title apparently.
- dvaun 2y agoSubmissions generally use the title of the source article.
- jacobgkau 2y agoYeah, Ars could have (and should have) put it in the title, though.
- SoftTalker 2y agoThey want you to click through and find out.
- jvanderbot 2y agoMinnesota resident. The smaller the ISP, the better the service and support. My in-laws in a town of 3k have more reliable Internet at their lake cabin, and faster, than I did in the city. I was very excited when competition arrived. I now pay 1/2 the price for symmetric gigabit that's solid as a rock. Xfinity is a joke - they'll practically force you to use their equipment, which has a public WiFi access point that any Xfinity customer can use. Why? No idea.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- theendisney4 2y ago> The new language says cities and towns may "not discriminate in favor of the municipality's own communications facilities Why not? Imho private isps should be forbidden if municipalitees want to diy. Just like the previous law. All this honesty and fairness is really not deserved.
- SpaghettiCthulu 2y agoYou really want to give the government a monopoly on internet connectivity?
- theendisney4 2y agoWith some well crafted requirements. Have someone independently compare it to a private offer. If they fail everyone involved gets fired. The question to ask imho is if an isp (or any privatized service) can just be allowed to go bankrupt. Can people live without internet? Or is it something that needs to work?
- from-nibly 2y agoFairness is not something you strive for because someone deserves it. It's because it's the only way to run a stable society.
- SoftTalker 2y agoWhile I favor competition, I have no faith the the ability of municipalites to run anything. And they exempt themselves when it suits them (for example, where I live it's illegal to hire a private hauler to pick up your garbage. You must pay the city to do it, and it's quite expensive compared to what people outside the city pay). They recently contracted with a company to provide "municipal" internet in competition with Comcast, AT&T and another small local provider. The fallout of that is lineal drilling through people's yards as they run conduits for their fiber. The number of sewer lines, water lines, and gas lines that have been punctured is astonishing. People are living for months with mud piles in their yards from the drills and little flags all over the place from the utility locating services. If Comcast were doing all this people would be screaming from the hilltops, but they put up with it because it's "municipal".
- cyanydeez 2y agoSounds like you just don't trust groups of people.
- SoftTalker 2y agoI don't trust groups of people who can legally reach into my wallet and who vote on their own salaries.
- from-nibly 2y agoAmen
- olsonjeffery 2y agoSorry your society has poor controls on public service. Sounds like a problem with the constitution; too bad it makes you sound like a crank.
- from-nibly 2y agoThat does sound frustrating. I'm pretty anti government in general, but one thing my city has done is make the best internet service I've ever had. My IP address hasnt changed in the 7 years I've been here and I don't even pay for static IP. Plus I get symmetric gigabit for $70. The profits are required to be rolled back into infrastructure upgrades. That's why we even got fiber. They just had a huge pile of money lying around and said "I guess we'll upgrade everyone to fiber". They already had conduit installed because of good city planning so it was just upgrading switches and running wires for the most part. (I'm sure it was more than that, please don't hang me by my hyperbole)