2 ms·
> small diesel engine to charge the battery as needed. Fuel is an insanely high cost for farmers, and the complexity of the ICE systems means high maintenance
by bluGill 2y ago
> small diesel engine to charge the battery as needed. Fuel is an insanely high cost for farmers, and the complexity of the ICE systems means high maintenance and repair costs too.
That is what they want, but that isn't something they can get. A 100 horsepower tractor will be expected to deliver 100 horsepower for 15 hours without stopping (it is common to eat while driving, though you will stop for a bathroom break here and there). That means you need to have a 100 horsepower engine. Contrast a Tesla which is rated at 600 horsepower - but realistically only can give you that for a few seconds before you are at speed and then only needs to deliver about 20 horsepower. The batteries in a Tesla would run that 100 horsepower tractor for maybe an hour, so a 20 horsepower engine in a Tesla could easially extend you a lot of range.
I work for John Deere. I don't speak for the company. I can tell you that we are looking at electric for small tractors - there are a lot of people who only use small tractors for a couple hours per day (or less). We have hybrid tractors for some applications, but there are others that hybird isn't useful. The rules of chemistry tell us that a battery will never be useful for large tractors, and even small tractors it is questionable if batteries can ever be good enough to go all day (if you look at our electric mower the dealer is required to examine your lot to make sure it isn't too big). We have tried things like put a 1km cord on a tractor - I don't know what the status of that is.
- eagerpace 2y agoBig, cheap batteries. Tractors don’t care about weight or speed. They don’t need fancy chemistries. I’d also think they could find a way to deploy a massive solar halo-type array since they’re working in big empty fields.
- Arrath 2y agoTractors may not care about weight, but soil does. Current tractors cause soil compaction issues in farm fields, even heavier weight-inefficient-battery laden tractors would be that much worse.
- voisin 2y ago> The rules of chemistry tell us that a battery will never be useful for large tractors, and even small tractors it is questionable if batteries can ever be good enough to go all day How can batteries work in a transport truck hauling massive weight long distances but we can’t figure it out for tractors? How can batteries work in mining equipment and logging trucks (charged by small ICE engines on board) for long hours per day, not for tractors? I am having trouble understanding what the fundamental differences are.
- bluGill 2y agoThose are not small enines in mining. Smaller than non hybride but still large. Trucks are not common yet, and trucks using the full power an engine can provide most of the time.